Blues Dialogues: Music by Black Composers, the 2018 release by violin virtuoso Rachel Barton Pine on Cedille Records, is both a standout solo recording with inspired performances of undeservedly obscure repertoire, and a challenge. How long until the standard classical violin repertory expands to include a more racially diverse cast of composers? Pine isn't one to wait on the sidelines, and with this CD she takes a strong step toward bringing about that change.
Blues Dialogues is one piece of a much larger musical project. It comes two decades after Pine's notable Violin Concertos by Black Composers of the 18th & 19th Centuries.Footnote 1 As Pine writes in the liner notes to Blues Dialogues, that earlier release generated interest among violin teachers and students for more repertoire by black composers and in 2001, the Rachel Barton Pine Foundation launched the Music by Black Composers project.Footnote 2 MBC has been particularly active of late, publishing both Music by Black Composers: Violin Volume 1 and a Coloring Book of Black Composers in 2018.Footnote 3 The MBC website includes audio and video recordings of all repertoire in the former publication, though the print book is unfortunately (though tellingly) out of stock at distributors SHAR Music and J. W. Pepper.
Whereas MBC is currently focused on pedagogical materials for beginning- and intermediate-level violinists, Blues Dialogues maps out the other end of the spectrum. One can imagine a future where young violinists study not only Suzuki classics like “Go Tell Aunt Rhody,” but also Juwon Ogungbe's “Feeling the Pulse” (2014)—the opening piece in Music by Black Composers: Violin Volume 1—and then progress not only to the Bach Sonatas and Partitas for Solo Violin but also to, say, Coleridge-Taylor Perkinson's three-movement “Blue/s Forms for Solo Violin” (tracks 2 to 4 on Blues Dialogues).
The repertoire on Blues Dialogues is, simply put, stunning. This is classical music with an ear to the world, from William Grant Still's “Suite for Violin and Piano” (1943), perhaps the best-known work on this album, to Belize-born British composer Errollyn Wallen's “Woogie Boogie” (1999), which reshapes the typical piano stylings of boogie-woogie for violin. Renowned composer and pedagogue David Baker contributes “Blues (Deliver My Soul)” (1968), a stately gospel-inflected adaptation of his choral work Psalm 22, in an expanded twenty-four-bar blues form. Daniel Bernard Roumain's “Filter” (1992) gestures towards hip hop and electronic dance music both rhythmically and timbrally, as Roumain asks the performer to move her bow closer and farther from the bridge to “filter” the sound frequencies, creating approximations of studio effects.
This album is centered around the blues, as the title suggests, but only loosely. As musicologist Mark Clague writes in the introduction to his excellent liner notes, these composers have found “inspiration in the freedom of the blues.” When they use a twelve-bar blues form or a blues scale, it is as a point of departure. Changing meters, edgy harmonizations, and distorted timbres are the norm. Writes Clague, “Each composer draws from the cultural tributaries of the African Diaspora, and each has come to terms with the power of this heritage to forge an utterly personal expression of universal community across time, place, and people.” The blues provide the musical grammar for “a vital engagement with the world.”
While a handful of these pieces may be familiar to listeners—“Levee Dance” (1927), by Clarence Cameron White, for instance, was recorded by Jascha Heifetz in 1944Footnote 4—Blues Dialogues is very much an album of firsts. It includes the first recording of Roumain's Hendrix-inspired cadenza for “Filter” (2018); the first recording of Wendell Logan's expansive arrangement of Duke Ellington's “In a Sentimental Mood” for violin and piano (1935/1988); the first violin recording of Charles S. Brown's homage to Blind Willie Johnson, “A Song Without Words” (1974); the world premiere recording of Billy Childs's “Incident on Larpenteur Avenue” (2018), commissioned by Pine for this album; and the world premiere recording of Noel Da Costa's “Set of Dance Tunes for Solo Violin” (1968), which takes as its inspiration several nineteenth-century fiddle tunes, probably from the popular Ryan's Mammoth Collection. As Mark Clague notes, Da Costa's polystylistic approach likely derives from his transnational childhood: he was born in Nigeria to Jamaican parents and raised in the “sonic kaleidoscope” of New York City from the age of eleven. The fiddle tunes spark flights of musical imagination for Da Costa: he begins the suite with majestic, elegantly rolled double stops leading into a showy cakewalk, flits from playful spiccato to bluesy slides on “Little Diamond Jig,” and ends in solemnity with a clog reworked as a rough, grainy blues.
Blues Dialogues is notable for its instrumental sparseness. Pine is joined here by the superb pianist Matthew Hagle, but fourteen of the twenty-three tracks, totalling nearly thirty minutes, are for solo violin. In additional to the Da Costa suite, Pine includes Coleridge-Taylor Perkinson's “Blue/s Forms” (1972), in three movements, and his “Louisiana Blues Strut” (2001). The highlight for this reviewer was the title track, Dolores White's “Blues Dialogues” for solo violin. White composed the first three movements in 1988 and added the fourth, recorded here for the first time, in 2016. The first movement sets the tone: exploratory, conversational, introspective. Pine approaches each note as if it had just occurred to her. The sparse second movement ends with a long, ascending glissando extending across three strings, while the third movement, a small gem of seventy-four seconds, dances through contrasting ranges before responding with a slow, descending glissando. In the fourth movement, Pine lays down a groove with descending chromatic scales and then transitions into a solo. Some trace of the underlying groove rests in the ear as Pine builds the solo into a double-stopped echo of Bartok's Sonata for Solo Violin (1944); she then restates the opening groove with triumphant leaps into the higher octave.
This album shows off not only Pine's technical virtuosity but also her playful approach to exploring the full timbral range of the violin. She can swerve from a rich, warm, meaty tone to a timbre approaching feedback in a split second. Her sound is simultaneously deadly serious and joyful, and she seems to revel in playing at the edge of sonic acceptability. Mark Clague's outstanding liner notes combine brief musical analyses with biographical details on the composers and tidbits of sociocultural history. They will prove useful to violin teachers and students seeking to add this music to their repertoire, as well as to university instructors who might assign tracks from this CD in music history or theory courses.
My only critique is the packaging. I was, I admit, surprised to see the CD arrive in a plastic jewel case. There are more environmentally friendly options today, even for an album with a twenty-four-page booklet. In any case, Blues Dialogues is also available as either an MP3 or FLAC download from Cedille Records and these options include a digital-only bonus track: William Grant Still's “Blues” from Lenox Avenue for violin and piano (1937).Footnote 5 The booklet is available as a free PDF from the same site.
This is no crossover album wherein a classical musician dips her toes into a new style. This is a vision statement for what classical music, and specifically the violin repertory, could look like: open minded, engaged, and fierce. Rachel Barton Pine has never been one to shy away from edgy projects—her heavy metal performances come to mind—but the real question raised by Blues Dialogues is why, several decades into the twenty-first century, an album of classical violin music by twentieth- and twenty-first-century black composers should still seem radical.
