Much of the scholarly discussion of conscientious objection focuses on the philosophical justifications for refusal to serve in the army and their interpretations in legal regimes. Erica Weiss’s book provides an ethnographic window into the lives, ideologies, and strategies of conscientious objectors in Israel, as well as context that many non-Israeli readers will find enriching and useful in navigating the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
The book revolves around the concept of sacrifice, drawing on the biblical story of Abraham and Isaac (pp. 32–33) to explain the meaning of sacrifice for modern Israelis. The story provides a road map for understanding different perspectives on sacrifice: the potential risk to life and health involved in military service, and the no less important sacrifice of conscience involved in succumbing to the will of the state and participating in military-sanctioned activities with which one does not agree. Weiss also spends some time discussing the sacrifices involved in refusal—risks to career, forgoing the instrumental rights and cultural prestige acquired through military service—and the meaning of sacrifice for women, noncombatants, whose sacrifices and strategies are marginalized within the context of combat and masculinized service. The author even discusses the absence of Palestinian sacrifice from the Israeli narrative (p. 58). These notions of sacrifice are analyzed in the context of various perspectives on the sovereign state and its demands upon its citizens.
The personal and communal debates among objectors about the value and worth of their sacrifice are set against the backdrop of an ardently Zionist mainstream, with which Weiss’s subjects constantly converse in their political and cultural activism. The author provides a solid account of the centrality of the Zionist narrative in Israel, which gives more meaning to her interlocutors’ internal and external struggles in going against their upbringing and indoctrination, alienating family members and friends, and confronting military authorities.
The book follows two different conscientious objection groups: Combatants for Peace, a group of former combat soldiers now refusing to engage in reserve services and touring the country to provide confessions and personal testimonies of their experiences as enforcers of the occupation of Palestinian territories (pp. 72–73), and New Profile, a far-left feminist organization protesting against the militarization of Israeli society. While Weiss does not go into social movement theory in depth, she astutely uses the contrast between the two groups to offer an important lesson in strategy and messaging. Members of Combatants for Peace stress their Zionist upbringing and combat background to garner legitimacy and engage with audience members who may have similarly participated in the occupation as soldiers, focusing on everyday indignities, rather than on mass atrocities, to generate sympathy and common ground. New Profile, on the other hand, challenges the mainstream not only in antimilitarist and feminist perspectives but also in cultural preferences. The book does not systematically discuss the relative successes and pitfalls of each approach, but provides a faithful understanding of these two radically different, but equally sophisticated, approaches to social and political dialogue.
One aspect that is common to both groups is their privilege within Israeli social structure. Weiss is keenly aware of the role of privilege, its empowering qualities as well as its pitfalls, showing how her interlocutors rely on their social status to present a thoughtful and intelligent counterpoint to the militaristic narrative. She shows how Combatants for Peace define their conscientious objection through their own experiences as highly regarded combat soldiers, while the young New Profile potential objectors form their opinions based on Western philosophy and ethics, having not actually been in contact with Palestinians (p. 85).
The feminist perspective on conscientious objection is one of the great strengths of the book. Weiss acknowledges several different stances from which women challenge the masculine social order: as “less valuable” objectors, whose loss to the army is not as important as that of a male combatant, and whose bitterness about the legitimacy acquired through participation in the occupation is authentically described (p. 91); as Women in Black, who receive scorn and disrespect in Israeli society; and as Four Mothers, an organization of combatants’ mothers against the war in Lebanon, who receive a more mixed reaction from the Israeli public and the army.
Weiss’s sensitivity and respect toward her interlocutors is clearly evident throughout the book, and especially when she narrates their defining moments in which they decided to refuse to serve. Also of much value, especially to empirical researchers, is her candidness about her own role as participant observer. Weiss is open and honest about her sympathy to her interlocutors’ struggle against the Occupation, and she freely provides her instinctual reactions to some of their statements and beliefs. For example, when a vegan high school student compares her care for the plight of animals to that of Palestinians, Weiss candidly shares her initial shock at such statements and her later acknowledgment of the logic behind them. She is also open about her position as an involved participant, who lent her apartment to one of the groups she studied, and about her strong reaction to men who yelled sexual obscenities at protesting women.
Most of Weiss’s observations of her interlocutors are keen and astute. In her perceptions of the high school students attending meetings organized by New Profile, she comments on their ascetic tastes and identifies them, classwise, not only within the context of Israeli society but also globally (p. 84). While the sense is that Weiss got most of what she saw “right,” especially the politics, class, and gender aspects—her observations of the gender dynamics within the conscientious objection movement are particularly insightful— there are a few aspects of the book that ring less accurate. Her depiction of Mizrahi Jewish Israelis as being “under pressure not to appear as Arab sympathizers” (p. 13) is grossly off mark, and her reference to their “hidden” conscientious objection glosses over important manifestations of refusal to serve for socioeconomic issues that are more common, by orders of magnitude, than political refusals by the Ashkenazi elites. Her discussion of the prison experiences of objectors when meeting soldiers from different backgrounds (pp. 150–51) somewhat compensates for this inaccuracy.
The book could also benefit from better organization; the narrative drifts between heavy theory (Slavoj Žižek, Judith Butler, and others) and observations. Moreover, basic issues, such as the time line of the movements and the legal status of objectors, are presented disjointedly, if accurately. The timing of Weiss’s fieldwork means that she essentially missed the big political and legal developments in the early 2000s regarding conscientious objectors. This information, which is crucial for understanding the internal dilemmas of the interlocutors and their balance of sacrifice, is provided relatively later in the book, such as the military “conscience committees,” to which prospective objectors have to prove that they are “total pacifists” rather than occupation dissenters, who are not seen as having a legitimate conscientious claim (pp. 118–19).
Conscientious Objectors in Israel is beautifully written and contains enriching and illuminating literary and poetic quotes that accompany the theme of sacrifice, which makes up for a few small inaccuracies in the phonetic Hebrew. It is overall an interesting and worthwhile read that brings more complexity and sophistication to an issue often seen by Weiss’s potential readers in black and white.
