This book brings together cross-country evidence to challenge a thinking that has led to the separation of the poverty discourse into distinct strands across the developed north and the developing south. More specifically, it explores the evidence on the contention that the human emotion of shame is at the core of poverty and that it is of consequence for designing policies to address poverty. The original reference to this proposition can be found in the writing of Adam Smith and Amartaya Sen have cogently highlighted it in recent times. The book is an outcome of a larger study ‘Shame, social exclusion and the effectiveness of anti-poverty programmes: a study in seven countries’ supported by UK Economic and Social Research Council and the Department of International Development.
Although obvious at one level, the relationship between shame and poverty is fraught with complexities, social as well as psychological. At a collective level, abject poverty could be a source of shame and embarrassment for a society, compelling it to respond in one of many ways. It may just choose to ignore or hide poverty by, for instance, confining the poor to areas away from the public gaze, or be ethical and create social interventions that seek to gradually capacitate and bring the poor into the social mainstream. At an individual level, some may respond compassionately by sharing their resources willingly, through either tax contributions or charity. For some others, poverty could invoke a sense of indifference and a burden, resulting in an attitude and behaviour that is less sensitive and contributes directly to the repeated shaming of poor people.
For the poor, the sense of shame experienced may prompt them to respond positively and proactively, with a view to preventing future suffering caused by the embarrassment associated with poverty. It could also be the case that the state of deprivation is intense and debilitating, resulting in a sense of helplessness and resignation, which restrains the poor from taking steps to address their material and emotional distress. It is very likely that people living in poverty feel ashamed at not being able to fulfil their own and their dependent's basic needs and aspirations, or to live up to societal expectations due to lack of material means or access to opportunities. They may feel ashamed for being the recipients of public welfare support or even due to their inability to access anti-poverty measures in a given context. Repeated experience of shame hurts and undermines confidence and the individual agency required to break the vicious cycle of poverty and deprivation. It pushes the poor into a marginal existence in isolation from the rest of the society.
The social policy response to poverty has evolved over time with local political-economy concerns, the magnitude of poverty and inequality, as well as the broader public engagement in the issue, all contributing to an articulated approach and its implementation in different contexts. However, the considerations that underpin the relationship between shame and poverty, have not necessarily informed the diverse approaches adopted to address poverty in the developed and the developing world. And that is where this book makes an important contribution. It presents evidence from day-to-day experiences of households living in absolute poverty or with relatively low incomes in China, India, South Korea, Norway, Pakistan, Britain and Uganda, to suggest that there are remarkable similarities in the social and psychological costs of poverty experienced by the poor in these vastly diverse societies.
In the introductory chapter of the book, the authors set the stage to explore the linkage between shame, social exclusion and the impact of anti-poverty programmes. They invoke Sen's capability approach (Sen,Reference Sen1983, Reference Sen2001) and build on it by bringing into play the relational and social aspects of policy process in shaping the impact of policy measures (Taylor, Reference Taylor2011). The country chapters, covering each of the seven countries, while reviewing the broad array of anti-poverty programmes, primarily focus on the discourses, assumptions and the strategies underlying the anti-poverty measures being implemented and how that may be contributing to a heightened sense of shame for the people targeted under the programmes. Three broad themes emerge from the country studies: the shame of poverty is not only about the lack of material means but also about weakened social resources; the mismatch between national policy and local reality is a major factor in the transformation of policy intent into effective delivery; and conditionality when woven into the anti-poverty measures exacerbate the sense of shame among the recipients of those measures. This analysis then leads to the two concluding chapters of the volume that seek to identify the framework for an anti-poverty approach to support individual agency and promote human dignity in the developing and the developed world. The principles outlined in the International Labour in the massive citizens protests such as the ‘IMF’ riots (ILO, 2002) Recommendation 202 (see ILO, 2012) concerning social protection floor have been used for synthesising the findings from the country studies to understand the nature of the relationship between poverty and shame and in building a focus on dignity in social policy.
The principal conclusion of the book as Robert Walker, who led this research, points out in the preface is that promoting human dignity in public discourse on poverty and in anti-poverty measures is not only a matter of social justice, but would enhance policy effectiveness as well. The focus on shame and shaming in policy processes for poverty eradication does break new analytical ground. In that sense, this book will influence the poverty discourse globally. However, in terms of implications for policy prescription, for the present, the study ends up lending a helping hand to the steady momentum building in favour of a human rights approach to poverty eradication, in general and the rights approach to a social protect floor, in particular (see Malhotra, Reference Malhotra2015, forthcoming). For the analysis presented in this book to make a decisive and unique contribution to the global policy discourse on poverty, it is important to further explore and identify the instruments needed to strengthen the social capital of those who live in poverty and find a way to dovetail that with the entitlements necessary for promoting and protecting human dignity. In reinterpreting poverty and the social policy framework to address it, this well-researched and well-structured book will be of interest to researchers, policy makers and students seeking to build a multi-disciplinary scholarship on the subject.
