Samuel Huntington's “clash of civilizations” has spurred an immense literature trying to disprove his argument. The Limits of Culture: Islam and Foreign Policy, which examines the role of “culture” in the foreign policy of the Caspian and Central Asian states, can be placed in this “anti-Huntington” camp. The central question of the volume is whether culture plays a role in the foreign-policy decision making of states of the Caspian region and Central Asia. The collective answer offered in the majority of the book's twelve chapters is that although “culture” is part of the official discourse in these countries, it does not directly motivate foreign policy.
After Brenda Shaffer's introduction, Markus Fischer's chapter explores the link between culture and foreign policy “on philosophical, theoretical and historical grounds” (p. 27). Fischer is skeptical about culture's future role in foreign policymaking. He argues that if the modernization and Westernization path is chosen, this will leave little place for culture in the foreign policy making of the “least Westernized people” (p. 64). Douglas Blum, in a similar manner, argues that, in addition to cultural factors, “exogenous factors” (p. 77) such as the forces of neoliberalism will be crucial in determining the direction of foreign policy in Central Asia and the Caspian Basin.
Ronald Grigor Suny's chapter highlights not only the constructed, amorphous, and layered nature of identity in this part of the world—especially in Uzbekistan, Tajikistan, and Kazakhstan—but also the importance of narratives passed down generationally that help construct and reconstruct identities, nations, and civilizations. Ido Oren and Robert Kauffmann's chapter provides a discursive analysis of major U.S. newspapers pre- and post-9/11 in order to discover “the proverbial American Mind” toward Saudi Arabia, Kazakhstan, and Azerbaijan (p. 116). The authors conclude that cultural perceptions of a country are not fixed but rather change as bilateral ties evolve.
David King and Miles Pomper illustrate the transformation of U.S. policy toward the Caspian from an issue in local politics to an issue in national politics with the Bush administration's declaration of a “global war on terror.” Roger Kangas examines how leaders in the region use Islam to justify their policies. In addition to analyzing the role of religion, Kangas discusses the cultural roots of strong leadership but concludes that the impact of all cultural factors in grand strategy is negligible.
In two separate chapters on Iran, Shaffer and Ali Ansari both conclude that despite being an “Islamic Republic,” Iran does not have a religiously directed foreign policy. When Islam is discursively used, Shaffer argues, the intent is to advance the country's “material interests” (p. 235). Ansari highlights Islam's “formative” rather than determinative role, which comes into being as a result of “interaction with competing cultures”; although the way culture interferes with foreign policy making seems “irrational” to outsiders, it should not be considered as such (p. 261). Finally, in two separate chapters on Pakistan and the Taliban's Afghanistan, Svante Cornell argues that despite conventional wisdom, the foreign-policy behavior of Afghanistan and Pakistan has little to do with religion.
The volume is extremely rich in detail. In particular, the chapters on the greater Caspian region make a good read for those interested in the former Soviet Union countries.
However, the volume has several shortcomings. First, the way that “culture” is conceptualized is problematic. In the introduction, “culture” and “local culture” are used interchangeably; there is the assumption that the state's culture is reflective of local culture, that is, the people's culture. Many different terms—such as religion, ethnicity, history, civilization, and ideology—are placed under the category of culture (pp. 1–3). Yet most of the chapters of the volume have little to do with this definition of culture. Second, Shaffer writes in the introduction about the problems of constructivism and in the acknowledgments sets forth the ambitious goal of combining international relations and area studies; yet this book is more about the latter. Third, although the introduction says that the book concerns the role of “culture” in the foreign policy of the Caspian and Central Asian states, the volume seems to lack a solid regional focus. Although Fischer's chapter is a theoretical overview of culture, the chapters by Oren and Kauffman and by King and Pomper are about American foreign policy toward the greater Caspian area rather than vice versa. Even the inclusion of Afghanistan and Pakistan in the volume might stretch the borders of Central Asia. It is interesting, however, that the back cover states that MIT Press has categorized it under “Middle East Studies.”
Fourth, some contributors' arguments are far from convincing. For example, although Fischer's chapter says nothing about Caspian and Central Asian countries, it ends with an “observation” based on long-outdated modernization theory claiming that modernization will eventually dispel concerns regarding the religious and ethnic motives of the “least Westernized countries” (p. 64). Oren and Kauffman's chapter also makes a problematic stretch by assuming that U.S. newspapers can be considered a reflection of the “proverbial American mind” (p. 116). They also conclude that these newspapers depicted Saudi Arabia as an oil-rich country before 9/11 and a Wahhabist country after and find that Azerbaijan's and Kazakhstan's images improved “markedly” and “moderately” in line with U.S. foreign policy toward them, which is hardly surprising.
Although some chapters are interesting and informative, the overall conclusion of the volume is not really new. The majority of existing scholarship has long concluded that culture has limited impact on foreign policy and, in most cases, is instrumentalized for other goals. If The Limits of Culture: Islam and Foreign Policy had focused more on the ways (i.e., patterns and processes) in which this happened, it might have had a better theoretical, empirical, and thematic focus.
