This is a milestone in the exciting revival of serious Victorian opera that has been rapidly gaining strength over the last 15 years or so. Victorian Opera Northwest has led the way. Its president and chief conductor, Richard Bonynge, who prepared this edition, has established a style and method that attract both the right kind of singer and the sort of audience that is no longer blinded by silly old nonsense about Victorian Britain being a ‘land without music’. The working principles seem to be as follows: minimize or do without the spoken dialogue; discreetly edit the sung words, making them more intelligible to a modern audience; adopt vocal styles now current for Italian opera of the period, allowing ornaments and brief cadenzas; and feel free to make numerous and frequent cuts of repeated passages, and of sections that seem too long or uninspired.
Some of these principles go beyond what would be acceptable for an established opera like Freischütz, Don Pasquale or Il trovatore. The cuts, in particular, substitute our own tastes for those of the composer’s time. The same thing happened in the early Handel opera revivals of the 1920s and 30s, when some of the arias and most of the da-capos were omitted because they might have bored the audiences of the day. Now that Handel’s operas are part of the regular repertory, the da-capos are back in full force. Perhaps the same thing will happen one day with these Victorian operas. Certainly there are some cuts here that undermine the composer’s plan, and the absence of the dialogue often obscures the plot. On the other hand, the confident singing in a style that makes one think of, say, Verdi, combined with excellent English diction and masterly orchestral accompaniment, does wonders in restoring the prestige and standing of this once-despised music.
Balfe, though not the best of the early Victorian opera composers, was by far the most successful. He wrote no less than 21 English operas, several of which were acclaimed not only all round the English-speaking world but in various languages in major European cities, and he even ventured to compose French and Italian operas himself. His success was due chiefly to his melodic gift, enhanced by his second career as a singer. It comes through especially in simple strophic songs or ballads. The most famous of all his operas, The Bohemian Girl (1843), survived far into the twentieth century, and was recorded in Dublin under Bonynge in 1991. It owed its fame above all to two ballads, ‘When other lips’ and ‘I dreamt that I dwelt in marble halls’. Much the same could be said of many other operas of the time. But it is a mistake to despise the operatic ballad. It was, after all, the one element that distinguished Anglo-Irish opera from its Continental contemporaries, and it survived triumphantly into Gilbert and Sullivan’s era and beyond it into musical comedy.
The theme of Satanella, as its subtitle declares, is the redemptive power of love. Satanella (soprano) is a demoness, and is ultimately in the power of the Devil (Arimanes, bass), who has ordered her to ensnare the pleasure-seeking hero, Count Rupert (tenor). Neither she nor Rupert can win much sympathy from us. He gambles away his entire fortune in a single scene (made even shorter by cuts) and is consequently deserted by his fiancée Stella (mezzo). He and his foster-sister Lelia (soprano) fall in love. He decides to marry her, but Satanella also falls for him and plans to replace Lelia at the marriage ceremony, having had her abducted by pirates. The ruse is discovered at the last minute. Arimanes is furious at Satanella’s disobedience and gives her 30 days to yield Rupert to him. In another bidding scene, Lelia is offered for sale at a Tunis slave market; Rupert is outbid by a wealthy Vizier (who does not sing and hence is not in evidence on this recording). Almost to the end, Satanella is determined to steal Rupert from Lelia. She disguises herself as a Sultana of Tunis to ‘weave her charm’, and Rupert sells his soul to her, on condition that he can spend his remaining days with Lelia, who is released and rushes into his arms. Their midnight wedding is interrupted by Satanella, who reminds them of the contract. Ultimately she gives way to the power of (Lelia’s) love. At the end there is a suggestion of Christian influence through the sudden appearance of a rosary and an organ; and in the last minute of the opera Lelia’s wedding to Rupert is completed, to the fury of Arimanes and his demons.
The frequent changes of mood and motive, and even of outward appearance in Satanella’s disguises, make it difficult to follow the story without the dialogue, and with only the briefest outline in the accompanying booklet. For instance the role of Hortensius, tutor to Count Rupert, never becomes clear, while the manservant Karl and even Stella seem irrelevant to the main plot.
There are some delightful tunes in Balfe’s score. One occurs already in the overture (originally written for his French opera L‘Étoile de Séville). Others are found in some charming ballads (not so labelled), such as ‘Oh! would she name the day’ for Karl, who is also in love with Lelia (disk 1, track 6). Rupert has two: ‘An angel form in dreams beheld’ (disk 1, track 12) with violin obbligato, and ‘No prize can fate on man bestow’ (disk 2, track 10), which is unusual in having a varied accompaniment for its second verse. Above all, the opera is distinguished by its memorable signature tune, ‘The Power of Love’, first sung by Satanella (disk 1, track 19) with beautiful accompaniments for flute, harp and (later) wordless chorus, as she falls in love with Rupert. It returns at key moments, and briefly at the very end, when the power of love has triumphed.
Balfe’s dramatic powers had improved in his later years, and they are at their best in his depiction of Arimanes and the invisible spirits (disk 1, track 7; disk 2, tracks 1–2). This is in total contrast to the scenes of love, with angular melodic lines and irregular rhythms, and even passages of genuine atonality; so is Rupert’s ‘Of life I have no care’ in the gambling scene (disk 1, track 5). The interrupted wedding scene at the end of Act 2 is also intensely dramatic, with thunderbolts and other horrors. So are the final scenes of Act 4. But elsewhere the composer chooses oddly inappropriate styles for scenes of tension or high drama: a polonaise for Arimanes’s curses (disk 1, track 7), a waltz for the pirate leader’s charge to his men (disk 1, track 13), a galop or fast polka for the slave market scene (disk 2, track 3). And although he often uses remote modulations for immediate effect, there are no larger tonal schemes of the kind that Edward Loder or Julius Benedict could muster for a sustained dramatic goal.
Sally Silver is an ideal choice for Satanella, and she seems equally at home in expressing love and fury. Her big scena introducing ‘The Power of Love’ is memorable, and her high notes, at last reaching a D, dominate the conclusions of concerted pieces in a most exciting way. The dramatic tenor Kang Wang is suitable as Count Rupert, who exhibits a wide variety of emotional states, while Catherine Carby as Lelia is consistently warm and expressive. Trevor Bowes’s sonorous bass well suits the totally negative Arimanes, though he has less power than one might wish in the lowest part of the register. In the minor roles Anthony Gregory, as Karl, stands out as a sweet-toned baritone with admirably intelligible diction, while Christine Tocci as Stella is effective showing jealous fury in her brief scene in Act 1. Bonynge has reduced the total length of the opera from a reported ‘over four hours’ to less than two, largely by his cuts, but also by his very brisk tempos.
Whatever minor faults one may find in the libretto, the music or the performance, the overall effect of this recording is overwhelmingly positive. It is a big step forward in making us familiar with the language, assumptions and achievements of the early Victorians in this grandest of musical forms. Now we can look forward to another first – a recording of Loder’s Raymond and Agnes, a work of true genius, produced by Retrospect Opera, with Bonynge again conducting. Let’s hope that we will soon reach a point where some of these operas begin to appear onstage in major houses.
