It is with great pleasure that we present this special issue showcasing contemporary feminist political research, theories and practices in Canada. In an era characterized by global movements and numerous transformations that range from the economic to the environmental, the political to the cultural, from macro- through to micro-scales, including complex debates about the fluidity of gender, and where “backlash” against the symbols and agents of past feminist activism is rife, this special issue queries where do we find feminism(s) today? The responses to this question, as well as to the interrogation of the place of gender in the discipline of political science more generally, are undoubtedly diverse and contested. The collective efforts contained in this special issue feature a mere taste of the rich range of thought-provoking recent scholarship on feminisms. And even with this necessarily condensed portrayal (the articles in this issue are shorter than is normally the case to allow for more work to be featured), the special issue is ground-breaking in that it marks the first time the Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique has dedicated an entire issue to topics of gender and feminisms.
Current events highlight the central role gender plays in politics. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's matter-of-fact retort, “because it's 2015” to explain the first gender-balanced cabinet in Canada and his government's announcement that, in 2018, African-Nova Scotian civil rights activist, Viola Desmond, will become the first racialized Canadian woman to grace a Canadian bank note might suggest important numeric and symbolic gains for women. At the same time, however, there are many indications that these are tough and turbulent times for women, gender, feminism and politics (broadly conceived), and that we are in the midst of a deepening wave of feminist backlash in Canada and elsewhere.
Consider here, the use of the premier of Alberta, Rachel Notley's image as a golf range target and the frenzied invocations of “lock her up” echoing in the angry shouts directed at Hillary Clinton during the US 2016 presidential race. Internationally, nationally and locally, we have been embroiled in social, legal and political contestations, infused with racialized (and particular forms of religious) intolerance over some women's clothing choices, from hijabs to burkinis. At the same time, women of all kinds (such as politicians, as well as activists, athletes, celebrities, journalists, mothers, teachers, and so forth) are experiencing an unprecedented, “huge scale” of social media misogyny and harassment, including rape and death threats (Ford, Reference Ford2016; Payton, 2015). On campuses, disputes have arisen around non-specific gender washrooms, and from universities to countless other institutions, a spectrum of sexualized violence has been increasingly exposed. Both have been unsatisfactorily acted upon, with the latter prone to cover-ups, downplaying and often inaction. Progress has been painfully slow on many other pressing issues, including the longstanding, abhorrent practices that have given rise to hundreds of missing and murdered Indigenous women in Canada. And, especially given the present American context, there are all too real concerns of multiple forms of equality backsliding.
Within academia, the current wave of backlash reinforces pre-existing hierarchies of patriarchy, colonialism, racism, and trans- and homophobia, putting recent equality gains at risk and making newer ones harder to imagine. Women, and particularly racialized women (see, for example, Griffin et al., Reference Griffin, Bennett and Harris2013; Monforti and Michelson, Reference Monforti and Michelson2008), Indigenous women, sexual minorities and those with disabilities, continue to face distinctive, and respective, impediments, in their universities, political science departments (Bates et al., Reference Bates, Jenkins and Pflaeger2012), in their teaching (Martin, Reference Martin2016), as well as in their research and writing endeavours (Hancock et al., Reference Hancock, Baum and Breuning2013; Maliniak et al., Reference Maliniak, Powers and Walter2013; Mershon and Walsh, Reference Mershon and Walsh2015; Mitchell et al., Reference Mitchell, Lange and Brus2013; Monroe, Reference Monroe2013; Monroe et. al, Reference Monroe, Choi, Howell, Lampros-Monroe, Trejo and Perez2014; Østby et al., Reference Østby, Strand, Nordås and Gleditsch2013). These systemic barriers have detrimental effects on career advancement (Anonymous and Anonymous, 1999; Van Assendelft et al., Reference Van Assendelft, Gunther-Canada, Dolan, Palmer and Swers2003; Wolfinger et al., Reference Wolfinger, Mason and Goulden2008). While this negative impact can be particularly acute for graduate students and less-established faculty regarding acquiring positions and appropriate salaries, discrimination affects all women political scientists in various ways, including the distribution of service responsibilities, securing tenure and promotion, experiencing institutional responsiveness to outside offers (Monroe, Reference Monroe2013; Monroe et al., Reference Monroe, Choi, Howell, Lampros-Monroe, Trejo and Perez2014), and the awarding of distinctions, such as Canada Research Chairs (Samson, Reference Samson2014; Side and Robbins, Reference Side and Robbins2007). These trends exist in Canada (Arscott and Tremblay, Reference Arscott and Tremblay1999; Vickers, Reference Vickers2015), in the US (Beckwith, Reference Beckwith2015; Mershon and Walsh, Reference Mershon and Walsh2015) and elsewhere (Bates et al., Reference Bates, Jenkins and Pflaeger2012; Curtin, Reference Curtin2013; Hancock et al., Reference Hancock, Baum and Breuning2013; Kadera, Reference Kadera2013;Vickers, Reference Vickers2015).
Despite these daunting challenges to women and politics of all kinds, we have witnessed unprecedented resistance. From the Indigenous women instigators behind the Idle No More movement, through to various recent actions including the Women's March on Washington and the many sister marches held across Canada on January 21, 2017, in response to the Trump inauguration. Online campaigns have also emerged to challenge the global attacks on women's equality more broadly (for example, #everydaysexism, #ImWithHer, #RespectHer, #futureisfemale). These actions reveal the commonalities among, as well as the significant points of difference and departures across, women's movement actors as they confront complex issues of voice, appropriation, and intersectionality in political practice.
And so, with these events and debates in mind, this issue offers an affirmative, activist-inspired, academic contribution that motivates progressive change on multiple fronts. First and foremost, this special issue, “Finding Feminisms,” serves as a tribute to the foremothers of Canadian political science and as a confirmation that the work they began decades ago continues unabated and remains as critical today as ever before. Second, it offers a testament to the plethora of approaches to, and the timeliness and relevancy of, current feminist studies by scholars from a diverse set of backgrounds, identities and perspectives. Third, it urges, and hopefully presages and animates, future feminist research and writing in all its diversity and complexity.
Moreover, at the heart of this special issue is a call to action that is positive, inclusive, and pro-active through its efforts to address some of the systemic biases around gender in political science. As Mershon and Walsh explain, “the question of bias in political science is both urgent and longstanding” (Reference Mershon and Walsh2015: 441) because it occurs in our faculties, our research networks, as well as in our journals. In her 2015 Presidential address, Jill Vickers argues that while feminist political science has added new knowledge, it has yet to make a transformative impact on, or be sufficiently integrated into, the mainstream of the discipline (Reference Vickers2015:749). Here, our goal is to challenge the biases that persist in our profession (based on gender, race, indigeneity, ability, sexuality, class and other intersecting identities) by working to diversify its scholarship in a Canadian context.
The guest editorial team took shape during the 2015 Canadian Political Science Association (CPSA) annual meetings in Ottawa. The title of the conference was “Challenges and Opportunities: How Has Gender and Diversity Scholarship Affected Political Science?” Jill Vickers presided as the CPSA President, Cheryl Collier was the programme chair and Tracey Raney assumed the role of section head for Women, Gender, and Politics. Fiona MacDonald and Alexandra Dobrowolsky organized a “Finding Feminisms” micro-panel for the conference featuring ten participants speaking on the feminist opportunities and constraints around issues such as Indigenous and immigrant women's mobilization, LGBTQ politics, social media, partisan political barriers and sexualized violence. Pascale Dufour subsequently joined the team, given her Quebec politics and transnational movement mobilization expertise and as the 2014 award winner of the L'ACSP prix francophone.
While we have been inspired by, and indebted to, all those who have laid the foundations for feminist political science in this country, Jill Vickers is responsible for this collection's genesis, and it, in turn, offers a rejoinder to her Presidential address of June 2, 2015, published in the December 2015 issue of this Journal. We are extremely grateful for her efforts and encouragement. We are also thankful for the support, attentiveness, labour—not to mention, wry humour—of Graham White, the editor of this journal, and the work of his editorial team who helped make this special issue a reality. And, of course, our sincere thanks to the many anonymous reviewers who provided their astute and attentive commentaries, in most cases, on more than one version of manuscript submissions.
As guest editors of this special issue, we bring different experiences and theoretical orientations to the table. Our backgrounds include the subfields of Canadian politics, comparative politics, political theory, public policy and provincial politics. The perspectives that inform our analyses range from feminist institutionalism, social movement theory and political behaviour to critical race and postcolonial feminist studies. The team reflects regional representativeness with members based in Atlantic Canada, Quebec, Ontario and Western Canada. Admittedly lacking representativeness in other respects, our core objectives were to feature, as well as create space and open up new directions in this journal for feminist writing and research across generations (that is, from junior to senior scholars), and from diverse academics on a range of topics. In our call for papers, we foregrounded the importance of including intersectional perspectives on a wealth of concerns. As the flagship journal of Canadian political science, the majority of articles in this special issue pertain to concerns in, or practices of particular relevance to, this country.
In the submission process, the team promoted the special issue through their respective networks (beginning with MacDonald and Dobrowolsky inviting the 2015 “Finding Feminisms” micro-panel participants to submit papers), and an electronic call went out on the CPSA and other relevant list serves. Reminders were also sent out and the call was revised to include one deadline extension. At the end of extensive and intensive processes of internal and external review, the contributors featured in this special issue provide exciting, eclectic critical perspectives on different topics. They draw on various methodologies and different theoretical perspectives and deploy multiple levels of analysis.
Five of the articles in this issue are related to (potential) paths toward new feminist agendas. Fiona MacDonald throws down the gauntlet to expand and diversify our understandings of women, gender and politics in our discipline in order to better grasp the current social transformations and transcend the old understanding of a male-female binary. Scala and Paterson, for their part, look at gender analysts' work in the federal state and how they create spaces for feminist knowledge and activism from “within,” using “micro-levels of resistance.” They suggest that while the public administration tool of Gender-Based Analysis Plus (GBA+) may not result in transformational gender mainstreaming as once promised, it still illustrates the potential for incremental feminist institutional change using available avenues. O'Neill examines the question of political generation in the Canadian feminist movement and how different cohorts of activists have an impact on the movement itself, its collective identity and its strategies. As such, her article provides new ways to understand and approach the challenges of building solidarity in the broader Canadian women's movement across diverse perspectives, including age. Morales Hudon focuses on alliance building between feminisms in Mexico, showing not only the fundamental challenges involved, but also that the redefinition of collaboration and alliances acted as a catalyst for Indigenous women's autonomous political activism. Finally, Tungohan argues that feminism is alive in grassroots migrant women's movements in Canada resisting neoliberalism by establishing “spaces of power.”
A second grouping deals with diversity issues, inside and outside feminism. Harell's article expands our understanding of feminist analyses by identifying the need for an intersectional approach in studies of political behaviour. Drawing on data from Canada's Ethnic Diversity Survey, she illustrates her point by revealing ethno-racial group differences in gender gaps across turnout and civic engagement measures. Dobrowolsky takes on the ongoing political tensions between certain dominant articulations of gender equality and cultural equality through an analysis of the “Charter of Values” legislation designed to prohibit public personnel from wearing or displaying “conspicuous” religious symbols in Quebec. Dobrowolsky reveals how the bill and the political strategies that motivated its proposal hindered complex understandings of culture, gender and feminism and in so doing further undermined efforts to develop meaningful diversity and equality in Canada. Finally, Pagé analyses how and why the francophone queer movement in Quebec was more slowly acknowledged by feminists—and feminist movements—than elsewhere in Canada and even in Europe. Here it is the presence of a queer group, Pink Panther, acting as a broker between queer and feminist activists' milieus that opens up the possibilities of dialogue and mutual transformation.
Another set of articles explores the potentiality of “gender” as an analytical category for political science research. While most political behavioural research tends to rely upon a single measure of sex (which is also often conflated with the concept of “gender”), Bittner and Goodyear-Grant's study shows the importance of gender as a multi-faceted—and important— new category of analysis. Based on original data from six provincial election studies, their argument is supported through a measure of “gender identity salience,” showing how and why this variable matters to an understanding of political attitudes. Manning's ethnographic contribution highlights the complex political context transgender children and their families navigate in Canada, a topic heretofore underinvestigated in political science. She argues that even though parental activists are able to push for new rights related to transgender children, they are still very constrained by intersectional normativity.
In this issue, only one article deals with what might be considered a more “classic” but ongoing feminist issue and concern, women's formal political representation. Ashe's research on the British Labour party shows that if women are underrepresented in politics, it is less because they are not showing up as aspirants but because women are disproportionally filtered out in a party's candidate selection process. This result confirms what feminists claimed for years (if not centuries).
Last but by no means least, in her capacity as chair of the 2015 American Political Science Association's (APSA) Victoria Schuck prize for the best book on women and politics, Jill Vickers' review essay offers a careful reading of gendered research on many pressing political issues, covering topics such as the performance of masculinities in Putin's Russia, the continuing problems associated with theorizing the public/private divide in theories of the state, and sexual violence and colonialism in settler states, including murdered and missing Indigenous women and girls in Canada. Additionally, her review delves into issues of women's reproduction and citizenship, the regulation of women's bodies and autonomies, and analyses of Muslim women's rights in a comparative context.
Overall, the contributors to the “Finding Feminisms” special issue engage with core dimensions of the discipline but also push the boundaries of traditional political science research. In so doing they open the conceptual and methodological tool boxes we use in our analyses, as well as propose a diversification of fields of investigations to include political, social and economic phenomena conventionally at the margins.
It is our hope that “Finding Feminisms” will not be viewed as a “one-off” contribution but rather as an entry point into broader and deeper discussions of the place of gender and feminisms in Canadian political science research, and of the ever-important need to make space for these perspectives in the discipline. We also hope that this special issue could be a source of inspiration for some in our academic community to push the boundaries of feminist political scholarship even further.
