For a place of its size, Zanzibar has received a disproportionate share of attention among historians of Africa. And it's not surprising that it has: situated at the intersection of flows of capital, commodities, people, and ideas from Arabia, South Asia, and the interior of East Africa, the islands that comprise the Zanzibar archipelago have long captured the imagination of historians of Africa and the Indian Ocean world. It was only a matter of time, then, before Zanzibar would attract its legal historian.
Stockreiter's book, one of the first sociolegal histories of Zanzibar, takes the reader into the world of litigation in the island's qadi courts (she uses the Swahili spelling, kadhi) during the age of British colonialism: roughly between 1890 and 1960. The book is split into three parts, the first of which situates the qadi courts within a changing Zanzibari legal bureaucracy and gives some insight into qadi’s views on issues such as marriage, gender roles, and respectability. In the second part, which is the book's most substantive, Stockreiter devotes three different chapters to looking into litigation surrounding marriage, property, and divorce; the third part consists of one stand-alone chapter on ethnicity and master–slave relations.
Although the subject matter varies from one chapter to another, Stockreiter's main concern throughout the book is the degree to which female litigants were able to navigate court proceedings, either by themselves or with the help of relatives. Her study vividly illustrates how Zanzibari women made use of the court (which older scholarship had characterized as a site in which patriarchy was given articulation) to shape the world around them. Through their litigation, Zanzibari women dictated the terms of their marriages, controlled money and property, managed their relationships with their relatives and slaves, and bargained for divorce. Thematically, Stockreiter's study dovetails nicely with work by Judith Tucker, Leslie Peirce, Maya Shatzmiller, and Yossef Rapoport, as well as more contemporary studies on East Africa by Erin Stiles and Susan Hirsch and another legal history of Zanzibar and Pemba by Elisabeth McMahon, all of whom have gone to great lengths to highlight female agency in Muslim legal proceedings across space and time. Stockreiter adds to this burgeoning debate, digging through local court records to situate her legal story within a fascinating commercial, social, and political past. There is much to commend throughout: particularly her animation of the various concerns that everyday Zanzibari men and women fought over, and her reconstruction of the careers of the island's qadis and other dramatis personae in the island's legal history.
The book, however, has flaws that might keep it from having the impact it ought to among historians of Islamic law. Rather than drawing the reader into the world of law as litigants and qadis saw it, Stockreiter tends to measure statements and actions against manuals of Islamic jurisprudence, to reveal the degree to which they match up or deviate from the norms they set out. Although her introduction states that the book “draws on the malleable discursive traditions of the shari‘a” and demonstrates how British reforms diminished them, her analysis frequently assumes that there exists a monolithic “Islamic law” that varies only by school of jurisprudence; what qadis and litigants engaged in either fits those traditions or is relegated to the field of custom. “Islamic law” thus becomes conflated with a series of rulings laid out in legal manuals: a conception that becomes particularly indefensible when one of the manuals she relies on the most is the Minhadj At-Talibin, a summary translation of a Shafi‘i text by L.W.C. van den Berg, published in the 1880s for the benefit of the British colonial administration in Batavia. The approach keeps Stockreiter from seeing how the very ontological and legal categories she is interested in might take on different meanings in different settings or genres of writing. There are times when she is clearly aware of the richness of these categories—the chapter on slavery and manumission is exceptional in this regard—but on the whole, she holds back from exploring the different lives of Muslim legal categories in Zanzibari courts and legal texts.
Readers might also feel frustrated by a distinct lack of context in Stockreiter's substantive chapters. Although Stockreiter's analysis draws her readers into the qadi court, the world beyond it is obscured from the reader's view. She states that there are changes taking place in Zanzibar and East Africa—for example, an ongoing process of monetarization in marriage relations—but she never lays these out clearly, nor does she peg her synchronic analysis of the court to them. Within individual chapters, examples separated by decades sit side by side, as though they took place within comparable contexts, despite the author's own acknowledgment that tremendous economic and political changes had taken place during the time period she studies. The reader is left wondering how these changing contexts shaped the legal discourse, to say nothing of the changing meanings of money and property during a 70 year time frame that includes such transformative events as the worldwide economic depression. Stockreiter tries to cover some of this ground in an early chapter, but by the time one is knee deep in Part Two, that background is long forgotten, and its impact on the actions of litigants and qadis feels limited.
None of this, however, should keep readers away from what is otherwise a valuable contribution to the history of Zanzibar and to the field of legal history more broadly. Stockreiter has done a tremendous amount of work to pull together a detailed picture of litigants' affairs in a unique social and political setting. She is clearly at ease with the difficult records she works with, and her argument is never unclear. Although readers unfamiliar with the Zanzibar's history might have trouble seeing the plantation for the clove trees, specialists in Zanzibar's history will delight in Stockreiter's showcasing of a rich trove of court records.
