Dimensions of Blackness presents a new empirical analysis of two longstanding research questions in political science: (1) how should political scientists conceptualize and operationalize black racial identity and (2) what affect might a heightened sense of racial identity have on attitudes and behaviors? In this work, the authors argue that racial group identity should be conceptualized and operationalized as a multidimensional construct, rather than a single item survey question (such as the centrality of racial identity to a respondent's overall identity or perceptions of linked fate). Using Sellers et al.'s (Reference Sellers, Smith, Nicole Shelton, Rowley and Chavous1998) Multidimensional Model of Racial Identity (MMRI), the authors demonstrate how a multi-dimensional conceptualization of racial identification reveals the nuanced relationship between racial group identity with attitudes, policy preferences, and political behavior.
Chapter 1 of the book reviews extant theorization on black racial identity, processes of black racial identity formation, and past research on the effect of racial group identification on political behaviors (such as voting) and attitudes (such as political efficacy and trust in government). The literature that the authors review on black racial identity is rich: the authors consider definitions and operationalizations that focus on stigma, oppression, experiences with discrimination, cultural experiences, and Afrocentricity at length. The authors also review past determinants of racial identification, including experiences with discrimination, interracial contact, and segregation, as well as research finding that racial group identity may effect rates of political participation and be associated with interest, awareness, efficacy, and trust.
The authors argue against unidimensional measures of race, noting that although racial self-identification is an important component of race and how it is experienced, so too is racial classification and treatment by others, the social standing of the racial group, and other intersecting identities an individual may hold. Past research, they argue, typically relies on single items such as individual questions measuring racial self-identification, feelings of closeness, or perception of linked fate. Utilization of any one of these items, to the exclusion of others, fails to capture the multiple dimensions racial identity. These measures also lack some clarity. Typical measures of closeness, for example, may measure strong feelings of attachment or proximity/empathy, which may not be the same.
In Chapter 2, the authors describe how they chose to operationalize black racial identity and their source of data. Specifically, they use the MMRI, developed by Sellers et al. (Reference Sellers, Smith, Nicole Shelton, Rowley and Chavous1998), which operationalizes racial group consciousness using three subscales to measure (1) the extent to which being black is central to the respondent's identity, (2) the extent to which they feel positively (or negatively) about the group, and (3) their evaluation of how others feel about the racial group. They identify the National Study of American Life (NSAL), a survey conducted between 2001 and 2003 with an impressive sample of 3,570 African Americans and 2,137 Afro-Caribbeans, as one of the few surveys that both asked respondents questions from the MMRI and a broad set of questions concerning attitudes, policy preferences, and forms of political engagement.
Subsequent chapters analyze the relationship between racial identity and social dominance orientation; attitudes toward black nationalism and other racial issues; attitudes toward policies that aid African Americans, such as reparations; and political participation. As expected, the authors generally find that black racial identity (specifically centrality and public regard) is negatively predictive of social dominance orientation. Their findings also demonstrate the importance of a multidimensional operationalization of black racial group identity.
The authors anticipate that greater levels of centrality and positive attitudes toward blacks will be positively associated with support for black nationalism. Conversely, however, they argue that the belief that blacks are evaluated positively by others in society should be negatively associated with support for black nationalism, as belief that blacks are treated with respect in American society should moderate against endorsement of separatism. They find support for both hypotheses.
The authors predict that although centrality and positive attitudes toward blacks will be positively predictive of support for policies that would specifically aid blacks, the belief that others view African Americans positively will be negatively predictive of support for these policies. As with black nationalism, this empirical pattern is what they observe in the data.
The National Survey of American Life contains multiple measures of political participation, and the authors chose to categorize these variables into electoral and non-electoral forms of political participation. The authors note that racial identity may spur political participation in some domains (such as protests or participation in black community groups) but not in others (donating to candidates). Racial identity may spur voter turnout when candidates are black, but not when candidates are not black. Overall, they do not find any of the three subscales of black racial identity to consistently predict political participation. Although centrality appears to positively predict formal participation, there are no other definitive patterns.
Altogether, Dimensions of Blackness constitutes an important and timely contribution to the literature on black racial identity. The book's most important contribution may be the evidence presented that different dimensions of black racial identity are predictive of different attitudes and behaviors, and in this manner advanced research in this important literature. Nevertheless, I would have appreciated greater theoretical engagement with the literature on racial group consciousness, which emphasizes the combination of strong sense of racial group identity, a sense of the group's marginalized position, and belief in the importance of (collective) action to remedy that marginalization. What are the advantages of researchers utilizing this conceptualization and operationalization of racial identity relative to group consciousness? By more explicitly situating their work within this broader literature, the authors could more persuasively demonstrate the significance of their work.
