Nothing symbolizes the spirit of the Gilded Age in the United States quite like the world's fairs. As elaborate spectacles showcasing American ingenuity, wealth, and power, they demonstrated the entrance of the United States onto the world stage. Despite their impressive scope, the world's fairs were never built to last—the grand and classically inspired architecture of their exhibit halls were mere facades made of little more than plaster. Still, these events can provide remarkable insight into the lives of nineteenth-century Americans. Nathan Cardon's A Dream of the Future: Race, Empire, and Modernity at the Atlanta and Nashville World's Fairs uses the world's fairs to offer a compelling glimpse into the culture of the “New South” at an important, transitional moment. As the temporary construction of the fairs themselves suggested, however, the visions of their planners did not entirely stand the test of time.
Utilizing the 1895 Atlanta Cotton States and International Exposition, the 1897 Tennessee Centennial and International Exposition in Nashville, and the 1907 Jamestown Exposition as case studies, Cardon illustrates how Southerners envisioned their place in the nation and in the world at the turn of the twentieth century. Still reeling from the Civil War and Reconstruction and the Panic of 1893, and facing a populist uprising, many doubted that the South could compete in an increasingly industrial and global marketplace. Rather than stubbornly cling to their agrarian past, however, Cardon argues that Southerners viewed the world's fairs as an opportunity to demonstrate how their unique regional heritage could be channeled into a progressive new direction.
According to Cardon, the fairs’ elite white organizers hoped to rehabilitate the popular perception of their region and place it at the vanguard of modernity and empire. Through the design of the fairgrounds, the nature of the exhibits, and the conduct of the fairgoers, they crafted a vision of the South as culturally refined, racially harmonious, and ripe for industrial development. In all, the fairs gave white Southerners an opportunity to present what they considered their best face to the nation and to the world. At the same time, however, these Southerners were anxious not to let their ambitions for modernity disturb their region's deeply entrenched white supremacy. What they crafted, Cardon says, was “Jim Crow modernity” (3). In their minds, the South could provide the United States a model for how to marshal the labor of people of color while maintaining strict racial hierarchy across its emerging empire.
Cardon is careful to point out that the Atlanta and Nashville expositions were also shaped by the competing visions of African Americans and women. Paying careful attention to race, class, and gender, Cardon persuasively demonstrates how the fairs both affirmed and subverted the aspirations of their planners. In chapter two, the strongest chapter of the book, Cardon reveals that black Southerners used the fairs to promote their own interests. According to Cardon, both fairs occurred at a precise, opportune moment—just before de jure segregation went into full effect. Unlike the aptly named “White City” of the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition in Chicago, the Atlanta and Nashville fairs were not officially segregated. Black men and women not only attended the fairs but also had dedicated exhibit space in the so-called “Negro Buildings.” Planned by middle-class black leaders, the “Negro Building” exhibitions reinforced the accommodationist politics of respectability championed by Booker T. Washington in the Atlanta Compromise. At the same time, however, they served as sites of resistance and forums for race pride. The “Negro Buildings” were prominently located and popular, and the exhibits therein celebrated black achievement, challenged pervasive racial stereotypes, and called attention to persistent discrimination. Through their juxtaposition with ethnological exhibits, including recreations of African villages, the “Negro Buildings” were also meant to illustrate proof of racial uplift. They encouraged the perception that along an imagined evolutionary track from primitivism to civilization, African Americans had reached the apotheosis, and that they were therefore an essential component of the South's transition to industrial modernity.
Southern women likewise utilized the Atlanta and Nashville fairs as an opportunity to articulate their version of modernity. Cardon says that “Women's Building” exhibitions positioned white women as an important link between the South's tradition-bound past and its future. Although Cardon does not neglect African American women, his analysis of their place in the world's fairs is more ambiguous—doubtless reflecting the challenges of obtaining sources detailing their perspectives. While the presence of black women as cooks and nurses at the fairs reinforced the “mammy” trope, satisfying the white supremacist imaginings of their organizers, Cardon insists that black women also used the fairs as a forum for organization and as a showcase for their artistry.
By the 1907 Jamestown Exposition, Cardon concludes, the dreams of “Jim Crow modernity” had largely fallen short. The South remained overwhelmingly agricultural. Women were far less present in the exhibits, and the racial control wielded by white Southerners was even more solidified. With Jim Crow laws firmly in place, the white organizers of the Jamestown Exposition subjected black fairgoers to greater segregation and harassment. The confidence the black elite had espoused at the Atlanta and Nashville fairs that they would share in the advantages of a modernized South had gone unfulfilled.
A Dream of the Future is a detailed, compact, and interesting read. With a clear and convincing argument, it offers a little bit of everything—cultural, gender, and even transnational history. Those interested in life and leisure in the Gilded Age or in Southern history will want to read this excellent book. Although the fairs themselves were fleeting, Cardon has successfully used them to open a rich and illuminating window into the “New South.”
