In The Drama of Scripture, Craig G. Bartholomew and Michael W. Goheen introduce the reader to the Bible as a sweeping portrayal of God's redemptive work in history. The authors have three emphases they wish to communicate: the comprehensive scope of God's redemptive work in creation; the believer's own place within the biblical story; and the centrality of mission throughout. Building on N. T. Wright's metaphor of the Bible as a drama, the text is arranged thematically according to creation, sin and redemption, and is subdivided into six acts and an interlude. As an introductory text to the subject, the book is intended for first-year university students as well as Bible study groups.
The six-act schema is developed in conversation with Wright's work, augmenting his five-act model with a sixth, new creation, arguing that it, not the incarnation (as in Wright), is the denouement of scripture. Thus, acts 1 to 3 (creation, sin and Israel) span the Old Testament. The interlude provides a survey of the intertestamental period, with acts 4 to 6 (Christ, church and new creation) unfolding the New Testament.
Select biblical books receive cursory attention, highlighting the events and subjects that give substance to the overarching narrative. Of course, with the narrative driving the analysis, some books are given more consideration than others. So, for instance, most of fourteen pages are granted to Exodus, while Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy combined are addressed across parts of six.
The story of Jesus is the climax of the grand biblical narrative, according to the authors, orientating how we read the rest of scripture. Christ is the one who shows us the true nature of salvation. The Old Testament, then, is the story of God moving towards this goal with the people of Israel, seeking to fulfil his promise of redemption and restoration. With the end of Jesus' earthly mission, the church's mission begins. The story is not over with the Bible; it is our story, one continuing into the present, and the authors urge us to allow this story to shape us, not vice versa, and to resist the temptation to use the Bible for systematic proof-texting, or as a source for ethical or devotional guidance, at the expense of its unity.
Keeping the book's intended audience in mind may allay concerns over issues either ignored or glossed over, such as when the authors acknowledge in an endnote that they are aware of arguments against the unity of scripture but point readers to a scholarly essay elsewhere for their response. Genre questions generally receive light treatment if addressed at all, the genre of Genesis 1 being an exception.
The authors are not ensnared by ‘behind the text’ issues, keeping attention on the story. However, even if we agree about the value of narrative in reading the Bible, one wonders whether its limitations are sufficiently accounted for. For instance, mention is made of the different ways the Christian story is encountered: liturgy, creeds, hymns and sermons. Yet over and above these, the Bible is posited as the ‘authoritative source’ for the story. In elucidating the biblical text, the authors often make use of socio-historical material, which becomes, next to the concept ‘narrative’ itself, the primary reserve they tap. Still, what of those other elements from the church's life? Even if it is granted that the Bible is the authoritative source for the Christian story, how much is lost when much of the multifaceted canonical body of the church is marginalised? To what extent can the church really come to understand its story without reference to, say, the Nicene Creed? Without these, even if we see scripture as a narrative whole, what constitutes a Christian reading of that narrative?
This is not to dismiss either narrative or socio-historical study but to question their priority and explanatory power. The authors offer that ‘covenant’ and ‘kingdom of God’ are the key ideas to answering how one sees the Bible's storied unity, but that is not quite the point. It is claimed early on that ‘All of the great Christian confessions’ state ‘that scripture is the norm for faith and life, the great rule and source of guidance’; this is what ‘orthodox Christianity has always maintained’, and the real controversy has been ‘how scripture functions to direct faith and life’ (p. 21). Yet Irenaeus, when confronted with heretical interpretations of the church's scripture, posited the rule of truth and apostolic tradition, contained in scripture but not reducible to it, as the hermeneutical key to correct interpretation. Likewise, Athanasius contended the Arians were wrong in their use of scripture because they did not know how to read it. Scripture itself was not in question; the question was how to read in a way faithful to apostolic teaching.
My concern is that an inadvertent result of the authors' presentation may be to reinforce the old problematic of how to relate scripture and tradition. Perhaps the literary concept ‘narrative’, when combined with ‘authority’ and pressed too far, encourages a sort of postmodern biblicism, promoting scripture above a greater constellation within which it is supposed to fit properly. More needs to be said about how other dimensions of the church's life relate to the Bible, for without them, the Christian story is incomplete.
It is nevertheless the case that the reader indeed comes away with a more developed sense of the Bible's overall coherence; in that regard, this is a very helpful book. Illustrated maps and models are occasionally employed, helping give concreteness to the narrative. A web address is also provided for access to supplementary material. In all, Bartholomew and Goheen make a much-needed contribution to the literature, providing a text that is readable and informative, capable of reaching a wide audience.
