The relationships between international humanitarian law (IHL) and international human rights law (IHRL) are the subject of much ongoing legal analysis. Particular interest in this topic has arisen in recent years, as the delineation between peacetime and war has been complicated by changes in the nature of contemporary armed conflict—including the rise of transnational terrorism, the increase of non-international armed conflict and conflicts in urban settings, and the greater involvement of non-state actors, blurring the distinction between combatants and civilians. This collection of essays addresses different aspects of this multifaceted topic, with the contributions developed from a lecture series given as part of the Academy of European Law's annual summer course in international human rights law. The editor's introductory chapter frames the discussion elegantly through the musical metaphor of a pas de deux, an intricate dance for two. This lends a structure to the book, with its four parts organized as the musical movements typical of this form of dance—an “entrée”, “adagio”, “variations”, and a “coda”. Covering diverse issues, the individual contributions reprise the general theme in different ways, and, understandably, are not always in accord. The musical metaphor is therefore apposite for conveying the dynamic interactions both between the two areas of law and between the different contributions of the authors. As the editor explains, the book “enters an ongoing, fluid conversation”, which “explores the movements unfolding between” IHL and IHRL.
Part II, “Adagio” comprises three chapters, each examining some broad normative and theoretical issues regarding the interaction between the two areas of law. Yuval Shany discusses the tensions between a security-centred, IHL-based “armed conflict” paradigm and a human rights-centred “law enforcement” paradigm, in the so-called “war against terror”. Marco Sassóli builds on this through his examination of the IHL/IHRL interactions in a range of other allegedly new types of conflict, including asymmetric conflicts, conflicts in failed states, and UN peace operations. Marko Milanović examines critically the adequacy of existing legal mechanisms for resolving norm conflicts between IHL and IHRL. He argues that there are tools for norm conflict resolution and norm conflict avoidance, as well as situations where such conflicts may be unavoidable and unresolvable through the tools of legal interpretation. The incisive analysis in this standout chapter helps bring clarity to areas frequently left blurred or imprecise in much writing on the relationships between IHL and IHRL.
Part III, “Variations”, provides detailed analyses of the IHL/IHRL interplay in three specific contexts. The editor examines belligerent occupation in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, arguing that both IHL and IHRL are used to justify and normalize unlawful activity. Andrea Gioia then examines IHL/IHRL in the practice of the European Court of Human Rights, while Ana Filipa Vrdoljak discusses how IHL and IHRL have addressed the issue of cultural heritage. Finally, in the “Coda”, Paola Gaeta examines the relationships between IHL and IHRL in the area of compensation to victims of war crimes, while Christine Bell offers some different conceptualizations of the legal regimes for post-conflict accountability—including accountability both for violations during armed conflict and for violations by international actors with post-conflict responsibility for peace-building.
Reflecting their origins as a series of lectures, several of the chapters cover some of the same ground and could perhaps have been pared back somewhat to make the key arguments more concise. However, as the editor acknowledges, navigating forward on this topic is not a straightforward path, but rather, “a process wrought with interpretive twists and turns in the often turbulent waves of a multitude of competing narratives, shifting paradigms, polar doctrines, and a patchwork of governing norms”. Overall, the book makes very valuable contributions that take the debate forward on this important and challenging topic. As such, it will be useful for international law students, academics, and practitioners interested in the fields of IHL and IHRL.
