What is the connection between the ‘repulsive’ sound of equal-tempered pianos and industrialized silk patterns? Do they emerge from a similar historical moment? In Harmonious Triads Myles Jackson pries open a neglected period of acoustics to reveal the complex interactions of music, craftsmanship, industrialization and science in post-Napoleonic Germany. During the time covered, we find the science of sound existing in, and fuelled by, the vibrancy of musical culture. In turn, we see how acoustics influenced the manufacture of musical instruments, the performance of music and the need for standards. Developments within the sciences are interesting in themselves; modern theoretical and experimental acoustics, which came into being during this period, contributed indirectly to other fields such as electricity and optics. One of the remarkable features of this book, therefore, is that the main elements of the story (music, science and artisans) are dealt with in equal depth, with each depicted as actively shaping the others. It is a history of music, and of how music was altered by science, as much as a history of science, instruments and nineteenth-century German culture.
Jackson presents a treasure trove of new material. He describes the life and work of E. F. F. Chladni, the founder of experimental acoustics, who moved effortlessly between diverse scientific and cultural activities to invent scientific and musical instruments. He describes the unifying power of folk songs at German scientific meetings. We learn about the acoustical work of Wilhelm Weber – better known for his contributions in electrodynamics – on adiabatic phenomena and reed pipes, a vital German manufacturing and cultural product. There is a fascinating chapter on Johann Scheibler, the character behind a major innovation in precision tuning and the A440, who was a silk manufacturer and amateur musician. Jackson also covers the quest to standardize pitch in nineteenth-century Europe, the aesthetic angle making this standardization story one of the more fascinating of its kind. The final chapter describes the shifting balance between machines, physics and musical pedagogy in the wake of these acoustical developments. The virtuosi, such as Paganini and Liszt, emerge during this period as counterweights to the infiltration of music by science, technology and industrial culture.
One of the themes that runs through this book is the tension, especially rooted in early nineteenth-century Germany, between organic and mechanical perspectives on music. There were those who felt threatened by the ‘reduction’ of music by science and technology. On the other hand, there were those, such as Weber and later Helmholtz, who believed that they were increasing the appreciation and quality of music by exploring scientific and applied questions. Musical automata – doll-like machines that could play music – were material witnesses to the early appropriation of music by technology.
Mirroring Chladni's nodal patterns, instruments in this book are meeting points for underlying historical forces. As with his previous book on optics, Spectrum of Belief (Cambridge, MA, 2000), Jackson brings instruments and their makers into the history with their own contexts and issues. The seemingly simple reed pipe, for example, is revealed as lying at the intersection of artisan skill, mathematics, physics and organ performance. The chapter on Weber, a fine example of scholarship that bridges complex technical issues with multilayered historical context, brings together the physics of aerial vibrations, the development of theory and experiment related to reed pipes, the manufacturing aspects of reed pipes, and musical contexts of performance. Jackson's work on instruments is particularly important for instrument scholars and museum curators. By assembling so much manufacturing, cultural and scientific detail about one object, he opens the door to meaningful artefact interpretation in the future. He does not examine instruments themselves (which could lead to even more unexpected connections and historical spaces), but he takes them seriously on their own terms, and not simply as occasions for the discussion of other issues in the story.
Harmonious Triads, therefore, offers valuable lessons in historical research and writing. Like the characters he is studying, Jackson ventures across boundaries. He has a remarkable capacity for bringing together diverse historical material, presented in a swirling yet interconnecting dynamic of relations, while keeping focused on the essentials of a larger theme – cross-fertilization among artisans, savants and performers. The result is so well researched, documented and expressed that it effectively sets a high standard for historians of science and museum curators who wish to break out of traditional narratives about science.
