It is a little unexpected, but not at all unpleasurable, early in the twenty-first century to review a Victorian ‘Life and Letters’. For this is what this volume is: Professor Schwartz has spent many long and devoted years with his subject, or at least with every pertinent letter he can find; he is sympathetic to his man but not unaware of weaknesses; and he presents the letters, with concise linking commentary, in order to tell the life of a gentleman, reveal a personality and pay tribute to contributions to science. As there is an existing ‘Life and Letters’, prepared after her husband's early death in 1894 by Ethel Romanes, the obvious question arises: why a new version?
Joel Schwartz makes his answer clear: because of Romanes's close relationship to Darwin and his central place in the post-Darwin debates about the mechanism of selection and the evidence for evolution of mind, his letters are one of the richest records we have for two decades, 1874 to 1894, in these branches of biology. ‘My criterion in deciding what letters should be included … was: Do they help the reader trace Romanes's development as a scientist and demonstrate his importance in natural history, particularly as an evolutionist and a supporter of Darwin?’ (p. xiii). He has organized the letters to bring out biological debate, but also used letters which Ethel Romanes did not know about or print, from the collection of the American Philosophical Society (for the Rev. J.T. Gulick), the Wellcome Trust Library (E. Schäfer) and the British Library (A.R. Wallace), amongst others. The present volume is therefore as complete a presentation of Romanes the biologist as can be assembled from the known letters, along with letters of his respondents – most completely, Darwin – where this is judged necessary or helpful. Moreover, Ethel Romanes, caring for her husband, who died from what was presumably a brain tumour, and for their young children, was concerned with his spiritual life. Because Romanes had a reputation, as he still has, as an actual example of a man whose scientific reason drew him from belief in religion, his wife was concerned to show that finally this was not so. Schwartz concludes, by contrast, that Romanes remained to the end painfully aware of faith as something of great beauty but inaccessible to reason. His letters to the Rev. Gulick, most of which are detailed commentaries on isolation and the divergence of varieties, suggest that Schwartz is correct. Apart from this, for Romanes the man this collection largely reproduces the letters (though checked against the originals) from the earlier ‘Life and Letters’. His poetry remains unread.
The letters show just how difficult it was to understand and to advance knowledge of evolutionary mechanisms. Correspondents had great difficulty in being clear to each other and in print: different proposals cut across each other in a tangle of claims and counterclaims, mixing rampant speculation and highly detailed knowledge of particular cases. Darwin seized on Romanes as a helper for the grafting work he anticipated would demonstrate pangenesis, and only when at work on the movements of insectivorous plants appreciated the importance of Romanes's more proficient work on primitive nervous systems in jellyfish. Inspired by Darwin, Romanes entered debates on heredity (pangenesis, Galton), acquired characteristics (Spencer, Weismann), the causes and consequences of sterility as an isolating factor between varieties (Gulick), the evolution of supposedly non-useful traits (attributed by Darwin to correlation of growth, denied by Wallace), the weeding out of non-useful organs (Darwin's ‘rudimentary’ characteristics), the evolution of intelligence (Darwin, Lloyd Morgan), and so on. Romanes introduced his own theory of ‘physiological selection’, focused on the claim that sterility is a cause of isolation of varieties leading to divergent speciation; almost everyone did not agree. This collection of letters will most interest specialists interested in such topics, and it clearly will be a valued resource for future accounts of the years immediately before new arguments about heredity transformed this area of biology.
There is further evidence here of just how difficult it was to be clear about what the issues were and who had authority to judge in the intellectual legacy bequeathed by Darwin. The exchange of letters between Romanes and Wallace is a surprising and sad monument to this, with Wallace insulted at being called a fool and feeling that Romanes said one thing in private and another in public about spiritualism, and Romanes bitter at being cast in a scenario titled ‘Romanes versus Darwin’, accusing Wallace of putting forward his, Romanes's, ideas while yet attacking him. By contrast, Romanes was emotionally fulfilled when playing disciple to Darwin: they shared both a way of life of independent wealth and a gentlemanly scientific style – fascination with the natural history of individual cases as the route to deep insight – with strong proprietorial views, wrapped in the language of modesty, about what they had to say. Romanes's comments on the contrast between rabbits, which refuse nettles, and guinea pigs, which eat with relish, then scratch their mouths, then break out in fights, capture this. The South American animals, Romanes thought, had not acquired the characteristic of knowing that what looks sweet may sting.
