What sets Quinn's account of the often-told tale of the Federal Theatre Project (FTP) apart is its wealth of engaging details, making it an invaluable resource for students of the New Deal. Perusing original sources (from personal correspondences to the Congressional Record), Quinn reconstructs in a compelling and often humorous manner the efforts of Harry Hopkins, head of the Works Progress Administration, and Hallie Flanagan, director of FTP, to build a relief project for thousands of unemployed theatre workers, which would not only provide employment but also produce socially significant art accessible to a large and heterogeneous audience at affordable prices.
Readers follow Hopkins and Flanagan through the initial difficulties of setting up a nationwide network of theatres, combating red tape and union resistance, and recruiting capable and enthusiastic personnel. The author introduces the project's stars (including Orson Welles, John Houseman and Sinclair Lewis) and the supporting cast (such as Eleanor Roosevelt, Brooks Atkinson and George Bernard Shaw), relishing the success of its most triumphant productions. Finally, she invites readers to witness its increasing persecution, heroic resistance and eventual defeat and abolition by Congress. From a scholarly viewpoint, Quinn's portrait remains mostly descriptive, offering little fresh insight into FTP's aesthetics and politics. She also succumbs rather uncritically to the general prejudice against leftism that has marked much of the decade, reducing the WPA workers' union to a noisy and troublesome communist-run organization and dismissing union activism in general, and sit-ins in particular, as ‘rude and confrontational’ and ‘undemocratic’ (p. 176). Likewise, the attribute ‘revolutionary’ is dispensed rather indiscriminately. Without doubt, productions like Cradle Will Rock and Stevedore were, in the spirit of the time, fervently radical in their rhetoric, but they hardly endorsed the overthrow of the American government.
On the contrary, the revolution they hailed in language and symbolism was one that had already taken place. Affirming the legacy of 1776, they exerted pressure on the government to reform the current system so that it would once again represent and protect the interests of the constitutional ‘We, the people’, marking it as more conservatory than revolutionary. The various ways in which it enlisted traditional American values on behalf of pushing for progressive reforms and creating a strong popular front against fascism remain equally unexplored. Quinn does, however, underscore FTP's insistence on integrated audiences and productions and demonstrates to what extent the fear of communism that allegedly ended the project masked a deeply embedded anxiety about the project's progressive racial politics.
