Rape reform in the United States is almost universally portrayed as one of the biggest successes of second wave feminism. Common accounts of the anti-rape movement of the 1970s claim that legal mobilization helped to engage the public in meaningful conversations about sexual violence, produced important legal changes, and standardized the administration of forensic rape kits in emergency rooms, which in turn facilitated the collection of evidence and increased prosecution and conviction rates.
Rose Corrigan is deeply critical of this assessment and challenges the reader to reevaluate this triumphalist narrative. In her book, Up Against a Wall: Rape Reform and the Failure of Success, Corrigan offers a much more cautionary tale that focuses on the continued struggles of rape survivors to be taken seriously and treated with respect and dignity. While Corrigan acknowledges that the laws have indeed changed for the better, she counters that public attitudes and perceptions have not changed, and many—if not most—rape crisis centers remain underfunded, marginalized, and politically vulnerable. Her analysis ultimately questions whether legal mobilization, even under the best of circumstances, is capable of improving the lives of rape victims and, perhaps even more importantly, reducing the rate of sexual violence in communities across the United States. The story that emerges from Corrigan’s research is “a story about the limits of legal mobilization rather than a triumphant account of success” (p. 7).
Corrigan’s socio-legal analysis is based on qualitative interviews with 167 rape care advocates from six states (Colorado, Kansas, Michigan, New Jersey, South Carolina and Washington). While I was certainly curious how the other key players—legal and medical professionals—would have responded to the grievances voiced by these advocates, I never felt that Corrigan’s focus was too narrow. Corrigan’s research is based on an impressive amount of data and her detailed case studies and extensive quotes from her interviews not only make for a fascinating reading, but offer an important and much needed addition to the existing body of research.
Up Against a Wall contains six chapters, with an introduction and a conclusion. The introduction, which is titled “The Failure of Success,” offers a clear outline of Corrigan’s major criticisms and leaves little doubt that the ensuing narrative will prove to be controversial to many feminist and legal scholars.
Chapter 2 provides a succinct overview of the complex interplay between the feminist movement, the legal changes activists fought for, and how the engagement with the legal process in turn transformed the feminist movement itself. More specifically, Corrigan highlights the limitations of legal mobilization by activists who were neither legal experts nor particularly successful in translating feminist arguments into a legal framework. Their belief that legal changes would ultimately change public attitudes about rape thus proved to be misguided.
Chapter 3 describes the research design and provides a brief overview of the organizational structure and history of rape crisis centers (RCCs) across the United States. Chapter 4 examines the first major piece of evidence that rape law reforms have indeed failed to reach their proclaimed goals: the persistence of extremely low reporting rates. Corrigan argues that “problems with rape reporting are not simply due to victims’ shame, guilt, or reluctance to come forward, but are also a result of concerted resistance from medical and legal actors” (p. 65). Her interview data vividly illustrates the pervasive disbelief that many rape victims encounter and that ultimately discourages them from pressing charges.
Chapter 5 takes a critical look at Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) programs. Corrigan emphasizes that “SANE programs have significantly improved the outcomes for victims,” but she is also deeply uneasy with the fact that many of these programs focus primarily on evidence collection, rather than on the medical and psychological needs of rape victims (p. 117). Her rich case studies demonstrate that the success of SANE programs varies quite dramatically: The best SANE programs, which are oftentimes run by RCCs rather than hospitals, can “provide a safe, comfortable, dignified setting for victims” while others leave victims feel violated and without agency or viable legal options (p. 147).
One of the most controversial aspects of SANE programs, the availability of emergency contraception (EC), is discussed in Chapter 6. This chapter, in particular, highlights the political and financial vulnerability of RCCs. Rather than criticizing rape care advocates for their reluctance to speak out in support of EC, Corrigan offers a careful and nuanced account of what is at stake. Her interview data makes it exceedingly clear that most advocates are not only very much aware of the importance of providing rape victims with access to EC, but are also supportive of reproductive rights and access to contraception and abortion more generally. However, “for RCCs already marginalized in their communities, risking association with abortion politics carries far greater risks than benefits” (p. 159). This reluctance to publicly support feminist struggles for reproductive rights is used to highlight the complex and problematic outcomes of rape law reform and thus supports Corrigan’s main argument.
The final chapter focuses on sex offender registration and notification statutes, which, despite their popularity among rape victims, have been criticized as deeply problematic by countless feminist and legal scholars. Corrigan agrees with their concerns about the extension of state power and emphasizes that these statutes have failed to reach their proclaimed goal of making communities safer. Her most important criticism, though, focuses on the fact that these statutes seem to confirm the popular stereotype of the violent, mentally-ill sexual predator who preys on strangers. Not only is this stereotype factually incorrect—after all, most rape victims know their attacker—it also makes it harder to prosecute cases that do not fit into this narrative. Ultimately, sex offender registration statutes have thus led to even lower conviction rates and have subjected the victims of acquaintance rape to even greater scrutiny.
The conclusion raises the important question: “Where to Go from Here?” (p. 262). While there is obviously no easy answer, Corrigan’s work offers a wealth of information to scholars, activists and rape care advocates alike. Corrigan’s rich, qualitative data and her nuanced analysis of the successes and failures of rape reform in the United States make a vital contribution to scholarship on reproductive rights, feminist theory and criminal justice. While the book offers an important and at times uncomfortable critique of rape reform, the interviews also tell a story of a network of activists who care deeply about the needs of rape victims and are not only committed to helping individuals, but also to reforming the system. Ultimately, the book is not simply about a failure of success, but it is also a call for action.
