The study of nonviolent civil resistance is now in vogue. The American Political Science Association gave its best book award this year to Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan, authors of Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict. Additionally, in the last few years, there have been an unprecedented number of academic books, edited volumes, and journal special issues published on this topic, largely due to interest generated by the Arab Spring uprisings and the “color revolutions” in post-communist regions.
Despite this burgeoning scholarship, the academic study of nonviolent civil resistance is still quite new and thus our theoretical and empirical knowledge on this topic is in the early stages of development. Therefore, as I began researching and writing Nonviolent Revolutions, my intent was never to develop a comprehensive model to explain the outcomes of all nonviolent revolutionary movements. Rather, in this relatively uncharted territory, my goal was modest: to generate some plausible theoretical assertions about the factors that shape the trajectories of nonviolent uprisings. Not surprisingly, therefore, Pearlman critiques my book for making a series of inductive insights instead of offering a theoretical model. Indeed, Pearlman is correct on this matter. Yet, in many ways, this book is exploratory, aiming to identify important influences and dynamics within civil resistance struggles. Moreover, with a small sample of six cases, I am reluctant to make strong claims about the significance of factors such as military defections, international sanctions, and internal movement dynamics. My hope is that these assertions are interesting and provocative enough to inspire other scholars to systematically test, refine, or challenge these theories against a wider array of cases.
On a related note, Pearlman states that the “book does not offer a powerful, parsimonious argument.” Here is where our two books differ. To answer her question of why groups choose violent or nonviolent methods, Pearlman develops the “organizational mediation theory of protest” that focuses on a single factor (organizational cohesion) to explain tactical choice. I, on the other hand, identify a larger set of variables that influence movement outcomes. Both approaches have their strengths and limitations. On the one hand, parsimonious models—such as the Political Process model within social movements—have the beauty of being able to clarify and explain a great deal by pointing our attention to a few factors. On the other hand, such models often fail to capture the complexity of movements, as scholars who take a cultural approach to collective action have rightly pointed out. In Nonviolent Revolutions, I hoped to strike a balance between these two approaches. Yet Pearlman is right that the book leans toward a complexity model, which “risks obscuring the more precise and unique analytical contribution.” However, at another point in the review, Pearlman expresses dissatisfaction that my analysis is not complex enough. Specifically, she observes that my discussion of security force defections is too simplistic since I present only two options—defect or remain loyal—without acknowledging other possibilities such as the splintering of the armed forces or the use of foreign mercenaries, as has happened in the Arab Spring cases. (In my defense, though, I note that my analysis was developed from those cases in my study, where troops largely did follow one of only two paths, and the Arab Spring had not yet occurred, which revealed additional military responses to nonviolent revolts.)
Yet Pearlman's overall critique here reveals an important dilemma that we all face: should we aim for parsimonious but perhaps oversimplified models of social movements? Or should we create nuanced, complex yet potentially muddled models of collective action? My hope is that the scholarly community will do both, fostering a dialectical process of knowledge building. While Pearlman's work directs readers' attention to the powerful significance of one factor, my book spurs us to think of myriad variables that may influence a political struggle. Both approaches are valuable.
