What does Athens have to do with Jerusalem? Everything. Throughout its history the Christian church has made use of secular philosophy to comprehend the mystery of Christ. As the early church grew in number, issues of inculturating the faith came to predominate. We see this in the church's encounter with Stoicism and Neoplatonism. In early Christianity such thinkers as Origen and Clement of Alexandria made use of Neoplatonic categories to understand the faith, with mixed results. Burkhard believes that today's postmodernisms may play a positive role in rethinking the notion of apostolicity for the Christian churches.
In this book John Burkhard, a Conventual Franciscan priest and Interim President of the Washington Theological Union in DC, examines the notion of apostolicity from a postmodern perspective and manages to breathe new life into dry bones. Apostolicity has to do with the last of the four notes or characteristics of the church, namely one, holy, catholic and apostolic. These notes were not generally discussed until the Reformation, when Roman Catholic theologians used them to discern the true church among the rival claims of the different Christian communions.
Burkhard distinguishes between the ‘Twelve’ and the apostles, arguing that they represent two different groups of individuals in early church with very different functions. The ‘Twelve’ do not yet represent an office in the church. The apostles, on the contrary, do represent an office and symbolise the emergence of a community distinct from Judaism.
How should we understand apostolicity? To start with, think of apostolicity as guaranteeing the identity of the church of a later period with the early Christian church. Apostolicity became important in the second century when Gnostic teachers claimed to have privileged knowledge of Christ's intentions and significance from the apostles. The Gnostics distinguished between the ordinary Christian versus elite believers, the latter having a secret knowledge or insight into Christianity. In countering the Gnostic claim Ireneaus of Lyon underscored the public character of Christian beliefs and practices. The word, apostolic, came to be used to make a claim about the public accessibility of Christianity.
A church is apostolic by virtue of its origin as directly founded by an apostle and by its fidelity to the apostolic kerygma. Burkhard understands apostolicity in an all-inclusive sense, one he terms, ‘substantive apostolicity’, or the apostolic tradition as encompassing the entire life of the church. This notion retrieves the accent in the early church on the authentic witness of the whole of the local church rather than the isolated authoritative witness of its leadership. Substantive apostolicity is open to understanding the church as a communion of apostolic churches.
Burkhard gives us three models for understanding apostolicity. First, the model of identity defines apostolicity in terms of sameness, namely that the church today is identical to the way it was in the past. Second, the model of continuity sees apostolicity in terms of the continued growth of something that is given, for example, change is the historical development of what is already contained in the seed of Christianity planted centuries ago. These two models characterise the ancient, medieval and modern worldviews. Third, the model of coherence (which characterises the postmodern world) makes room for the richness of reality and the pluralism of our human explanations and interpretations. A postmodern understanding of apostolicity embraces genuine pluralism. Why? Burkhard argues that only a multitude of perspectives (rather than a single, all-encompassing one) does justice to the complexity and richness of the world. Christians can understand apostolicity better by sharing their experience of apostolic faith, apostolic life and apostolic ministry with each other, as has occurred in the ecumenical dialogues which have taken place among various denominations over the past half century.
In the final two chapters Burkhard looks at apostolicity from an ecumenical perspective. He casts a bright light on apostolicity in the Roman Catholic–Anglican, Roman Catholic–Lutheran and Orthodox–Roman Catholic dialogue over the last forty years, while also considering its meaning in the document, Baptism, Eucharist, Ministry (1982) and in the Porvoo Common Statement (1992). In writing this book Burkhard inhales everything from K. Rahner, B. Lonergan and W. Pannenberg to E. Levinas, P. Ricoeur and J. D. Zizioulas. When he exhales, it is not just the dilettantes who are blown away.
Not everyone will agree with Burkhard's claim that contemporary Western society has turned the corner from modernism to postmodernism. I see postmodernism as a passing fancy or fad. I think it is still too early to tell whether postmodernism is an appropriate term with which to describe today's world. Although written from a Roman Catholic perspective, this book sheds important light on apostolic succession in Lutheranism, on the question of the recognition of ministry, and on the notion of the church as fundamental sacrament. I strongly recommend it for those who want their theological muscles to have a bracing workout.
