This is a short and readable book by a well-known thinker and writer. But it is hard to share the enthusiastic endorsements of the (no fewer than) eleven pre-publication plaudits that are to be found on the opening pages and the back cover. Caputo's is a brief version of a grand narrative which divides the relations between philosophy and theology into three historical periods – the pre-modern, the modern and the postmodern. In the pre-modern, philosophy was subservient to (Christian) theology. Thanks to Descartes, philosophy established its independence to the point where the relations were reversed. Not just theology but religion itself was called to answer to the bar of ‘reason’, and found to be sadly lacking. But philosophy's own integrity came to be undermined by Kant, whose Critiques left it only the role of a ‘meta’ science, removed from realms of genuine knowledge and discovery, in the way a restaurant critic compared with a chef is at one remove from the food (a happy metaphor of Caputo's). The efforts of Hegel (and others) both to reconceive the relations between philosophy and religion, and to restore philosophy's immediate concern with truth, failed. It was only when existentialists like Kierkegaard and Nietzsche began to challenge the pretensions of philosophy to be reason itself, that a new relationship could emerge, a relationship that accords perfectly with the postmodernism of Lyotard (amongst others), even if most of the intellectual figures associated with postmodernism are acknowledged secularists. Postmodernism acknowledges a multiplicity of ‘voices’, of which faith and reason are two, and gives priority to none of them. Closer inspection, in fact, reveals that reason requires a kind of faith, and faith requires reason, so that the radical opposition which both contemporary believers and secularists tend to see between philosophy and theology rests upon a misunderstanding left over from modernist thinking. Philosophy and theology are different but entirely consonant ways of pursuing what Caputo calls an intellectual ‘passion for life’.
To fit this grand narrative into just seventy-four pages (with another ten of notes and glossary) is self-evidently an ambitious undertaking. There is no general objection to the broad brush, in my view, so long as no matters of detail are required. The trouble is that Caputo's picture requires detail – about Aquinas, Copernicus, Descartes, Kant, Hegel, Wittengenstein, Schleiermacher, Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, and not enough can be given to show both that their ideas and influence have been properly understood and that they bear out the story he wants to tell.
This raises the question: for whom is the book written? The dust jacket advertises it as an introduction for students, but I don't think it is informative enough. (Reference is made to the importance of Copernicus' theory, without even a one line explanation of what it was, for example.) Some of the plaudits hail it as a work of originality, but I cannot say that I find anything very new in it. The ‘postmodern’ account of religion in chapter 6 is for the most part the Wittgensteinianism that the late D. Z. Phillips made his distinguishing contribution to philosophy of religion nearly forty years ago. What is missing is any awareness of the difficulties in such a position that all the critical discussion since then has revealed.
The most interesting chapter comes towards the end when Caputo offers us an intriguing comparison between Augustine and Derrida. Here the broad brush is dropped, along with the (to me) faintly annoying prose style (though Richard Kearney calls it ‘brio’) and one gets a sense of a far more interesting book that he might have written on these themes.
