Evelyn Tribble's Early Modern Actors and Shakespeare's Theatre: Thinking with the Body performs in the garb of theatre history, plays with the properties of cognitive science, and dances in time with cultural phenomenology. The book builds on Tribble's prior engagements with “distributed cognitive ecologies” (4), reading early modern stage actions as complex interactions with a multiplicity of agencies. Understood through a contemporary neuroscientific and sociological concept of skill, individual writers, players, brains, and bodies become accretions of repeated experiences where a single person “thinking with the body” (5) involves many people and places. Tribble integrates this framework with primary sources on crafts relevant to theatre, finding modern science and early modern practices complementary rather than temporally incongruous.
After the first chapter introduces this ecological framework, the second refines the critical scope to the staged body in motion. Later chapters focus on individual skill sets germane to the early modern English player's body: combat, dance, and transferable skills like memory, awareness, and a sharp wit. In Chapter 2, Tribble develops the idea that the actor's body is a mindful one, rendered such by an extensive regimen of skills training and repeated action. This body communes with audiences that are likewise trained to appreciate and critique displays of skill. Tribble tests this notion of embodied skill against two passages that have befuddled editors: Helena's “choosing scene” in All's Well That Ends Well and Imogen's confusion of Cloten for Posthumus in Cymbeline. Instead of postulating errors by Shakespeare or his characters, Tribble plausibly accounts for these two strange moments with physical choices available to actors. Kinesic intelligence gives actors control of their gait and bearing, allowing them to personate natural qualities and perform natural passions.
Chapter 3 turns to actors’ facility with weapons. Fencing and stage combat, Tribble asserts, call forth bodily habits familiar to players and audiences in daily life, such as the simple act of seeming to walk naturally with a rapier on the hip. These actions also import a multitude of social meanings. Rapiers and English swords, for example, call forth intergenerational, socioeconomic, and geopolitical conflicts, pitting dilettante courtiers against “downright” (72) laborers and honest English folk. Individual actors must move within these registers convincingly to render dramatic stakes meaningful.
Chapter 4 shows that dance likewise carries a density of social meaning and requires extensive skill development. Tribble investigates the “kinesic intelligence” (11) required in dancing to manage not only its fluent performance but also the moral and social evaluations contingent on that performance. The layers of skill here are dense as is the potential for theatrical irony. Dancers, even outside of London's theatres, must brook the critical gaze of peers and superiors with grace, embodying a natural nobility without displaying their art. Onstage, players perform this dynamic, creating an affective spectacle of dance, a structurally important moment in the action, and a metadramatic reflection of the stage and audience within the theatre.
In Chapter 5, drawing on contemporary descriptions of players, Tribble examines the early modern actor's reputation for intellectual and cognitive capacity alongside heightened gymnastic and musical skill. Some requirements, like the rapid memorization and retention of lines, are mandatory to the repertory theatre. Others, like comedic timing, crowd work, and the ability to improvise, apply to a more diverse repertoire. Tribble places these skills within the framework of distributed cognition, outsourcing what modern readers might attribute to individual prowess alone. These skills, she argues, rely on a commitment to the shared experiences, prejudices, and tastes of theatre audiences. As such, the deep labor of memory flattens with the assistance of a multitude of familiar scenarios, character types, plot devices, and stage technologies. The very choices that make plays accessible to audiences (rendered so by repetition and familiarity) also lighten the specific cognitive load of memory, freeing actors to be more mindful of the space, the crowd, and subtle points of variance in the experience. Audiences, likewise trained, can thus appreciate these acting choices.
Throughout the book, Tribble draws distinctions between early modern and contemporary practices in terms of skilled preparation. In dance, as in combat, these differences present challenges to twenty-first-century “original practices” productions (148), the subject of her final chapter. Early modern dances, such as the pavan and galliard, no longer carry the social resonances they once did, so current audiences are not trained to view them, and current actors must train hurriedly and specifically to perform them. Extensive experience with weapons—both on the stage and off—prepared early modern actors for spectacular and convincing fights and gave them more space to improvise expertly. Modern productions require extensive fight choreography and rehearsals and must manage a variety of experience levels. According to fight captains Tribble interviews, they frequently must sacrifice verisimilitude for safety.
Tribble's book occupies a similar critical space as other recent works of early modern theatre history, especially in its commitment to material and affective history. Like Farah Karim-Cooper's The Hand on the Shakespearean Stage (2016), it foregrounds gesture as a means to reading the flow of passion in staged performance. Tribble's work distinguishes itself methodologically by inventively extending Pierre Bourdieu's theory of habitus. She uses contemporary cognitive science to broaden Bourdieu's notion of skill beyond the difficult distinction between conscious and unconscious nervous control. This allows her to engage with a more diverse range of theatrical practices as contributors to skill acquisition.
As a work of theatre history, Early Modern Actors and Shakespeare's Theatre is a compelling introduction to the breadth and depth of players’ practices. Its concise and direct prose renders difficult historical and scientific concepts simple to navigate, if not easy to resolve. The text is efficient and fluent, demonstrating its claims using an extensive collection of brief but cogent readings, which it prefers to lengthier, closer interpretations of a given playtext. This invigorating book offers a model for more sustained academic engagement with acting as both historical practice and contemporary craft. As such, it amply serves both researchers and practitioners invested in early modern stage action.
