In dealing with historical figures there is always the risk of overlooking the scope and significance of their cultural contexts. In the case of Maimonides, the medieval rabbi and philosopher, there is the further tendency to approach his philosophical views apart from his more practical religious concerns; to separate the philosopher from the rabbi. Maimonides the philosopher is usually associated with his monumental Guide of the Perplexed, which shows him to be well-versed in the Aristotelian-Arabic philosophical tradition. Maimonides the rabbi, on the other hand, is the author of the equally monumental juridical work the Mishneh Torah, which sees him situated in the Jewish Talmudic tradition. The two works and the respective traditions they encapsulate are easily kept apart, as if there were no overlap.
Sarah Stroumsa argues against such a compartmentalized reading of Maimonides. Instead, she presents Maimonides as typifying a Mediterranean thinker steeped in a multi-layered culture of Jewish, Islamic, Christian, religious, and non-religious elements, which in his case intermingled into a whirlpool effect (xiv) informing both his philosophical and religious views. Her meticulous study explores the influences that likely shaped Maimonides’ education, percolated in his formative years, and filtered into his mature thinking.
The book lays out the contours of a Mediterranean culture in an intellectual, rather than anthropological, sense (chap. 1). Maimonides’ reading list or bookshelf would have comprised a wide variety of writings, including works representative of heretical Sabians, Sunni Muslims, Ismā‘īlī Shi‘ites, and Sufi mystics, in addition to standard works in philosophy, science, and the rabbinical tradition. He would have responded to theological issues that arose, in broad terms, from Jewish, Islamic, and Christian orthodox and non-orthodox currents (chap. 2). However, of particular significance is the Islamic theology prevalent under Almohad rule in twelfth-century Spain, to which Maimonides would have been exposed in his formative years (chap. 3). The Almohad dynasty instituted a revivalist movement that sought to restore Islam in what proponents perceived to have become a corrupt state. The movement was fundamentalist in the sense of returning to the roots of Islam and away from the subsequent legal tradition. Stroumsa shows the impact of Almohad thinking in Maimonides’ use of the same Arabic term (uşūl) for ‘roots’ or ‘fundamentals’ which he expands to refer to authoritative primary sources, to broad formulations of laws instead of specific rulings, and to fundamental beliefs that characterize Judaism. The influence is also seen in his methodology of the Mishneh Torah, his hermeneutic approach in the Guide, and his general attitude toward philosophy and science, in which he too, like the Almohads and their spokesperson Ibn Tūmart, gives a deference to foundational texts—in this case, to the metaphysical and physical works of Aristotle—but at the same time acknowledges a limit to human understanding.
In subsequent chapters Stroumsa offers test cases for her hypothesis that Maimonides intertwined philosophic, Islamic, and Jewish sources with which he was either explicitly or likely familiar. Her analyses show how he adopted a phenomenological view toward the development of religion in general and of Judaism in particular (chap. 4); how his approach to medicine combined practical efficiency with theoretical understanding and how his critique of pseudo-sciences also clarified the scope and limit of sciences proper (chap. 5); how his discussion of human perfection and the afterlife meshed with his political views on the one hand and with a traditional Jewish view on resurrection on the other (chap. 6).
Two instances serve to illustrate the intermingling of influences that characterize his Mediterranean culture. In his compilation of Jewish law, the Mishneh Torah, Maimonides avoided citing sources for his rulings, which became a point of criticism among Jewish jurists. However, on Stroumsa’s reading, his methodological approach parallels Almohad theology that bypassed the practice of tracing rulings and offering explanations in favour of reverting to the roots of Islamic law in the Qu’ran. Under Islamic influence, Maimonides thereby introduced a new model into the Jewish legalistic tradition. The other instance concerns a controversy over the view on bodily resurrection. His Treatise on Resurrection poses an enigma (p. 165). On the one hand, Maimonides is reluctant to dwell on the issue and applies a harsh and dismissive tone to the controversy. On the other, although he listed resurrection among articles of faith, the belief is significantly absent from both of his major works: the juridical Mishneh Torah and the philosophic Guide. On Stroumsa’s account, Maimonides elevated the by-then Jewish view on resurrection to an article of faith and only of faith, because of his philosophic views (p. 182). The latter implies a view of human nature that is essentially intellectual, whose perfection is found in a state of contemplation that is eternal and universal. Including it as an article of faith, Maimonides relegated resurrection to the not-to-be-discussed-rationally compartment (p. 182). In this instance, Maimonides clearly separated Jewish faith from philosophic reason.
However, Stroumsa seems too quick to attribute to Maimonides an Averroistic view of universal immortality. Despite an admitted emphasis on intellectual perfection and the implication that contemplation involves union with the Active Intellect, universal immortality clashes with individual immortality, which is implied in Maimonides’ allusions to levels of human perfection in terms of knowledge of God (Guide I: 60), proximity to God (Guide III: 51), and individual identity (Guide III: 54). Moreover, Stroumsa suggests a sharper separation between faith and reason in this instance than Maimonides seems to advocate in other instances. Elsewhere, he endorses faith or traditional beliefs only when reason or philosophical understanding fails to demonstrate a claim or its negation, as he does, for instance, in the case of beliefs about God (rejecting anthropomorphic beliefs because of demonstrations to the contrary) and in the case of a belief in creation (accepting scriptural teachings because of a lack of demonstration). If philosophical views on human perfection and immortality are matters of demonstrative knowledge or even of reasonable belief in the thought of Maimonides, then his view on bodily resurrection as an article of faith becomes problematic. And if they are not, then his stands on faith and reason, on religion and philosophy, become questionable.
Nevertheless, Maimonides in his World shows him to be an original and bold thinker, respecting Jewish tradition while, like Aquinas after him in the Christian tradition, willing to introduce innovation. The book concludes with a methodological approach not only to a reading of Maimonides but also, more generally, to Jewish medieval philosophy. One cannot, should not, read Maimonides the philosopher without being aware of Maimonides the rabbi; nor should one approach Maimonides the erudite thinker and acknowledged leader of a diverse Jewish community without being cognizant of the Islamic and Christian sources to which he would have, or could have, been exposed. Analogously, one should not disassociate Jewish philosophy from the Arabic-Islamic culture in which Judaism found itself in medieval times.
The book is rich in scope and in source material. Nearly half of the volume is taken up by footnotes. That by itself makes it a well of information for a more thorough study and understanding of Maimonides on specific issues within the context in which they arose and within which he developed his views.
