Jean Elson's Gross Misbehavior and Wickedness profiles the tumultuous union between James Wilson Grimes Walker and Nina Chinn Walker, a high-society couple who wed in 1897 and legally ended their marriage in 1916 after seven years of divorce proceedings. This dramatic courtroom battle unfolded amid rapidly transforming ideas about marriage and divorce in the Progressive Era. As Americans came to embrace the modern notion that marriage should provide emotional support and personal satisfaction, divorce became an increasingly popular remedy for marital distress. Rising divorce rates reflected, in great part, affluent women's desires to separate from men who were adulterous, physically abusive, and cruel. But as Nina Chinn Walker's story indicates, the effort to prove these allegations could be extremely difficult, costly, and controversial.
The most compelling chapters of Elson's book take place in the Rhode Island Superior Court in Newport, where Nina Chinn Walker pursued her divorce in several phases. Her initial 1909 effort was unsuccessful due to her lack of long-term residency in Rhode Island. In 1911, she submitted a second petition for divorce on grounds of her husband's cruelty and adultery. Specifically, Nina's lawyers emphasized James's emotional detachment from his wife and their four children, his contraction of gonorrhea, and his alleged affair with housekeeper Mabel Cochrane to justify Nina's exit from the marriage. Though Judge Darius Baker hoped the couple would be able to set aside their differences, he hesitantly granted Nina a divorce for separate maintenance—or a legal separation—when a reconciliation appeared impossible.
The case found new life after this initial verdict when two female physicians examined Mabel Cochrane, both reaching the conclusion that she was a virgin and thus casting major doubt on allegations of a sexual relationship with James Walker. In response to this revelation, the Rhode Island Supreme Court authorized a new trial in the superior court. This trial, which featured testimony from twenty-five physicians, led Judge Charles Falconer Stearns to overturn Baker's ruling in December of 1913. While Stearns remained suspicious that the relationship between James Walker and Mabel Cochrane had been inappropriate, he also believed that the two had not engaged in sexual intercourse and that evidence of adultery was circumstantial at best. In March of 1915, Nina Chinn Walker responded to this blow by filing a motion to reargue her divorce suit, insisting that James had practiced “gross misbehavior and wickedness repugnant to and in violation of the marriage covenant” (232). With this last-ditch effort, Nina's lawyer's evoked vague language from Rhode Island's divorce statute to win a case that could not quite be proven on grounds of adultery alone. Judge Elmer Rathbun was persuaded by this roundabout strategy, granting Nina an absolute divorce in December of 1916.
Elson's account illustrates many of the complexities surrounding marriage and divorce law in the Progressive Era. Though the ambiguities of Rhode Island's “gross misbehavior and wickedness” clause ultimately helped Nina Chinn Walker to end her marriage, the years of litigation preceding this outcome indicate just how challenging it was for petitioners to prove adultery and cruelty in the decades preceding no-fault divorce. Throughout her detailed narration of this saga, Elson also raises fascinating questions about the application and interpretation of evidence in early twentieth-century courtrooms. Her discussion of the intimate physical examinations performed on Mabel Cochrane to resolve the question of her virginity—and thus to disprove allegations of an extramarital affair—carries startling implications about the vulnerability of non-elite women's bodies to invasive medical procedures in family court proceedings. Meanwhile, Elson's emphasis on the debates surrounding the admissibility of Nina Chinn Walker's hand-copied letters as evidence pushes readers to consider the reliability of many of the sources that informed Progressive Era judicial culture.
In illustrating the many layers of this elaborate case, Elson presents a narrative that is consistently readable and engaging. But her attention to detail can also work to the book's detriment. Elson is meticulous in recounting the twists and turns of the various trials, including thorough accounts of witness testimony and legal strategy. She also offers prolonged discussion of the individuals involved in this case, including an Epilogue that describes the lives of various Walkers and Chinns in the years following the divorce. This material will speak to readers who are interested, above all, in the specific families in question. But Elson's decision to contextualize her book with extended focus on the lives of a few characters limits its potential impact and reflects a missed opportunity to dig more deeply into the social and political fabric of the era. While Elson's brief introduction does provide a summary of shifting popular ideas about divorce in the early twentieth century, the vast majority of her book relates explicitly to James and Nina Walker's personal struggles. Elson is so invested in laying out the details of this marriage and divorce that she rarely considers the insights her narrative can lend to readers’ understandings of marriage and divorce as broad historical concepts; or the legal, cultural, economic, and gendered implications of the vivid account she provides.
Some of the issues here are source related. Elson has assembled an impressive array of news reports, court records, and family documents to inform the story. In prioritizing these rich primary texts, Elson engages less effectively with historical scholarship on gender, sexuality, marriage, and divorce in the Progressive Era. Along these lines, citations are scarce in many parts of the book, making it a challenge for readers to distinguish verifiable fact from speculation; this is a particular problem when it comes to the quotations and thoughts Elson attributes to her subjects without citation. These shortcomings do not negate the power of Elson's narrative, to be sure, but they do lessen the overall contribution of Gross Behavior and Wickedness to Progressive Era historiography.
