In the context of the Europe 2020 Strategy, the June 2010 European Council endorsed a target on the reduction of poverty and social exclusion in the European Union of 20 million persons by 2020 (European Council, 2010). This decision was reached after a short but intense period of discussion among Member States in the European Social Protection Committee on which indicator(s) this target should be based. Starting with a proposal from the European Commission in March 2010 (European Commission, 2010) to set the target on the at-risk-of-poverty rate (60% of median income threshold), indicators of material deprivation and low work intensity were subsequently taken on board to identify the target population. Thus, finally the target population was identified as those persons who are at-risk-of-poverty and/or who are materially deprived and/or who live in a household with a low work intensity. The decision to include a social target in the Europe 2020 strategy is an important political sign, but it also constitutes a major evolution for all those who have been working on social protection and social inclusion indicators.
Brian Nolan and Christopher Whelan clearly frame their new book in the work on indicators and targets at EU level. The aim of the book is ‘to explore why and how non-monetary indicators of deprivation can play a significant role in complementing (not replacing) income in order to capture the reality of poverty in Europe’ (p. 1). Among the issues that are treated in the book are the place of deprivation in the EU social inclusion indicators set, the impact of the enlargement of the EU on the measurement of poverty via income and deprivation measures, the mismatch between income poverty and material deprivation, the dynamics of poverty, the Europeanisation of reference groups, welfare state and social class variation. All these issues are discussed from a measurement perspective: what is the best way to identify the poor? The book concludes with an assessment of the Europe 2020 target.
In the final chapter, the authors note that ‘no explicit rationale has been advanced at EU level’ for the choice of the target indicators, and how they are combined (p. 229). The books major strength is that it does make explicit the conceptual context of non-monetary poverty indicators. It does this in a very systematic and empirically based, but at the same time, non-technical manner. Furthermore, overall, the different analytical perspectives offer a convincing argument for the use of non-monetary indicators to complement income-based measures. This makes the book a valuable and very timely reference point for further work on the monitoring of poverty and social exclusion in the EU.
The confrontation of EU measures with the analysis of the authors gives rise to some critiques on the former. To give a few examples, a first issue on which there is disagreement is the selection of indicators for the deprivation measure and the dimensionality at which the two arrive. The EU deprivation measure is based on 9 items (combining a ‘financial stress’ and ‘lack of durables’ dimension). The authors arrive at a ‘consumption deprivation’ measure of 7 items. Contrary to the measure of the authors, the EU measure excludes the enforced absence of a computer. On the other hand, the EU measure includes the enforced absence of a phone, a washing machine and a colour TV, whereas these are not included in the authors’ measure. The six other items are identical for the two measures (food, heat, a holiday, a car, avoiding arrears and being able to meet unexpected expenses). The authors present convincing evidence for their choice of items. However, a revision of the EU material deprivation indicator is prepared for the mid-term review of the Europe 2020 strategy by 2015. This revision will be based on a broader set of items and will require a whole new item selection process, where the authors’ approach may well be taken into consideration.
A second point of disagreement concerns the use of three indicators to define the Europe 2020 target on poverty and social exclusion. As already noted above, the authors point to the lack of a clear conceptual basis for the choice made. In line with their plea for a combined use of income and deprivation measures to identify the poor, the authors question the inclusion of the low work intensity indicator. They argue that it is conceptually not clear why persons in low work intensity households that are neither income poor nor materially deprived should be included in the target population. Furthermore, they show that the inclusion of this indicator results in less differentiation in terms of poverty and social exclusion among Member States.
Indeed, in defining the highly visible target, the approach taken in the political context of the Europe 2020 strategy clearly differed from an academic or purely national approach. To reach an agreement among the Member States, the target needed to reflect different situations and policy priorities. Still, the point remains valid that ‘in order to be able to fight social exclusion effectively, we need to be able to measure it accurately’ (Vandenbroucke, Reference Vandenbroucke, Atkinson, Cantillon, Marlier and Nolan2002: 240) and so also this point should be taken seriously when evaluating the European strategy and the poverty/social exclusion target.
For the reader involved in the policy process who wants to upgrade his/her knowledge on the issue of deprivation and multidimensional poverty, the part on ‘economic vulnerability’ and multiple deprivation (chapter 8) will probably prove to be the toughest one. The discussion on the content of and relation between concepts of multidimensional poverty, social exclusion, while adding the concept of ‘economic vulnerability’, is somewhat less transparent, and more inconclusive, than other parts of the book. While one can ask if it is useful to add another notion (vulnerability) to existing, still rather vague, notions, it must be admitted that the results presented are interesting. However, it is safe to assume that further work will be required for this notion and methodology to enter into the (EU) policy process.
The focus of the book is on material deprivation as a complement to income-based poverty measures and not on the material deprivation measure as such. This implies that specific methodological issues with policy relevance, related to material deprivation are not treated here. For example, for policy purposes, the situation of subgroups is of great importance and a discussion of the consequences of using a fixed set of items for subgroups with divergent needs would be very useful, as well as further work on understanding the behaviour of individual items, as indicated in the book. Meanwhile, it must be hoped that the book will be extensively used in the EU social inclusion monitoring process.
