Why are facts in plain sight sometimes invisible? Psychologists call this selective perception: humans tend to see what they expect to see, such as men fighting war. Henrietta Roelofs, a YWCA organizer quoted in Lynn Dumenil's superb new book, expressed her frustration about precisely this phenomenon: “Can we not get into our minds the actual status of women from a military point of view … the actual value of women in winning the war,” she fumed (1). Roelofs had personally arranged Paris billets for uniformed females in the U.S. Army Signal Corps, yet the army still blindly maintained that the women running battlefield communications were not actually serving in France.
The Second Line of Defense examines women's wartime roles as organizers, activists, workers, and military personnel. Dumenil illuminates faces that would have been familiar in factories, railroads, government offices, army bases, hospitals, and even near the firing line on the Western Front, but that have since been forgotten. Dumenil's comprehensive, imaginative account sweeps away any remaining excuse not to “know” that women played a vital historical role during World War One. She also asks why the New Woman who seemed everywhere in 1918 vanished in 1920.
The wartime emergency drew four million men into the armed forces. It heightened demand for food, arms, ammunition, telecommunications, mass transportation, and all other requirements of an industrialized conflict. As Dumenil shows, women leaped into the breach, taking many jobs previously held by men. Some did so to improve their economic prospects, others out of patriotism. For suffragists, the war provided a rare opportunity to prove women's fitness for full citizenship. Indeed, the “Wilsonian war message of a ‘war for democracy’ seemed tailor-made for the suffrage cause” (37). Activists kept women's contributions before the public eye to secure passage of the Nineteenth Amendment, giving female workers of the First World War more celebrity than Rosie the Riveter in the Second—until they were forgotten.
Numbering in the millions, these women seemed everywhere. In Washington, DC, females claimed 75 percent of all new wartime jobs. Dumenil's account finds them in munitions plants, manufacturing facilities, and municipal transport, earning higher wages than ever before. It finds them on the railroads, where they cleaned tracks; worked in machine shops, took tickets, operated controls, and performed other jobs normally monopolized by men. It finds them knitting socks, preparing care packages, and harvesting fields. Women of all racial and ethnic backgrounds pitched in, whether as workers or volunteers.
Yet as exciting as the war was to those who flouted gender norms in order to serve, Dumenil argues it was a flash in the pan rather than the catalyst for any “profound change in gender relations or women's status” (5). Political reform was underway before the war, and limped along afterward. The Industrial Revolution had long since expanded labor outside the home. Women attained the vote during the year, and female clerical workers enjoyed a growing share of white-collar jobs (up from 37 to 50 percent), but beyond these two developments, women mostly failed to hold onto their new opportunities. Well-paid positions disappeared, the vote yielded little political influence, and awareness of female contributions dimmed. Flippant flappers replaced purposeful New Women.
Even those who had braved submarine and aerial warfare to serve in France as ambulance drivers, clerks, canteen workers, and telephone operators found themselves marginalized. The army, which used more than 22,000 women overseas, undercut their achievements and denied them formal recognition upon return. (In contrast, the Navy and Marines, which inducted 11,000 women to serve at home, granted full benefits.) Congress even refused female veterans a charter for their own organization when the congressionally approved American Legion denied them membership. Instead, Dumenil tellingly reveals, Congress granted a charter to American War Mothers, whose “service” better fit conventional notions of the female role in war: namely, to stay home and hand over one's sons uncomplainingly.
Male resistance caused some of the problem. Unsurprisingly, returned soldiers wanted their jobs back. The American Federation of Labor and other unions forced women out, insidiously suggesting that “the finest of women” had no interest in taking men's places (201). Females who balked at their pink slips met with such overt hostility that they soon conceded the field. Hollywood films that once depicted venturesome young women as plucky heroines recast them after the war as mannish “freaks” if they wanted to continue in new occupations (253). Established political parties sidelined women when they discovered that former suffragists could not deliver votes reliably.
Female reformers lost momentum as well. Women unionists resisted the Equal Rights Amendment for fear that it would jeopardize special protections in the workplace. Political leaders failed to bridge differences among factionalized followers. White suffragists gave African American women little if any support for their attempts to challenge Southern disenfranchisement following ratification of the Susan B. Anthony Amendment.
Dumenil weighs evidence with a careful hand. Consistent with her desire to evaluate how much things changed or remained the same, the author avoids sensationalizing her subject. Instead, she skillfully blends continuities and discontinuities, proving that “real changes” took place between 1900–1930 because of long-term shifts, not the Great War.
Nonetheless, Lynn Dumenil establishes without a doubt in this important overview that women provided matchless, indispensable service in a time of national crisis. The Second Line of Defense re-creates the vibrant, bustling, complex world that women carried upon their shoulders. Readers have no further excuse not to see them.
