Until the mid-1970s, the Indian National Congress dominated Indian politics like a colossus. In considerable part it was able to do so because the party had been an umbrella organization. Owing to its organizational structure, the party had subsumed a variety of competing interest groups; it had extensive grassroots support across the country, and had thereby limited the role of regional political parties on a nationwide basis. However, as a number of political scientists, most notably Robert L. Hardgrave, Jr., and Paul Brass, demonstrated, Prime Minister Indira Gandhi played a vital role in undermining the organizational sinews of the party at the state and local levels and in aggrandizing power at the national level. Hardgrave, in fact, used a rather apt cultural metaphor to describe Gandhi's role: he likened her to the banyan tree under whose shade little grows.
In the process, the party atrophied and regional parties increasingly came to the fore. Faced with these developments, Gandhi came to see the emergence of regional parties as direct threats to Congress's dominance. Worse still, on occasion, she often suggested that they constituted threats to India's integrity. Not surprisingly, she resorted to various dubious methods to undermine them. The adverse consequences of her decisions were considerable. In some cases, states from Assam in the northeast to Punjab in the north witnessed the genesis of insurgencies which, at least in part, could be attributed to Gandhi's high-handed actions toward various regional parties.
By the late 1980s, with the steady decline of the Congress Party, India had started to witness a series of coalition governments. These governments were frequently composed of an agglomeration of regional political parties. Owing to their particular interests, which frequently diverged, many of these coalition regimes proved unstable and had a limited shelf life. Even after the rise of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in the late 1990s and its assumption of power at the national level in 1998, regional parties nevertheless retained their importance. Indeed, the first national BJP regime remained dependent on a range of regional partners. Despite being the dominant partner in the National Democratic Alliance coalition regime, the BJP was thereby forced to take the views of its diverse membership into account on crucial policy issues.
Adam Ziegfeld's book Why Regional Parties? constitutes an important contribution to the theoretical and empirical literature on the emergence and evolution of regional political parties in India. One of the key strengths of this work is that it squarely places the analysis in the larger stream of theoretical literature focused on regional political parties. Another of its novel features is its focus on the role of clientelism in sustaining regional political parties. Finally, it makes a significant contribution to the study of political parties in India. Ziegfeld rejects the proposition that regional parties succeed because of specific programmatic appeals. Such an argument would focus on voters who develop an allegiance to particular political parties based upon their political messages and policy platforms. This amounts to a significant advance in the extant literature because of the careful theoretical grounding of the argument and evidence.
The sheer richness and complexity of this work necessitates focusing on and highlighting some of its key findings. One of its more counterintuitive and intriguing conclusions is that regional identity is not strongly associated with voting for a regional political party. Instead, Zeigfeld demonstrates on the basis of ample evidence that elites and their clients constitute key determinants of the success of a regional political party.
Zeigfeld also shows that certain structural and institutional features of India's political system have facilitated the growth and subsequent success of regional political parties. These include political and fiscal decentralization, horizontal decentralization, parliamentarianism, low electoral thresholds, single-member districts, and no cross-regional contestation laws. In turn, he scrupulously explores how each of these factors have facilitated the rise of regional parties.
The book also deftly explores why regional parties have been more successful at particular times than others. One of the key contributing factors, Zeigfeld argues, is the likelihood of a party being part of a national government. This, in turn depends upon the presence of a coalition government at the national level. The advent of coalition governments in the late 1980s in considerable part explains the success of regional parties. In making this argument, Zeigfeld explicitly rejects the contention that regional political parties brought about the growth of coalition governments.
Given its substantive sweep, its dexterous disconfirmation of alternative explanations, and its adroit amassing of both qualitative and quantitative evidence, Why Regional Parties? constitutes a vital addition to the extant literature on the subject. It should be of considerable interest to scholars of comparative politics in general and scholars of contemporary Indian politics more specifically.
