Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T06:29:39.545Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Finite-amplitude instabilities of thin internal wave beams: experiments and theory

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  07 October 2020

Boyu Fan
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA02139, USA
T. R. Akylas*
Affiliation:
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA02139, USA
*
†Email address for correspondence: trakylas@mit.edu

Abstract

A joint experimental and theoretical study is made of instability mechanisms of locally confined internal gravity wave beams in a stratified fluid. Using as forcing a horizontal cylinder that is oscillated harmonically in the direction of beam propagation makes it possible to generate coherent finite-amplitude internal wave beams whose spatial profile comprises no more than a single wavelength. For forcing amplitude above a certain threshold depending on the driving frequency, such thin wave beams are observed to undergo an instability that involves two subharmonic perturbations with wavepacket-like spatial structure. Although it bears resemblance to the triadic resonant instability (TRI) of small-amplitude sinusoidal waves, the present instability cannot be predicted by TRI theory as the primary wave is not nearly monochromatic, but instead contains broadband wavenumber spectrum. In contrast, the experimental observations are in good agreement with the predictions of a formal linear stability analysis based on Floquet theory. Finally, experimental evidence is presented that transverse beam variations induce a horizontal mean flow of the streaming type and greatly subdue the instability.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2020. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematics of the experimental set-up. (a) Side and transverse view of the wave tank and horizontal cylinder. The cylinder is harmonically oscillated at frequency $\omega _{0}$ and angle $\theta$ relative to the horizontal such that $\omega _{0}^{2} = N^{2}\sin ^{2}\theta$. The laser sheet is in the $xy$-plane at $z=4.3\ \textrm {cm}$. (b) Sketch of the uniform cylinder and (c) non-uniform cylinder used for the experiments. Dimensions are given in § 2. (d) Sketch of the generated wave beams (in grey), which reflect off the free surface and tank bottom. The dotted-line box shows the PIV window, with the primary beam of interest propagating from the upper right to the bottom left. The beam-oriented coordinate system $(\xi ,\eta ,\zeta )$ is defined by the along-beam, cross-beam and transverse horizontal coordinates, respectively.

Figure 1

Figure 2.(a) Horizontal ($x$) velocity for beam inclination angle $\theta =45{{}^{\circ }}$ and forcing amplitude $A/L= 0.45$ at $t=8T_{0}$ after start of forcing. The grey box corresponds to the region around the cylinder that is masked out. (b) Same as panel (a) but for $A/L = 0.63$. (c) Theoretical beam profile used in the linear stability analysis of § 5 to approximate the experimental beam in panel (b). (d) Same as panel (a) but at $t=36T_{0}$ after start of forcing. (e) Same as panel (d) but for $A/L = 0.63$. (f) Time series of the horizontal velocity for $A/L= 0.45$ at the location marked with the cross in panels (a,d). The vertical lines indicate the times $t=8T_{0}$ and $36T_{0}$. (g) Same as panel (f) but for $A/L= 0.63$ and at the location marked with the cross in panels (b,e).

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Spatially averaged time frequency spectra for the experiments shown in figure 2. The dotted line corresponds to the stable case at $A/L= 0.45$ (figure 2a,d) while the solid line corresponds to the unstable case at $A/L = 0.63$ (figure 2b,e). The subharmonic frequencies $\omega _{1}/N=0.26$ and $\omega _{2}/N=0.45$ are labelled. (b) Experimentally measured horizontal velocity field from figure 2(e), filtered at $\omega _{1}/N=0.26$. (c) Same as panel (b) but filtered at $\omega _{2}/N=0.45$. (d) Time frequency spectrum of the fastest-growing Floquet mode. The vertical dotted line marks the primary wave frequency at $\omega _{0}/N$. (e) Theoretically predicted spatial mode shape corresponding to the first peak (from the left) in the frequency spectrum in panel (d) at $\omega /N=0.24$. (f) Same as panel (e) but for the second peak at $\omega /N=0.47$. Dashed arrows in panels (b,c,e,f) indicate direction of phase propagation. Solid arrows in panel (b,c) indicate direction of group velocity $\boldsymbol {c}_{g}$. Velocity scale in panels (e,f) is normalized to have the same maximum velocity as in panels (b,c).

Figure 3

Figure 4.Phase diagram showing the dependence of the instability on the non-dimensional beam amplitude $U_{0}$ and beam angle $\theta$. Experimental configurations where instability was visibly apparent, ($\blacktriangle$); experimental configurations where instability was not visibly apparent but small instability peaks could be seen in the time frequency spectrum, ($+$); stable configurations, ($\circ$). Overlaid are contour lines of the (non-dimensional) real growth rate $\sigma \equiv \max _{i,\mu }\mathrm {Re}(\lambda _{i})$ as predicted by Floquet stability analysis.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Dependence of the instability growth rate $\sigma$ on the dimensionless transverse wavenumber $m$ as predicted by the Floquet analysis for beam angle (a) $\theta =35{{}^{\circ }}$, (b) $\theta =45{{}^{\circ }}$, (c) $\theta =55{{}^{\circ }}$; and dimensionless beam amplitude $U_{0} =0.15$ (dotted line), $U_{0} =0.20$ (dashed line), and $U_{0} =0.25$ (solid line). All growth rates are normalized by the two-dimensional ($m=0$) growth rate.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Experimental mean horizontal velocity field at $t=300\ \textrm {s}$, obtained by filtering the horizontal velocity field around the zero-frequency. The uniform cylinder is used as forcing. (a) Beam inclination angle $\theta =35{{}^{\circ }}$ and forcing amplitude $A/L = 0.72$, with $t=300\ \textrm {s} \approx 26 T_{0}$; (b) $\theta =45{{}^{\circ }}$ and $A/L = 0.54$, with $t=300\ \textrm {s} \approx 32 T_{0}$. In both cases, the primary wave beam has non-dimensional maximum along-beam velocity $U_{0}\approx 0.22$ measured 20 cm away from the cylinder, and did not exhibit any visible signs of instability. Contours of the horizontal velocity field of the primary wave beam at ${\pm }1\ \textrm {mm}\,\textrm {s}^{-1}$ are plotted in the dotted lines.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Experimental velocity fields for beam inclination angle $\theta =45{{}^{\circ }}$ and forcing amplitude $A/L=0.63$ using the uniform cylinder (a–c) and the non-uniform cylinder (d–e) at $t=39 T_{0}$, where $T_{0}$ is the forcing period. Panels (a,d) show the horizontal velocity field at $z=4.3\ \textrm {cm}$ while panels (b,e) show the horizontal velocity field at $z=14.3\ \textrm {cm}$, closer to the lateral tank wall. Panels (c,f) show the mean horizontal velocity field at $z=14.3\ \textrm {cm}$ obtained by filtering panels (b,e), respectively, around the zero-frequency. No significant vertical mean flows were observed.