When Martha Biondi's first book, To Stand and Fight: The Struggle for Civil Rights in Postwar New York City, was published in 2003, it adjusted the geographic and conceptual coordinates of civil rights historiography. Her second monograph is likely to have a similar effect on the intellectual topography of black power. The Black Revolution on Campus “unsettles the usual geography of vanguard student radicalism” (6), elevating the place of black colleges and black students in the period's social activism, and masterfully recapturing both the movement's “indigenous and local” origins (5) and the “character of simultaneity” (78) it had attained by 1969, a year she, and others, take as the movement's high point. The work toggles between detail and sweeping interpretive strokes, presenting black student activism in this period as “another legacy of the twentieth century's massive internal migration” (4), and restoring the central place of black students within black power. It is not a history like that which Fabio Rojas (2007) presented, which took us from black power to black studies. Rather it is one that takes black studies to be an expression of black power.
Biondi is not the first scholar to write about black student activism, of course. Over the past decade several studies of individual campuses where black studies programs were created have quietly accumulated, and a number of recent works, by the likes of Stefan Bradley and Donna Murch, have widened the interpretive aperture to consider the place of black students in the black power movement. But The Black Revolution on Campus is one of the first syntheses of this movement (a few months earlier, Ibram Rogers published The Black Campus Movement (2012)), and certainly the most capacious in its approach to the politics that informed it. Many of the same issues and concerns that irritated students on campuses across the US were also experienced by high-school and professional students, and, in a luminous chapter entitled “The Black Revolution Off-Campus,” Biondi shows how the solutions these groups devised encompassed the creation of adult education programs, community discussion groups, public broadcasting, and research institutes, as well as the formation of new academic disciplines. The decision to discuss these sibling ventures together, alongside the rise of black studies, is related to Biondi's view that all were expressions of “the broader Black Power upsurge” (79) that strived to make institutions relevant to black communities. The chapter will provide scholars with a useful device for thinking about how particular institutions related to each other, and to the period as a whole.
One of the questions that drives Biondi's analysis concerns the coordination of activism in light of the lack of “formal organizational links” (13–14) between campuses and across regions. “Student activism had been emerging in various locations in isolation” (149), she argues, using chapters on San Francisco, New York, Chicago, and the South to show how the “local political landscape shaped [students'] thinking” (68) in each of these areas. While some formal organizations, like the Western Regional Alliance of Black Student Unions, were eventually set up to facilitate the sharing of tactics, ideas frequently wandered along more informal pathways. In the summer of 1968, students at UCLA visited San Francisco State College (SFSC), and “borrowed some of their ideas” (69), while nonstudents swept up by the strike at Howard University a few months later used that campus “to disseminate black power literature” (145). The frequent movement of academics, from graduate school to professorships, and, in the case of the omnipresent Nathan Hare, who moved from Howard to SFSC, or Jimmy Garrett, who went in the other direction, also encouraged this circulation.
Some of the movement's ideas came through the existing civil rights infrastructure. The strike at SFSC, for example, was led by Jimmy Garrett, a “seasoned organizer,” who had worked with the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, and Hari Dillon, whose grandfather had helped to found the Ghadr Party, and had participated in James Meredith's March against Fear. But one of Biondi's central points is that such backgrounds were not necessarily the most typical. Many of the students caught up in campus organizing worked part-time, and were in their mid-twenties when they enrolled. Vice President Spiro Agnew was therefore wrong on both counts: these students did not take their tactics from Gandhi, nor their money from their daddies.
What motivated many of them were the issues that they confronted when they arrived on campus. “From day one our life on campus was political protest” (19), one black student remembers. It was for a variety of reasons that they did so, not least the racism that they encountered when they turned up for class. Early Affirmative Action programs, like New York's SEEK initiative, at the time the largest in the US, barred the minority students it assisted from participating in student politics and athletics. Moreover, while black studies was largely the product of increasing black student enrolments in higher education, it was the restrictions placed on, or the restrictive nature of, those admissions that occasioned its start, as for instance was the case in California, where a shift in policy drastically reduced the numbers of black students. Finally, the most formative experience for tens of thousands of black students, particularly those studying at historically black campuses in the south, was the violence used against them by police forces keen to deploy the enhanced suite of weaponry acquired in the wake of Watts. At Texas Southern University in May 1967, South Carolina State University–Orangeburg the following year, and Howard University in March 1968, as well as at numerous other campuses around the country, the use of “excessive … force by police pushed moderate students over to the side of radicals” (62). That the campus itself was as much a spur to activism as the site of it is one of Biondi's main points.
It is a point that emerges from the genre of history she writes. By her own description, The Black Revolution on Campus “combines activist history and intellectual history” (3), though the book is only a partial delineation of the latter. If black student activism “encompassed admissions, faculty hiring, curriculum, and overall mission” (114), it should be said that Biondi is magisterial on the first two of these subjects and interesting on the fourth, although she has less to say on the third, curricula. Passing references are made to what students read, but there is less on what professors taught and examined, or the relationship between those interests and the type of work that editors encouraged. The debates that are prioritized here tend to take place in administrative chambers, not lecture theatres or seminar rooms. There may be good reasons for this approach, including what Biondi describes as the “lag between activism and meaningful curricula reform” (7). But I suspect that this was not always so. Events at SFSC and Merritt College in Oakland suggest a more intricate chronology, for instance.
The work's final chapter, “What Happened to Black Studies?”, provides the most direct attempt to describe the intellectual trajectory taken by black studies in the last three decades or so. In it Biondi briskly dismisses the influence of Afrocentrism, and what she feels are wrongheaded attempts to standardize curricula and methodology, and instead focusses on the conceptual contributions made by scholars working in black studies programs. But this is all done in broad strokes, glossed from retrospective surveys of the field done in the 1990s and early 2000s. We still need to relate the intellectual development of black studies to the broader epistemological conditions of these years in ways that Daniel Rodgers's The Age of Fracture (2011) has begun to do. Still, this final chapter, like much of this study, is both a history of and also an argument for the place of black studies in the academy. And in that respect, some of the most persuasive evidence it presents for the contribution made by black studies is the book itself.
