Both of these books examine how political institutions shaped the adoption of social policy across time. Both authors focus largely on the nexus between public policy and morality, with special attention to the evolution of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and queer history. In Morality at the Ballot Box, Daniel R. Biggers analyzes how direct democracy influenced the adoption of morality-based ballot measures. He argues that not all direct democracy encourages increased voter turnout, but ballot measures lead to notable increases in citizen engagement under the right conditions, that is, when the ballot allows otherwise politically unengaged individuals to vote on a moral issue about which they feel strongly. Rather than focusing on tax reform or budget-related issues on the ballot, he analyzes ballot initiatives with the most potential to mobilize citizens—those involving morality. In The Courts, the Ballot Box, and Gay Rights, Joseph Mello also analyzes political institutions in order to understand the history of the LGBTQ movement. Whereas Biggers analyzes the relationship between morality issues and direct democracy, Mello focuses on the evolution of gay rights through several political lenses—courts, direct democracy, and legislatures.
Morality at the Ballot addresses the long-running debate about the true effects of direct democracy on its citizenry. In it, Biggers argues that the inconsistent (or sometimes null) effects found by direct democracy scholars occurs because we effectively treat all ballot measures as equally capable of mobilizing citizens on Election Day. However, he cautions against this simplistic approach to studying ballot measures. The commonly used count of ballot measures on the ticket may be too rough a proxy to pick up the mobilizing effects. Rather, if direct democracy truly has educative effects and increases voter turnout, the effects may be limited to mobilizing fairly disengaged citizens and only on controversial issues. Biggers asserts that for a notable increase in voter turnout to occur, voters must be aware of the issue and impassioned enough to express their opinion on it, but otherwise unlikely to vote. Given these assumptions, morality issues on the ballot present a perfect test of this theory. The ability of ballot measures to mobilize the disengaged is best illustrated by the fact that Republicans placed same-sex marriage bans on the ballot in 2004 as a way of increasing voter turnout and assuring reelection for President George W. Bush. This is not the only instance in which activists capitalized on the mobilizing effects of morality issues, but it highlights the circumstance that motivated voters nationwide to go to the polls for specific issues, not just to cast a vote for the top of the ticket.
Biggers justifies the focus on morality issues because they are the most likely topics to bring in individuals who are otherwise unlikely to vote or engage with government. He distinguishes morality politics from other social issues by highlighting that moral issues cut at the basis of what people believe to be true, or an objectively right action. Thus, people typically participate with little information, and devoid of economic incentives. Through an experiment, the author tests how individuals respond to morality issues, tax reform, and criminal justice reform. He shows that peripheral voters are drawn in to morality issues more than “hard” issues, or issues that do not immediately send partisan or ideological cues to voters. He emphasizes that the effects on voter turnout may be limited to instances where individuals on the periphery want to engage in political discourse due to the controversial nature of the issue but are otherwise apathetic to politics. He also finds that direct democracy and morality politics are not biased in favor of conservative activists, nor do they favor one political party. While conservative voters helped to propel Bush to reelection with same-sex marriage bans, a similar approach was deployed recently by more liberal activists who coordinated marijuana ballot initiatives to encourage voter turnout on presidential election years in order to advantage Democratic candidates.
Biggers extensively tests the effects of ballot measures on voter turnout at the state and local level. He focuses on morality issues on the ballot in each year, finding that these initiatives increase turnout for midterm and off-year elections. He argues that these moral issues pull in new and younger voters who are otherwise largely disengaged from politics. The pickup of these peripheral voters explains the increase in voter turnout across the states for these years. He applies a case-control study design to demonstrate that similar increases in voter turnout occurred in localities that had morality issues on the ballot when compared to nearby localities without a morality issue on the ballot. Overall, he finds consistent evidence that ballot measures increase voter turnout, with this specific caveat: Morality issues clearly give voters motivation to cast a ballot, but the effects on turnout may be largely limited to mobilizing only peripheral voters.
In The Courts, the Ballot Box, and Gay Rights, Mello takes an interesting approach to explaining the expansion of gay rights by simultaneously analyzing the evolution of arguments made by both LGBTQ proponents and opponents. This is particularly useful since the history of the LGBTQ movement is a story that goes hand in hand with the contemporary rise of the Christian Right movement. These groups share historic events, but their interpretations of these moments differ markedly. Both sides also quickly learned to temper their arguments to attract more moderate individuals. Outright attacks of the LGTBQ community quickly fell out of fashion, and both groups shifted attention to how individual rights are affected by extending or refusing protections to the LGBTQ community. Mello asserts that policy advocates naturally want to compete in the political institution that is most beneficial to their interests. For LGBTQ advocates, this is the courtroom where long-held biases against LGBTQ individuals are harder to activate by fearmongering. Meanwhile, opponents of LGBTQ issues prefer public forums, where participants need and want little information, and broad claims regarding the community receive minimal scrutiny.
Mello argues that opponents of LGBTQ rights capitalized on latent hostility and limited public support to promote biases against the community and pressure politicians into more conservative positions. As a result, these activists preferred political institutions that are majoritarian, in this instance ballot initiatives and referenda. He further argues that direct democracy serves as the perfect vehicle for inciting panic and uncertainty with minimal information. This strategy drives opponents of potential LGBTQ protections or rights to the polls, which is exactly what motivated higher turnout in the 1990s and 2000s as states adopted same-sex marriage bans.
Proponents of LGBTQ rights took a different approach. Historically, they have been on the defensive when issues are left to the public to decide through mechanisms such as a referendum or ballot initiative. Public forums act more as social commentary regarding people’s overall views of the LGBTQ community. Rational and well-articulated arguments do not resonate with the common voter, who spends little time researching issues on the ballot; however, this stands in stark contrast to the preferred presentation style in the courtroom. These more reserved and rational venues allow LGBTQ advocates to take emotion and even morality out of the equation by focusing on their long history of marginalization and a lack of a compelling state interest to uphold a series of discriminatory laws.
The Courts, The Ballot Box, and Gay Rights applies mixed methods to explore issue frames used by advocates on both sides of this important question of law and social policy. After laying out his initial argument that activists pursue policy through their preferred political institution, Mello proceeds to examine the issue frames that opponents of LGBTQ rights used. He finds that morality-based claims are the most prevalent, but frames regarding loss of personal rights and populist opposition to activist judges also frequently appeared in their discourse. He shows that opponents of gay rights commonly describe rights as a zero-sum game in which they are concerned about the loss or reduction of their personal rights when the queer community gains such rights as same-sex marriage or nondiscrimination protections. Mello shows that these opponents turn to rational arguments focused on constitutional concerns when in the courtroom, but judges are less persuaded by these arguments since legal cases require substantiated claims devoid of emotion.
Two case studies highlight the problems faced by advocates on both sides of the issue. Mello provides detailed explanations of the ways in which activists used issue frames preceding the elections in which California’s Proposition 8 (2008) and Maine’s Question 1 (2009) were on the ballot, both of which sought to prevent their respective states from allowing same-sex marriage. These chapters carefully explain the political context that policymakers confronted in California and Maine. Both cases are outliers in their own regard: California raced to prevent a court ruling from allowing same-sex marriage, and Maine tried to invalidate legislation that legalized same-sex marriage. Both cases also occurred later in history than most ballot measures, at a time when the public supported LGBTQ individuals in larger numbers. Nevertheless, the two cases showcase how varying arguments deployed by proponents and opponents have affected policymaking. These cases nicely portray the book’s core arguments—that public involvement, as well as limited emphasis on evidence to support claims, favors opponents of LGBTQ rights, and that rational, dispassionate arguments offered by LGBTQ proponents are more successful in reserved environments, such as courts or legislatures.
Both of these books illustrate the power of political institutions to shape the behavior of individuals. For Biggers, placing morality issues on the ballot spurs citizen engagement by offering voters an incentive to meaningfully participate in politics. This activates a narrow group of voters, but leads to a notable increase in voter turnout in years with poorer overall turnout. For Mello, political institutions dictate which line of argument activists use and where they will likely find a more receptive audience. He argues that policy advocates are strategic and work within their preferred institution, except when drawn into other arenas by their political adversaries. Together, these two books help us better understand the way in which battles over public policy, particularly relating to gay rights, have been fought in the past and are likely to be conducted in the future.
