The field of late antique family history has been developing over the last fifteen years, but as Badel and Settipani note, relatively little has been done on the subject of familial ‘strategies’ from that era (x–xi). This lacuna is perhaps more pronounced given that ample studies exist for the classical age. To that end, the present volume is drawn from a colloquium held in 2009 on this subject, focusing mostly (though not exclusively) on the fourth through seventh centuries c.e. The contributions assembled here collectively examine the strategies that the élite in particular (but again, not exclusively) deployed to ensure the prominence, aggrandizement and most importantly the survival of their families. The nineteen papers, along with a substantial conclusion, consider not simply common tactics employed by individuals and families as a whole, but also focus on contemporary challenges to endurance and notoriety — especially Christianization, Germanic migrations and settlement, and the establishment of Constantinople as a new focal point for imperial and aristocratic prestige.
The collection's division follows that of the conference. The initial papers concentrate on memorialization practices as a mechanism for achieving familial prominence. A second group examines the legal and religious means for promoting and continuing the élite family's status. A third set look at generational concerns. The final contributions to the volume question the distinctions between survival and familial advancement. Sometimes, these delineations are not so clear. For example, Sylvie Joye's quite readable longue durée analysis of raptus marriage in the context of father-daughter relations and broader familial goals might very well fit into several of these groups. As a whole, however, this occasional conceptual fuzziness is not really an issue.
As the collection deals mostly with élites, it is unsurprising that genealogical and onomastic studies feature prominently. The temptation for historians to see aristocratic conceits as simple vanity, as Christian Settipani notes in his own study about the head of the Academy in Athens c. a.d. 500 (58), is largely rejected here. Instead, the authors focus on what functions specific pretentions served. For example, the polyonomous practices amongst Constantinople's aristocrats in the fifth and sixth centuries, as Avshalom Lanaido argues, can be understood in the context of the ‘new man’ status of many Eastern élites. The fusion of late antique naming practices (à la Flavius), Christian piety and important patronal links all served to create a unique onomastic eminence for an aristocracy who could not hope to compete with the pedigrees of Western notables. These observations are all good, even if not terribly surprising.
Various studies on the rôle of marriage are also understandably stressed. Luce Pietri, for example, argues that although there was an awareness of legal and religious challenges to certain marriages in Late Antiquity, their influence was largely subordinated to the traditional interests of Gaul's local and imperial élite (an observation already noted by many, including this reviewer). Compare this to Christel Freu, who challenges Évelyne Patlagean's famous 1978 article stressing the growth of endogamous marriages in the East at the end of the fourth century. She demonstrates that in the case of Egypt, élites pursued exogamous and endogamous unions with no particular favouritism.
A third group deal with generational issues. Michael Satlow's contribution on marriage and the connection to natal families amongst Jews in Roman Palestine questions broader contemporary Rabbinic teaching that insisted on a legal, economic and affective split between a woman and her parents after marriage. Béatrice Caseau's piece perhaps most directly deals with the rôle of Christianization and family by examining the strategies and conditions for consecrating a child — usually a daughter — to the Church. The option not only impacted upon families and inheritances, but also upon civil and canon law.
A prevalent feature and slight weakness throughout the volume as a whole is a somewhat limited geographical focus. Southern Gaul in particular is over-represented. Constantinople and Syria also fare a bit too well. To a degree, this is a product of the dependence on literary sources, but these spatial limitations contrast with the variety of subject matter and the collection's broad temporal sweep.
Mireille Corbier (appropriately) ties things together at the end with the slightly anticlimactic observation that familial strategies as a whole were most influenced by Christianization, ‘barbarian’ integration with indigenous ‘Roman’ peoples and the political disruptions of Late Antiquity. Her perspective is undoubtedly correct, but seems less significant than some of her smaller methodological observations. For example, one thing she notes is the paucity of anthropological perspectives in the collection (or at least of anthropological terminology; 394). In the end, Corbier notes correctly that each case study must be placed carefully in their respective temporal, cultural and spatial milieus (407) — but that the sources should be treated holistically. Fair enough, even if such warnings also limit her overall assessment.
In general, the family stemmata are easy to read (with the exception of Settipani's dizzying ‘la géniologié d'Hègias’ (78–9)). The end matter includes indices for ancient individuals, peoples and places, and modern authors. General subject and passage indices would have been useful. Two abstracts seem to be missing.
The editors and authors are to be congratulated on the generally high quality of scholarship here. Taken as a set of varied studies, this is a useful, if not entirely ground-breaking addition to the growing historiography of late antique family studies. In the end, the value of the volume overall is less significant than its constituent parts.
