Omar Pereyra's ethnographic study begins with an abrasive, morning encounter between a dark-skinned woman in her thirties, wearing jogging pants, and a lighter, formally dressed woman in her seventies. The younger woman is walking her dog. The older woman, employing a disdainful tú, loudly informs her that she needs to clean up after her animal. The accused draws a plastic bag from her pocket and insists that she is a ‘clean person’ who does not require instruction or supervision. Their confrontation takes place in Residencial San Felipe, a large, middle-class apartment complex in Lima's Jesús María neighbourhood. It highlights Pereyra's main concern: tensions between the ‘traditional middle class’ and the ‘new middle class’, especially as they play out between older residents and younger, recent arrivals.
San Felipe was created by Fernando Belaunde's government to serve the needs of the growing, post-war middle class. As it happens, Pereyra grew up in San Felipe, a son of the first generation that settled there in the 1960s. Since then, successive waves of families have come to San Felipe, their shifting characteristics representative of the changing composition of the middle class.
Pereyra returned to San Felipe in 2011 to study, along lines suggested by the work of sociologist Michele Lamont, the symbolic, ‘us-them’, boundaries that residents recognise among themselves and the consequences these boundaries have for their everyday lives. He distinguishes four groups of residents, emphasising the social ‘trajectories’ of each: first, the ‘Seniors’, the original settlers, now in their seventies. They are first- or second-generation Limeños, who came to San Felipe from older, formal areas of the city (that is, not the ‘informal’, outlying shantytowns) or from larger provincial cities. They were professionals and white-collar workers, often government employees and military officers. Wives did not work. They were formal men and women and practising Catholics. Having arrived together, with large, young families, they developed an intense social life. They are and see themselves as mestizos, but with lighter skins and whiter features than those who came later. The ‘Adults’ form the second group, a slightly younger cohort, similar to the first group, who arrived in the 1970s and 1980s. The third group is comprised of the adult children of the first group, who have remained in or have returned to San Felipe. ‘Newcomers’, the recently arrived contemporaries of the third group are the fourth group. They come from deteriorating Lima neighbourhoods or former shantytowns, now ‘incorporated’. The Newcomers are first-generation middle class and darker-skinned than the earlier arrivals. Like the adult children, they have university degrees or technical qualifications as well as the advantage of two salaries, which enable them to afford the current high price of a San Felipe apartment.
Pereyra contends that the essential social cleavage in San Felipe is between the Newcomers and the other three groups, which he identifies with the gap between the old and the new middle class. But his material often suggests that strictly generational differences are at least as important. For example, his systematic comparison of the ‘dimensions of worth’ by which residents say they judge others reveals a wide gulf between the two older groups and the two younger ones. The Seniors and Adults have a high regard for ‘Catholic values’ and ‘being well-mannered,’ while the Newcomers and adult children emphasise the more modern, meritocratic values of tolerance, openness, hard work and achievement. The older groups, unlike the younger ones, are often racist in their assessments of others.
Pereyra concludes that the residents of San Felipe do not share a single, social-classificatory scheme, but that members of the first three groups, in varying ways, feel significant differences between themselves and the Newcomers. Seniors regard the Newcomers as ‘invaders,’ who fit their ‘iconic image of the migrant’: dark-skinned people with indigenous features and bad manners, who work in commerce, and came from the countryside or from the disordered shantytowns, not quite real Limeños or authentic members of the middle class.
The adult children of the first generation do not, by and large, share this conception. They see the Newcomers as ill mannered and uncultured, but they are uncomfortable with the Seniors’ racist discourse and minimise the differences between themselves and the Newcomers.
As examples of the practical consequences of such judgments Pereyra studied conflicts over control of San Felipe's common spaces. Here again, generational differences are salient. In the past, the common spaces were occupied and controlled by children and young people. Now the Seniors are dominant. By virtue of their large numbers and free time, they run the resident councils and hold sway over the local security patrols. Under their influence common areas have been landscaped in a way that shrinks the accessible play areas. Like the woman in the example cited earlier, Seniors are ready to publicly admonish young people who are doing something ‘inappropriate’ (kissing in public) or doing it in the wrong place (skateboarding on the paths).
The task of policing public behaviour is complicated by the fact that some of those using the common areas are from surrounding areas. Since it is often impossible to distinguish these strangers from residents, the Seniors and security guards tend to concentrate their corrective efforts on people who look as if they do not belong, those who fit their stigmatised image of the migrant. According to Pereyra, neither the second-generation young adults nor the Newcomers share the Seniors’ notions of the proper use and policing of common areas.
By focusing on within-class differences, Pereyra makes a useful contribution to the expanding literature on the Latin American middle class. But the peculiar circumstances of San Felipe, with its prominent founding generation, cloud his findings. The differences he reports are largely generational, suggesting a process of middle-class assimilation rather than the anticipated differentiation between old and new middle class. For the future, the intra-generational comparisons, between those who rise into the region's middle classes and those who start there, deserve closer study from Pereyra and others.
