The three books reviewed here all examine the ways in which globalization or economic liberalization has impacted the strategies and ability of organized labor to defend its interests. Beyond this very general common theme, the books also illustrate their theoretical arguments with the juxtaposition of unexpected and interesting cases, often pairing developed with developing countries or established democracies with emerging ones. The comparisons also span broad geographical or cultural regions. The result is a set of theoretical insights and arguments that will be of significance to a broad range of political scientists and sociologists interested in understanding the role of labor organizations in contemporary society, politics, and policymaking.
In Organizing at the Margins, Jennifer Jihye Chun answers the question: As globalization erodes the structural power of organized labor, how can workers claim and expand their associational power? Structural power derives from position in the economy, whereas associational power derives from collective organization (p. 10). Her study suggests that workers, even those most vulnerable in the labor market, can leverage “symbolic power” (cf. Pierre Bourdieu, Pascalian Meditations, 2000) to reclassify their contractual or employment status, thereby increasing their associational power. Key to these strategies was the ability to draw upon lessons and networks from earlier Civil Rights or worker struggles in both the United States and South Korea.
The first half of Chun's study documents comparable shifts in the labor market and in union strategies in the United States and South Korea. In both countries, expansion of the service sector has contributed to the growth of a marginalized labor force, with a significant concentration of women and ethnic or racial minorities. The author also illustrates the shifts in organization and mobilization strategies by segments of the organized labor movement in both countries in response to these shifts in the labor market. To highlight the ways that workers can leverage symbolic power to enhance their associational power, she uses case studies of university janitors and independent contractors. The case studies of janitors at the University of Southern California (1996–98), Harvard University (1999–2001), Seoul National University (1999–2000), and Inha University (1999–2001) illustrate how workers were able to organize and mobilize symbolic power in “public dramas” that challenged the “moral authority” of universities that had begun subcontracting their janitorial services. The workers built alliances with students or workers' movements to force universities to acknowledge their role as employer despite subcontracting arrangements. In addition, Chun compares efforts by home-care workers in Los Angeles County (1987–2000) and golf caddies at a private country club in Kyonggi-do County (1990–2001) to organize into unions despite their ambiguous status as independent contractors. In both cases, workers tapped into existing union networks or formed alliances with other social movements and used appeals to legal interpretations by courts or the state to establish their right to organize and negotiate collective terms of employment.
Like Chun, Dorothy J. Solinger is interested in understanding the contextual factors that shape labor's strategies and its ability to shape outcomes. In States' Gains, Labor's Losses, her ultimate objective is to explain labor's propensity to protest neoliberal economic reform and the state's willingness to compensate workers for dislocations due to globalization and economic liberalization. The analysis begins with an exposition of the ways in which three states with relatively extensive intervention in their domestic economies—France, Mexico, and China—liberalized their economies in response to real or perceived economic crises in the late 1970s or early 1980s. According to Solinger, economic reform entailed a conscious decision by political elites to abandon earlier bargains with organized labor and, instead, seek external reinforcement for reforms via membership in supranational economic organizations in the three cases. She presents a convincing narrative highlighting similar economic and political decisions across all three.
Although labor faced similar economic liberalization policies, its response, however, varied across the three countries, with relative acquiescence in both Mexico and France compared to heightened mobilization and protest in China. Solinger asserts that the variation in labor's response reflected the “terms of attachment,” or dominant mode of labor–state relations, prior to economic reform. In France, unions lacked formal ties to partisan politics, but were also fragmented in a way that diluted their political voice (pp. 33–35). This fragmentation also limited labor's ability to effectively demand compensation for economic liberalization measures (p. 156). In Mexico, official unions exchanged regime support for some limited voice in policymaking (p. 42), but economic and political reforms in the 1980s and 1990s undermined labor's capacity for protest and policy influence (p. 164). In contrast, in China, where unions were formally attached to the ruling party but were never effective interlocutors for workers' interests (p. 30), unemployed and underemployed workers had nothing to lose from protest, while internationalization limited the state's willingness to violently repress workers (pp. 147–48). Solinger then argues that this cross-national variation in labor protest following economic liberalization explains an expansion of compensatory policies, such as unemployment insurance and new income subsidies in China, in contrast to either maintenance or erosion of compensatory benefits in France and Mexico.
Similarly, Agnieszka Paczyńska's State, Labor, and the Transition to a Market Economy explains variation in the ability of organized labor to influence policy outcomes—in this case, the design and implementation of privatization of state-owned enterprises. According to Paczyńska, neither political regime type nor sequencing of political and economic liberalization adequately explains variation in labor's influence. Poland and the Czech Republic engaged in privatization after democratic transition, whereas privatization in Egypt and Mexico proceeded under authoritarian rule. Nevertheless, the influence of labor on privatization was greater in both Poland and Egypt than in either the Czech Republic or Mexico.
Instead, Paczyńska argues that labor's resources prior to privatization's reaching the reform agenda explain the variation. That is, where divisions within the ruling elite and external allies created opportunities for labor to extract procedural concessions such as fiscal autonomy and legal prerogatives, as opposed to substantive concessions like wage increases or welfare benefits, labor was able to leverage these procedural resources to shape the design and implementation of privatization. Throughout, the author also claims that “experiential resources gained from past contentious encounters with the state” (p. 20). However, this aspect of the argument is undertheorized and empirically difficult to evaluate or follow through the cases, compared to the concrete and very convincing ways in which worker participation in enterprise management or legal rights to participate in policymaking provided direct avenues for labor influence. Nevertheless, she adroitly demonstrates that in both Poland and Egypt, organized labor was able to use its role in enterprise management or its legal prerogatives to effectively shape the design of privatization plans and later to delay or stall privatization implementation. In contrast, organized labor had little influence over the design or implementation of privatization in the Czech Republic or Mexico.
Collectively, these three books suggest that neither economic development nor political regime type is central to and understanding of the relationship among globalization, economic liberalization, and the power of organized labor. By highlighting comparable cases of labor organizing and mobilization within similar national patterns of precarious employment and its expansion in the United States and South Korea, Chun challenges the notion that labor faces fundamentally different obstacles in the developed as opposed to developing world. Instead, we are to conclude that workers “at the margins” of the economy face similar pressures and opportunities everywhere. At the same time, her cases suggest that workers must be able to claim the moral high ground in labor disputes or appeal to allies that support their claims. It is unclear whether such resources are available to all types of worker movements in all national contexts. By comparing countries at markedly different levels of economic development, Solinger, like Chun, explicitly challenges the notion that level of development is central for understanding variation in labor mobilization and compensation for economic liberalization. Instead, her cases and findings contradict the conventional wisdom that labor mobilization and compensation are most likely in developed economies.
Similarly, these books imply that political regime type or democratic experience does not explain variation in labor strategies and influence in the context of economic liberalization pressures. Again, Solinger's comparison turns expectations on its head, with the least democratic case, China, seeming to have both the greatest labor mobilization and protest and most extensive state compensation for workers, compared to either democratizing Mexico or democratic France. Conversely, perhaps workers in Mexico and France sought or achieved influence through democratic openings or normal partisan politics, a possibility that is discounted in her analysis. For instance, by emphasizing the election of a right-leaning president in 2000 in Mexico (pp. 139–40), Solinger underestimates the extent to which organized labor was taking advantage of the political opening to redefine its relationship with the ruling and opposition political parties in the 1990s. Meanwhile, in France, the evidence suggests that the state responded quickly to worker unrest with compensatory measures (pp. 153–54), perhaps suggesting that the escalation of labor protests was not necessary for achieving labor's desired outcome in a democratic context. Despite these differences in interpretation of the evidence, Solinger consistently highlights similar ways in which labor's role in the ruling coalition has come under attack in the context of economic liberalization across all three cases, regardless of political regime type. Like Solinger, Paczyńska explicitly rejects the usefulness of political regime type as an analytical tool for understanding the capacity of labor to influence privatization outcomes. Although political regime type is perhaps oversimplified into dichotomous categories, her paired comparisons quite convincingly demonstrate that union resources are more crucial for understanding labor's ability to shape privatization design and implementation.
If economic development and political regime type do not explain variations in labor power and influence, what does? According to these books, the outcomes or legacies of prior labor struggles, including formal institutional arrangements and informal experiences, are central to future labor power and outcomes.
For Solinger, it is preexisting state–labor arrangements, what she calls “terms of attachment,” that shape the extent to which labor uses protest in response to economic liberalization and labor dislocation. Likewise, Chun highlights the importance of past labor struggles as a resource for future movements. In the United States, these were the Civil Rights and union struggles of the 1960s and early 1970s. In South Korea, it was the democratic and women's union movements in the 1990s. These earlier movements provided symbolic resources, social networks, and lessons about strategy that became powerful legacies and tools for later movements to leverage in their struggles for recognition. Finally, Paczyńska highlights the ways in which past outcomes from labor conflicts generate future resources that unions can use to influence policy outcomes. In particular, she highlights the relative value of substantive versus procedural concessions as a future source of labor power or influence. Whereas substantive concessions like wage increases and related benefits may increase workers' quality of life, procedural concessions ensure workers' future political or fiscal autonomy or ability to influence enterprise management or public policy.
These findings, which suggest a certain amount of path dependence, consequently raise other questions for the future of organized labor. In particular, if the outcomes of past labor conflicts or relationships with the state shape future possibilities, the question then becomes one of whether or under what circumstances we might expect labor to be able to break with the past. In other words, if labor movements do not have useful institutional or experiential resources or legacies upon which to draw, are there means or strategies by which labor can overcome these deficiencies? This is not merely an academic question but one with practical implications for workers' movements and organizations as well.
