Why do most Turks today have a modern liberal understanding of Islam, considering it to be primarily a matter of personal choice and private belief, and not see this attitude as alienation from their Islamic traditions? Brian Silverstein's ambitious Islam and Modernity in Turkey synthesizes recent research on history and social theory to “diagnose the Turkish present” in order to make sense of the rather peculiar place, compared with other Muslim-majority societies, that Islam occupies in modern Turkish society. The study seeks a new angle on how Turkey's experience speaks uniquely to the global discussion on the place of Islam in modern societies.
The book may be best characterized as an innovative think piece on modern Turkey. Although it does present some original material from Silverstein's fieldwork among Sufis, its most valuable contribution lies in how it seeks to reconceptualize and find novel connections between familiar features in Turkish history and society. The work is theory driven, employing a stream of anthropological and social theory (Alisdair MacIntyre, Michel Foucault, William Connolly, Talal Asad, and Saba Mahmood) that the author spends much time explaining quite clearly, even if repetitively, throughout and that applies brilliantly to the ethnographic and historical materials. Asad's notion of Islam as a discursive tradition provides a way to think about continuity in a religious tradition amid possibly drastic changes in practice, ideas, and attitude. This non-essentialist approach views Islam not as a fixed, core body of doctrines or practices but rather as an ongoing conversation through time among Muslims, in interaction with texts, over what constitutes correct belief and conduct.
The perspective enables Silverstein's main argument that when most Turkish Muslims today experience Islam by the liberal understanding of private practice and personal belief, they see this as completely continuous with their Islamic traditions. The reason is that changes in the conditions and meanings of Islam in Turkish society unfolded beginning in the late 18th century through Ottoman and republican institutional reform, with major shifts (in regard to religious institutions, education, the ulema, and eventually the abolition of the caliphate) justified on grounds internal to Islamic reasoning, that is, using canonical sources and recognized methods of argumentation. “Westernization” does not adequately describe this process, he argues, because the goal of the reformers, which eventually included members of the ulema, was not to Westernize as such or abandon Islamic norms but to strengthen the empire as a Muslim polity. While the drive for military technology and modern educational techniques of the Tanzimat progressively shifted the society's emphasis toward new non-Islamic domains of knowledge and their practitioners, those changes are considered (by Silverstein and, he claims, by most Turks implicitly) consistent with and thus incorporated into Islamic tradition because they were done for, as it were, Islamic reasons. This outcome was not inevitable but resulted from specific shifts in power and knowledge in a “reflexive modernization” that has since formed the very conditions of possibility for the movements that promote Islamic piety in Turkey today.
Turkish Sufism provides a particularly useful window on to Muslim sensibilities in the republic, which Silverstein shows through two ethnographic chapters in the middle of the book. His years of fieldwork reveal how a Naqshbandi community (cemaat) in Istanbul operates with modern forms of sociality, personhood, and knowledge constituting its variety of Islamic tradition in the Asad perspective. Sufism in practice is an ethical project, Silverstein emphasizes, about not mystical experience (as most have written) but the cultivation of a certain kind of moral self marked by virtuous habitual dispositions, feelings, and actions. Members undergo a regimen of repeated exercises (such as dhikr) conducted with an intense personal relationship with the shaykh via the sohbet, translated here as companionship-in-conversation, a technique of ritualized discourse where face-to-face presencing, direct oral transmission of knowledge, and repetition are central to nefs terbiyesi, the training of mastery over base human instincts. The link between social power and subject formation illustrated in Sufi disciplines, the author asserts, is more important to understanding the relation of religion to the political than the links between Islam and Turkish party politics, even under the rule of the AKP. On this count the book makes a critical companion to Jenny White's Islamist Mobilization in Turkey (University of Washington Press, 2002), because Silverstein divulges a modern religious orientation underlying Turkish politics that operates at a deeper level than the Islamist communalism that White describes. Silverstein suggests that the crucial issue is how ethical sensibilities of the kind cultivated in Sufi circles undergird the terms of public debate in Turkey today, which is marked by increasingly prestigious Islamic idioms of sociopolitical criticism, rather than how Sufi orders influence party politics as such.
Sufi “disciplines of presence” have been undergoing transformation, however, with the larger audiences reached by the radio broadcast of sohbets (Silverstein does not consider the Internet). The altered contexts of reception have turned sohbets from a technique of tutored self-cultivation into general Islamic informational content subject to deliberation in a Habermasian public sphere. The change forms part of the broader 20th-century shift of Islam into a liberal mode characterized by abstraction and personal choice thanks to mass education and media, as noted by scholars like Dale Eickelman. However, Silverstein is careful to distinguish his argument from recent discussions about Islamic discourses as a form of “counter-public,” an alternative sphere of community and action against the oppressive postcolonial states in which many Muslims live. Here lies his claim for Turkey's unique experience regarding the place of Islam in modern society: it does not quite fit the cases considered by scholars like Armando Salvatore on Islamic publics and their claims for social justice. Turkey is not a postcolonial state, so it never suffered the humiliation of modern reforms imposed by foreign powers. Unlike most Muslim majority states, the Turkish state has not failed to deliver on developmentalist promises, and so does not suffer from a lack of legitimacy. In fact, a central concern of Salvatore's Islamic publics, maslaḥa, the common good, was a key stated motivation for late Ottoman and early republican reforms. Turkey provides a compelling model because it has been synthesizing liberal ideas about society, state, and religion for two centuries on its own Islamic terms. Turkey's new regional assertiveness before, during, and since the 2010 Arab revolts is unsurprisingly linked to its similar claims of uniqueness. However Europe's anxieties about Turkish membership in the European Union play out, “civilization” is not among the reasons Turkey should be kept out, Silverstein argues as a parting shot, because its history of political culture, juridical norms, and socioreligious understandings is as much part of Europe's history as that of any admitted candidate.
Although the book is strong in theoretical argumentation on the broad parameters of Turkish society and history, it lacks ethnographic richness. Fieldwork descriptions are few and brief, mostly found in opening vignettes of chapters, and analyses do not work closely through the actual talk and conduct of the informants, which would be particularly critical concerning the power of words and presencing in Sufi disciplinary practice. Historians may largely agree with his overall argument on the Islamic rationale of reforms but find the repeated assertion of this rationale peculiar for falling short of full contextualization and nuance (cf. on that count the chapter on the Tanzimat in Carter Findley's Turkey, Islam, Nationalism, and Modernity: A History [New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 2010]). Silverstein's book is nonetheless a brilliant piece of lucid scholarship in its synthetic originality and sophisticated grasp of scholarly concepts that indeed illuminate the topic. It is most recommended for scholars and graduate students of the modern Middle East and in anthropology concerned with the productive place of theory in social analysis and the provocative place of Turkey in today's world.
