The paucity of evidence that is available on the subject of West African living standards in the precolonial period, and the heavily politicised nature of the surrounding debate, present those interested in the subject with a doubly difficult challenge. By combining existing qualitative sources with his own quantitative analysis of prices and wages, Klas Rönnbäck has risen to that challenge and, in the process, made an important contribution to the economic history of precolonial West Africa.
Rönnbäck has three clear aims: to examine evidence of factor markets for labour; to measure the living standards of labourers on the Gold Coast, both historically and in comparative global perspective; and, to consider how the slave trade may have impacted the labour market.
The book begins with an outline of the approaches that have provided the dominant understanding of African living standards. A second chapter reviews previous research on the Gold Coast, while Chapter Three introduces the primary written and manuscript sources. The study draws heavily on published travel accounts and the correspondence of the Royal African Company (RAC) and its successors and the Danish West Indian-Guinea Company. But the author has also collected unpublished RAC data on the prices of African foodstuffs and European goods sold on the Gold Coast, and on wage payments that were made to European staff, free African labourers, and African slaves working in RAC forts and castles in that area. This amounts to over 14,000 price observations and nearly 37,000 wage payments during the period 1699–1760, although the payments cover only a limited number of workers. The remaining chapters form the core of the analysis, examining the African work ethic, work, and wages; the domestic market for goods; and, housing and material wealth.
The most significant contribution of the book is the attempt to calculate the living standards of labourers and how they changed over time. Rönnbäck has chosen to apply the method pioneered by Robert Allen for the study of Europe and Asia, in which the real wage is estimated by reference to nominal wages and the cost of living. The method allows a ‘subsistence ratio’ to be calculated wherever there is information on local wages and prices. There are a number of problems with this. Applying Allen's method involves making a number of major assumptions, including calorific requirements, the source of family income, and the average size of the family, for example, not all of which sit well with the African evidence. In addition, working within a framework that uses material variables alone to drive its analysis of living standards is unable to evaluate fully the complexity of those standards given the coexistence and overlapping nature of unfree status and unfree labour that were ongoing features of the African workforce.
That said, Rönnbäck's findings are extremely thought provoking. His research confirms the presence of a factor market in labour in the precolonial period and suggests it was undermined by the development of the slave trade from the later seventeenth century. Although in 1675 the subsistence ratios for unskilled labourers on the Gold Coast were well below those of northwestern Europe, they were comparable with other parts of Europe and above those found in parts of Asia. On the Gold Coast at least, before the emergence of any significant slave trading activity, the labouring population was not especially poor. Those ratios had fallen by 1725, however, just as they did in Europe and elsewhere. Yet, what marked the Gold Coast as unusual was the size of the decline. Though reluctant to make any direct causal connection to the slave trade, Rönnbäck notes a number of contemporaneous effects: on the one hand, the trade increased demand for foodstuffs and raised their cost relative to wages; on the other, while the violence and disruption that accompanied the trade from the later seventeenth century increased urban migration and placed significant competitive pressure on unskilled workers, the RAC's decision to upskill their own enslaved workers at around the same time reduced the need for skilled craftsmen. Consequently, both skilled and unskilled labourers saw a fall in their subsistence ratios.
The author is aware of the significant problems created by his evidence and methodology. Throughout the book, he is clearly indicates the speculative nature of his findings. This makes the book accessible as well as provocative; it also reveals exactly how much we still do not know. Through a sensitive and meticulous examination of travelogues, company correspondence, and RAC accounts, Rönnbäck has provided the most detailed and vibrant account to date of living standards in precolonial West Africa. This welcome book will surely become the starting point for all those interested in this subject.
