Literary critics and cultural historians have long puzzled over the question of irony in the work of Zora Neale Hurston. A brilliant experimentalist in both her fiction and ethnography, she left both her contemporaries and subsequent readers uncertain: Was she pandering to the “folkloric” desires of white audiences? Or was she playing with them, using the same “signifying” strategies she pointed to in her own analyses of African American cultural expression to appear to satisfy an appetite for exoticism, while actually exposing her audiences' ignorance? Her strategies were consistently ones of deferring meaning and keeping irony unclear. The reader is duly warned: Hurston's Mules and Men ends with the author picturing herself as “Sis Cat,” demurely licking her paws after having devoured a potential critic.
While Hurston's literary production has been scrutinized from various angles and her shrewdness widely acknowledged, Anthea Kraut's Choreographing the Folk draws our attention to another area of Hurston's professional activity that has gone virtually unremarked and unexamined: her production of “folkloric” concert dance performances in a variety of venues beginning in the early 1930s. Kraut convincingly argues that Hurston's staging of the Bahamian Fire Dance (a performance taking multiple forms over the years) was seminal in the theatrical presentation of African diasporic dance practices.
Although Katherine Dunham and Pearl Primus have long been acknowledged as choreographers whose work combined ethnological research and artistic innovation, Kraut asks us to consider the repercussions of Hurston's little-known intervention into the world of black dance. Hurston, like Dunham, Maya Deren, Margaret Mead, and Jane Belo, was among the women ethnographers either directly or indirectly set on their professional paths by Franz Boas, the putative “father” of American anthropology, stalwart antiracist, proponent of cultural relativism and what has come to be known as “auto-ethnography,” and—significantly—lover of dance. The photos of Hurston demonstrating the “Crow Dance,” which ornament the cover of Kraut's book, bear a striking resemblance to the famous photos of Boas himself demonstrating Kwakiutl dance. Why are the Hurston images not as familiar? And why has her involvement in dance spectacle gone virtually unremarked by prior scholars? Kraut combs through the archive, reconstructing an elided history. One of the fascinating threads in the story is Hurston's somewhat frictional, competitive relationship to Dunham (who also had friction with Deren). If Dunham deserves more acknowledgment for the courage and originality of her ethnographic writing, Hurston, it seems, should certainly be recognized for her presentational work in the field of dance.
Choreography is, Kraut notes, a weighty term, and one not usually associated with Hurston. Even scholars familiar with her concert dance works have tended to describe them as “stagings” or “arrangements” of “vernacular” forms. Kraut's project urges us to rethink not only the question of folkloric “authenticity,” but also our conceptions of authorial innovation in relation to dance. The book has the virtue of rigorous archival research, but it also asks us to reconsider some of our basic assumptions regarding the status of those archival materials. How has live performance been categorized and understood in relation to folklore, originality, and intellectual property? Kraut engages with the recent theoretical interventions of African Americanists, performance scholars, and feminist theorists in making a case for Hurston's place as an innovator in the field of dance performance. While Choreographing the Folk is modest in its own theoretical claims, it gathers together, with intelligence and measured judgment, arguments for a more inclusive understanding of what both “choreography” and “folklore” might mean.
Kraut's book is not biographically oriented, nor is it hagiographic. To her credit, Kraut acknowledges the full complexity of Hurston's often ambiguous claims and practices. In staging her performance reviews, Hurston was “simultaneously critical of and complicit with the marketplace's operation and effects” (xi). Anyone who has performed in or has been involved in the production of “folkloric” dance can attest to the fact that both audiences and venues continue to have very constraining expectations from performers. Even the most daring and innovative presentational strategies are often sucked back into a vortex of primitivist desires. But it may be Hurston herself (in the guise of Sis Cat) who shows us the way out of this conundrum: we need to be as attentive to the performance of spectatorial demands as we are to the performance taking place onstage. It's a strategy that Kraut takes up in this quietly authoritative, judicious, and sensitively written narrative.
