No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 11 April 2005
This is a work of history and economics and a description of how technology transformed 19th-century Iran. It is certain that such changes had social, cultural, and economic ramifications. Willem Floor mainly delves into the last, but his work and his reading into the various travelogues, missives, and official reports could aid in a different reading of the Qajar period. The sources are impressive in their detailed description of the manufacturing of each handicraft. In many ways, this is a history of modern life in Iran, for each of the handicrafts described in this book had a profound effect on everyday life and even national identity. International economic pressure altered everyday lives, and Floor depicts this issue by recounting observations made and historicizing these accounts for each handicraft. Eight handicrafts are discussed in detail, chosen by the author to represent the manufacturing of these goods in Qajar Iran.
How did 19th-century Iran react and position itself vis-à-vis foreign (mostly European) powers economically? This is the wider question answered in chapter 1. The Persian government did not simply “neglect” traditional crafts. The government did respond throughout the 19th century in many ways, from making direct investments to encouraging direct and indirect European involvement in rapid industrialization and setting up tariffs to encourage local and national industries. Floor shows that some traditional handicrafts suffered from foreign competition during this period, but other handicrafts flourished—such as the handwoven carpet industry. Although this particular commodity is not discussed in this book, Floor has devoted a separate monograph to the topic.
“Western penetration had come to Iran as a political and military threat” (p. 21), Floor writes, and this continues to be the manner with which foreign goods were received by the government. Using a multitude of sources, Floor shows how the government fought foreign competition by employing policies to bring materials and factories that built such goods to Iran to promote buying “Persian goods only.” These costly policies failed “because the government was too weak, too ignorant with regard to economic affairs and the requirements of modern technology, and in fact unable to protect its nascent industry” (p. 33).
In the exegesis of the eight handicrafts, the reader moves through the struggles of Qajar Iran with its competitors. Most crafts do not fare well—ceramics, for example. One learns that ceramics, and specifically the art of the craft, were not autochthonous to the famous cities of Kashan and Yazd. Glass also suffers, for the manufacturing of this commodity never constituted an important national industry for several reasons. The most important are the lack of technology and the success of foreign imports. Paper, soap, and mining and metalworks all suffered the same fate. Even with government intervention, the manufacturing of all of these goods eventually suffered against foreign competition, which offered better quality and lower prices.
The gem of the book is the chapter on lighting. All forms of lighting are discussed, dating back to the Safavids. The chapter covers rural and urban areas. The history of public lighting—discussions of the oils, candles, and gas lamps used prior to the establishment of electricity—is especially important. The manner in which 19th-century Persia modernized, publicly and privately, through the transformation of modern life via lighting is extremely important in the history of technology in the emerging nation-state of Iran. As with other handicraft products described in this book, the candle industry tried to transform itself in the face of foreign competition, but local factories failed to produce competitive products because of the lack of know-how and of technology and materials. Floor's meticulous research depicts different types of households and how they used light. Before public lighting, people walked around in the darkness or carried personal lanterns, not just for safety, but for a more important reason: “having a light indicated to the night watch that one was good people” (p. 155).
It is in the discussion of sugar, tanning, and leather crafts that a different view of Qajar Iran is presented. Although sugar was largely imported, the craft of producing sweetmeats flourished in Qajar Iran, for sugar products played an important social, political, and cultural role. Tanning and leather crafts are the successful manufacturing products of this monograph, with the city of Hamadan leading the industry in the region. “The trade in skins, pelts and derived products was important to Iran…. [I]t yielded foreign exchange, because Iran, in financial terms, exported three times more skins and leather products than it imported in 1914” (p. 405). Nineteenth-century Iran did quite well in exporting “goat, sheep and lamb skins” and furs and pelts to Russia, India, and Turkey.
Floor expertly depicts the many different cities, regions, and villages in which each craft was most famous, including details of the guilds involved, the sources of raw materials used, and even detailed accounts of the manufacturing of particular products by the artisans in their own words. Drawing on the writings of the 19th-century French scientist Olmer, who studied traditional Persian industries, and Tahvildar, an Isfahani official-turned-historian, Floor describes local handicrafts with an authoritative voice making extensive use of quotes. Readers who are not familiar with the Qajar period may want to learn more about these and other writers who provide the sources for this work. The overall quality of the scholarship rests on the synthesis of various resources to add to our knowledge of the Qajar period. Scholars of this period will benefit from this original work. This book is invaluable to the history of technology in the Middle East.