Blossius Aemilius Dracontius was certainly the most important Latin poet whose works survive from the Vandal period in North Africa. Imprisoned by the Hasding king Gunthamund in the latter part of the fifth century for the crime of composing a poem in honour of a dominus ignotus, Dracontius composed two Christian poems during his imprisonment, the conciliatory Satisfactio and the more intransigent three-volume De Laudibus Dei. A number of profane poems also survive including several epyllia on classical mythological topics and shorter incidental poems and epithalamia, collectively known as the Romulea. (Other works, including the fateful carmen for which he was imprisoned have since been lost.) Writing as he was in a period of political upheaval and sectarian conflict, Dracontius has long been interrogated as a historical source on Africa in the later fifth and early sixth centuries, and the mysterious circumstances of his own imprisonment and eventual release have been the subject of extensive speculation. In recent years, moreover, Dracontius has also been appreciated for the literary qualities of his work, for his inheritance of both Christian and pagan poetic traditions, and for his own influence on the later generation of African poets collected in the Latin Anthology. The present volume gathers together many important voices in this scholarship and offers points for reflection for further work. Based on a conference held in 2016, the collection consists of fifteen papers in German, French, Italian and English, and includes a very full bibliography on matters Dracontian. If the poet who emerges from all of this is sometimes difficult to pin down, and variously appears as a champion and a critic of the Vandal regime, a sensitive preserver of classical traditions and an innovative Christian poet, this perhaps reflects the richness of his oeuvre and the social complexities of the time in which he lived.
The book is loosely divided into four sections, but common themes and points of contention cut across the contributions. As the title of the collection suggests, Dracontius’ cultural and political context ‘between Romans and Vandals’ is the most obvious of these — perhaps not surprising for a poet who variously praised contemporary rulers and was imprisoned for this writing. Yet the Vandals themselves appear only fleetingly within his work. Particularly important is a celebrated passage from the first of the Romulea, in which Dracontius compares his former tutor Felicianus to Orpheus; just as Orpheus had tamed wild animals through the power of his song, the poet argues, so Felicianus’ teaching charmed both Romans and barbarians who sat alongside one another in his lecture theatre. The image is a compelling one and has commonly been taken as evidence for a literary revival in Vandal Carthage during the 470s or 480s and for the engagement of the barbarian elite within this process. But the value of Roman culture within the Vandal kingdom was never clear cut, and the tensions between the different African elites are explored in different ways by many of the contributors. The image of barbarians as ‘tamed beasts’ is an ambivalent one at best, and may be read as a thinly veiled attack on the brutish new elite. As Konrad Vössing argues in his chapter, the panegyrics written in honour of Vandal kings need not have been particularly valued by their recipients, and literary education among them may have been partial at best. This may perhaps overstate the case — the literary patrons we do hear of among the Vandals may have been exceptions, but need not have been, and there is little evidence that the new elite were disdainful of Roman culture — but his argument is a salutary rejoinder to a current tendency to emphasise acculturation over Vandal ‘barbarism’. Annick Stoehr-Monjou and Miryam De Gaetano similarly see an essential opposition between Roman poets (and their audiences) and the Vandal authorities, and each argues that the mythological themes of the Romulea provided Dracontius with a space to frame veiled criticism of the Vandal elite. In the last chapter of the volume, Silke Diedrich returns to this theme of opposition and discusses Dracontius’ explicitly anti-Arian message in De Laudibus Dei — perhaps his clearest poetic statement against the ruling elite.
Yet other contributors are less willing to see Roman and Vandal as quite so clearly opposed in the poet's works. In the opening chapter, Étienne Wolff provides a more cautious discussion of the valence of Romanitas in Vandal Africa. He notes that references to classical culture might have been positioned in opposition to the new elite, but need not be read as explicitly political, and others share this more cautious framing. Antonella Bruzzone suggests that the mythological themes within the Romulea may have had an educational function and may have been intended in part to introduce a new audience to the nuances and delights of the classical heritage. Similarly, Christoph Schubert notes the multiple registers on which Dracontius’ profane poetry can be read and infers multiple intended audiences from this, including perhaps the Vandals themselves. All of these contributions are stimulating and all reflect the cultural complications of Vandal Africa, not least for a poet whose position within this world changed dramatically (and repeatedly).
Other contributions to the volume prefer to set Dracontius within multiple literary contexts, and it is here that work on the poet has advanced most over recent years. Thomas Gärtner, Christine Schmitz and Katherina Pohl all discuss innovation within the epyllia specifically, highlighting the poet's experimentation with well-established form. Hedwig Schmaltzgruber similarly places Dracontius within a Christian poetic tradition through a close examination of the theme of terra mater within De Laudibus Dei. Here, Dracontius worked within a wholly different poetic tradition, one which Stefan Freund discusses expertly through the different ways in which the writer variously positioned himself as both a profane writer and a Christian poet in his different works. Helen Kaufmann's paper discusses the profound influence that all of these compositions had on later African poets, particularly those collected in the Latin Anthology, but also those surviving outside that collection, including Verecundus of Iunci. This is an important reminder that Dracontius was not the only writer to flourish in the Vandal kingdom. These approaches are complemented by Angelo Luceri's discussion of the ambivalent status of Carthage across Dracontius’ work — at once a symbol of the sinful past and the setting for contemporary cultural revival. Clearly Carthage was an important locus of late Latin poetry, with Dracontius himself in a central position.
Together these papers offer a range of approaches to this important poet and illuminate both the context in which he worked and the extant verses themselves. Ultimately, the contributors do not reach consensus on some important issues, including the nature of relations between the Vandals and their Romano-African subjects, but the range of approaches adopted here is admirable and welcome. These papers should set Dracontian (and Vandal-period) scholarship on a firm new footing, not least through the rich bibliography assembled by the editor.
