At a time when mention of Syria, in both public discourse and scholarly work in North America, tends to be linked to the “war on terror” or the United States' violent attempts to reconfigure the Middle East, Christa Salamandra's A New Old Damascus: Authenticity and Distinction in Urban Syria provides a breath of fresh air. Based on field research conducted between 1992 and 1994 in Damascus, the book's focus on what she alternately calls the “old leading families” or “Damascene elite,” also positions it to contribute to another understudied area, that of the anthropology of elites (e.g., “studying up”).
Building on Bourdieu's insights about distinction and the relationship between consumption and social status, Salamandra is primarily interested in the construction of elite Damascene identity through consumption and cultural production. She argues that Damascus and “Damasceneness” work as focal points for debates and arguments about identity, status, authenticity, and prestige, and that such contestations take place primarily through “agonistic criticism” or “the poetics of accusation” (p. 22). The book's chapters trace these contested discourses as they emerge in the production of a wide variety of visual and textual evocations of the old city. Specifically, Salamandra touches on the history and urban geography of Damascus, gender and competitive display, commodification of heritage through leisure sites such as restaurants, Ramadan practices and television serials, memoirs, and other forms of cultural production.
The two penultimate chapters are the highlights of the book. Here Salamandra provides rich depictions of Ramadan practices among the elite and the ostentatious display that characterizes both fasting and fast breaking, alongside local critique of that ostentation from within the community. This is followed by analyses of several Ramadan television serials in relation to the construction of “Old Damascus” as a trope identified with a particular segment of the urban elite. The following chapter takes up the memoirs, visual arts, and documentary films that are redolent with nostalgia for the old city and contribute to its association with status. Salamandra weaves analyses of folklore and architecture with discussion of notions of authenticity and tradition as employed by her elite interlocutors as they shape discourses of the city.
The chapter addressing gender and consumption also warrants mention. On the one hand, the inclusion of this detailed discussion of women's sociability is one of the few places in the book in which Salamandra's argument that “agonistic competition is a key mode of sociability among elite Syrians” is explicated ethnographically. On the other hand, the critiques of prior scholarly literatures in anthropology and gender studies that emerge through the chapter are dependent on generalizations and lack the citational apparatuses and historical depth that would lend them specificity and weight. For example, reference to “the giggling harem parties suggested in most literature on Middle Eastern women” (p. 61) does not take into account recent work that does not fit this stereotype or differences of ethnographic context. Such statements have the unfortunate effect of reducing Salamandra's well-taken argument for integrating analyses of contestation or social hostilities into research on social dynamics to an agonistic plea for an anthropology of antipathy.
One always desires of ethnographies more than it is possible to provide in a limited space. In the case of A New Old Damascus, the book's strengths—especially its inclusion of multiple voices and the author's skillful weaving of myriad aspects of cultural practice and production—lead to its main limitation. The reader is left with a clear sense of the discursive contests and variation of perspective within the “Damascene” scene, yet is left without a map of the social, political, and economic landscape through which to interpret that variation. The ethnographic aspects of the text would be improved by greater attention to family ties, social relationships, and the ways that socioeconomic class and status work on a daily basis for her interlocutors. Similarly, although Salamandra's deliberate underattention to the role of the Syrian state and to Islam is a welcome shift, for a nonspecialist reader the book errs on the side of too little, as these and other factors lay the context for the contested discourses that are her focus. A final set of questions that arise—perhaps for future study—has to do with the role of transnational relationships in this field of discursive production. Globalization is invoked several times in the book, but an analysis of how ideas about consumption, heritage, and identity travel—especially in relation to Beirut and Istanbul, two nearby capitals where similar issues are debated—would add another layer of depth.
Despite these shortcomings, Salamandra has written a fascinating account of the discursive deployment of “Old Damascus” as a trope linked to the construction and contestation of an elite identity. When read in this vein, A New Old Damascus is a nuanced depiction of local manifestations of classic modes of constructing tradition in the service of a quintessentially modern identity. It should be of interest to scholars in Middle East studies and cultural studies, and could be used in an undergraduate classroom along with other texts that provide a political framework for students.
