Nostalgia for the Modern: State Secularism and Everyday Politics in Turkey is a fine contribution to a multidisciplinary, rich, and sophisticated discourse on contemporary Turkey.
In this study Esra Özyürek analyzes how and why official ideology and politics moved beyond the conventional boundaries of the state in Turkey during the late 1990s, and she demonstrates how the different spheres of economic, civil, domestic, or personal life are actually linked to and mold each other. Based on fieldwork carried out in Ankara and Istanbul, Özyürek studies how secular state ideology, politics, and symbolism found a new space and validity in the private realms of the market, the home, civil society, life history, and emotional attachment just as political Islam began to occupy the civic and private spheres. She also explores shifting meanings and boundaries in various concepts ranging from citizenship to private versus public.
The author provides us with a rich ethnography, a sophisticated and nuanced theoretical frame, and a historical perspective through which we can understand her data and conclusions. She makes use of important and relevant notions from fields such as feminism to complicate her discussion of global and local understandings of private versus public as she seeks to understand how local political actors reshape their definitions of what is private and public and what is political and what is not. In her study she focuses on nostalgia as a way to study what was once public and political but has been privatized in post Cold War Turkey: she posits that nostalgia has been an integral part of modernity and asks how the more recent nostalgia is related to the neoliberal modernity in which it flourishes. Özyürek argues that when Kemalist Turks could not locate modernity in the present or future of Turkey or the present of Europe, they looked for it in the single-party regime of the 1930s.
The author has a concern, which she shares in her introduction. She tells us that her study became a tool to negotiate her relationship with her parents. In addition, her parents facilitated her research by providing her with contacts and information about ongoing political activities, television programs, relevant newspaper articles, and so forth. Although readers may appreciate her honesty, her fear is unwarranted. She has made excellent use of the sources she was able to access due to her family connections.
Özyürek's book is a welcome addition to the discussion on contemporary Turkey. A variety of discourses on contemporary Turkey informed by political science, anthropology, and sociology intersect in this work. It is not only well researched and well written but also presented in a frame that allows it to be of interest to scholars and a larger audience that may be interested in the concepts of citizenship, modernization, and nostalgia rather than Turkey. The author opens up new venues of thought and new questions for future works in this field. For example, the European Union commissions dealing with Turkey have members of Turkish origin. How are these European Turks or Turkish Europeans complicating the discussion on citizenship both in their positions with the European Union bureaucracy but also in the private sphere?
