It seems appropriate that Women in the Shadows: Gender, Puppets, and the Power of Tradition in Bali opens with author Jennifer Goodlander riding on the back of a motorbike dressed in traditional Balinese ceremonial garb en route to a performance. This is a book that wraps new knowledge in stories, paints a vivid sense of place, and values understanding gained through active participation. Through Goodlander's experience, the book powerfully conveys an insider-outsider's glimpse of the place of women, power, and tradition in the Balinese shadow puppet theatre, wayang kulit. Her insider status, as a student with the highly regarded puppet master Pak Tunjung, informs her rich exploration of performance elements. The fact that she is a woman and an American scholar-practitioner maintains her status as an outsider to this male-dominated performance medium as it is uniquely situated in Balinese society. Gender norms, the puppets, and the surrounding Balinese tradition are contextualized as Goodlander richly describes her experience of shadow puppet theatre as an American researcher and practitioner invited into this inner world behind the shadows.
This book is appropriately structured as a journey from the outer material consideration of the form to the inner mystical knowledge and experience of its spiritual wisdom, function, and meaning. The first chapter provides an overview of the physical form itself, the puppets, and the practice of performing within changing traditions. The remainder of the book is divided into two major parts to represent the visible and the invisible realms in Balinese cosmology: “Sekala: The Visible Realm” (Chapters 2, 3) and “Niskala: The Invisible Realm” (Chapters 4–6). In Chapter 2 the process of becoming a puppet master, or dalang, in Bali is explained by following the unusual path traced by Goodlander as a foreign, female scholar. Chapter 3 explores both the materials used in performance, such as the puppets, the puppet box, and musical instruments, and the various modes of performance, such as vocalization and storytelling. Chapter 4 delves into the ceremonial transformation of a student apprentice into a dalang through a detailed account of Goodlander's own process. She explores the “room for slippage between the social and ritual hierarchy” (117) that allows women the space to insert themselves as performers of the wayang kulit without disrupting the larger social system. Chapter 5 examines the opportunities and challenges experienced by women who perform the Balinese wayang kulit, including Goodlander and other female dalang in Bali. The final chapter shares an account of Goodlander learning a new story for performance that features several female characters. This provides an opportunity for considering gender within the wayang kulit and imagining possibilities for future developments within this performance form and its supporting society.
The use of precise, accessible language makes this book appropriate for high-school students, yet the academic sophistication and depth of consideration make it appropriate for scholarly research and university seminars. In this regard, the book matches its subject since the wayang kulit itself is a layered communicative form that is accessible and engaging for multiple age groups. Words and references are carefully chosen and thoughtfully explained throughout the text. Goodlander enhances thick description of the process of performing with a rich array of theoretical insights that link aspects of performance with Balinese belief and society. A deep consideration of aesthetics is woven into this thick description and, astutely, is provided only once the reader is solidly hooked into the story and hungry for understanding. Goodlander resists the assumption that we all commonly understand what is conveyed by key words such as tradition and ritual and instead interrogates and carefully delineates what is indicated by her use of each term, while also placing these terms within the scholarly conversations in which they are most often used in theatre and performance studies. The only improvement for this book that I could imagine might be the inclusion of a more detailed account of Goodlander's culminating performance at the Ubud Festival, for which she trained extensively and prepared ritually through various ceremonies.
Goodlander is careful to situate her voice as not necessarily an authority on the ceremonies associated with the wayang kulit; rather, she writes from her “own experiences in order to better understand the roles these kinds of rituals play within the framework of Balinese society” (104). During a ceremony preparing the author for her first public performance, the officiating Balinese lay priest, I Made Sumantra, substituted a traditionally spicy taste for another one to appease Goodlander's stomach, which cannot tolerate spicy foods. In doing so, he assured her that this substitution in no way lessened the efficacy of the ritual, since, as he stated, “each ritual must be suited to the time, place, and circumstances of the moment” (114). The fact that “ritual[s] could be changed in order to accommodate difference[s]” (120) has potentially profound repercussions. If rituals can be changed, then so too can traditional gender roles and biases toward women. The fact that women are proving that they are capable of learning the necessary skills and are performing the wayang kulit in public for satisfied audiences is testimony to the fact that our world is rapidly evolving. The question of what impact women performing the wayang kulit has on gender dynamics in Balinese society is satisfyingly answered by the thoughtfully considered and richly informed analysis that permeates this book. In answering this question, the book addresses performance innovations that seemingly disrupt centuries of tradition yet equally gratify the desire for novelty—and, in doing so, much is revealed about the nature of transformation, balance, gender, and culture in Bali.
