This is a major contribution to the rethinking of the modern economic history of East Asia brought about mostly by Japanese scholars, though the title is slightly misleading in the sense that it is not a geo-political concern but a matter pertaining to regional economies only. The collection of 11 essays, which is the result of a panel discussion at the International Economic History Congress in Buenos Aires in July 2002, brings together a rich selection of perspectives, examining economic development in Asia both nationally and internationally in the 1930s and 1950s, with the British Empire/Commonwealth at the centre of the stage. Presented by the two British historians P.J. Cain and A.J. Hopkins, Britain's pursuit of her colonial interests in Asia is seen here as “gentlemanly capitalism”.
Shigeru Akita's first chapter focuses on British economic interests, re-evaluating the role played by the United Kingdom in the formation of the industrialisation-based “International Order of Asia” in the 1930s. Yoichi Kibata's Chapter 2 on British Imperialism in Asia and Anglo-Japanese relations in the 1930 and the 1950s stresses the continuity of British imperial policy by examining British attitudes towards Japan in the period from the Japanese occupation of Manchuria in 1931 to the outbreak of the Sino-Japanese war in 1937, and the clear abandonment of this policy between the 1930s and the post-war period closely corresponds to Akita's work. On the other hand, Nicholas White emphasises the continuity of British existence in post-war Asian economic life using Malaya's rubber export as an example (Chapter 6). Catherine Schenk also argues for the greater degree of continuity in the post-war years than commonly believed in her study of sterling in relation to Hong Kong and China (Chapter 5).
The British-led international economy in Asia during the 1930s is re-examined in Kaoru Sugihara's analysis of the connection between the sterling area and East Asia's industrialisation. He argues that the shift to a managed currency system triggered by the British pound's departure from the gold standard in 1931, provided the foundation for the monetary order in East Asia (Chapter 3). Focusing on Korea, but with reference to and implications for the “Northeast corner” of the world economy as a whole, Bruce Cumings’ study points out that Japan's emphasis on heavy industrialisation and the development of a sophisticated transportation network in its East Asian colonies changed the face of the region which has had a profound influence on East Asia's economic development to this day. According to Cumings, the construction of Asian regional economies hastened British manufacturing decline in the 1930s and assisted American manufacturing advancement in the 1940s, which was one important aspect of the shift from British to American hegemony that characterised the 20 years from 1930 to 1950 (Chapter 4). It is also interesting to hear his argument that even before the end of the war the US was preparing to restore Japan's imperial economic power, which was contrary to the Roosevelt administration's stated desire for Asia's post-war order which favoured the prominence of Nationalist China.
The five chapters in Part II examining the formation of intra-regional trade relations within Asia in the 1930s and the economic revival and transformation in the 1950s are all concerned with China, except for Naoto Kagotani's Chapter 7. This offers an analysis on the relationship between Japan and the European occupancy of South and Southeast Asia in the 1930s, especially with regard to the international rivalry in the cotton industry and market between British India, the Dutch East Indies and Japan.
Tomoko Shiroyama sheds new light on China's relationship with the international monetary system in the first half of the twentieth century as characterised by scholars writing in the English language by focusing on China's 1935 currency reform, which demonstrates the incredible depth to which the country was integrated into the world market (Chapter 8). It was a great misfortune that the process was interrupted by the war. Toru Kubo's Chapter 9 focuses on the different policies which affected China's economic development in the 1930s and 1950s and how China interacted with the Asian regional economy in varying ways during the two periods. Toshiro Matsumoto in Chapter 10 reviews the history of the Anshan Iron and Steel Company in Manchuria and attempts to clarify the relationship between political and economic continuity and discontinuity from the 1930s to the 1950s in the Northeast region of China. Japanese colonial rule in Taiwan and its residue is explored in the final chapter by Man-houng Lin. Her findings that the Japanese-educated business elite continued to function and were endorsed by the government in the first decade of the Nationalist rule of the Republic of China in Taiwan are eye–opening to say the least.
While the ‘soft’ transition from British to American domination in the 1950s commands the attention of the reader, it remains true that the most important factor of the post-war discontinuity in East Asian economic life was China's complete withdrawal from the international monetary system, which still affects China's relationship with the rest of the world today, and the country's fundamentally diminished role in the Asian market, a situation rendered possible by China's incorporation into the Soviet bloc (this is evidenced by the Constitution of the Anshan Iron and Steel Company which was heavily modelled on Soviet heavy industry management). At the same time, the Soviet Union made its high-profile comeback through its allies in East and Southeast Asia. Though understandable for the obvious absence of expertise in Soviet studies, it is nevertheless a pity that the present volume is not able to address this inevitable dimension of the economic order of post-war Asia.
