No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 31 January 2005
The importance of sugar in the creation of the Atlantic world can scarcely be overstated. Soaring production and surging demand underpinned the so-called hot beverages revolution in eighteenth-century Europe, as sugar sweetened the coffee and tea drunk by ever-widening groups. The abundance of studies of sugar in its Caribbean heyday has sometimes led to the assumption that the exigencies of sugar cultivation had imposed a common structure on production from the beginning, typified by the capital-intensive latifundia employing African slaves. This assumption, however, comes from reading back, and this new study of the formative first two centuries of Atlantic sugar production wisely cautions against such an approach.
The nine contributors to this volume, edited by Stuart Schwartz, focus mainly on early sugar production—dominated by the Iberian kingdoms—in Madeira, the Canary Islands, Hispaniola, Cuba and Brazil. These essays are particularly valuable because they often convey research previously inaccessible to nonreaders of Spanish and Portuguese. Also commendable is the acumen of these scholars who have creatively pieced together what are often very spotty archival records for this period. Consequently, much of the information offered here will be new to many readers. For example, it may come as a surprise to some the extent of cane cultivation in sixteenth-century Hispaniola and seventeenth-century Cuba, even though these early periods of Spanish florescence in colonial sugar production could not be sustained for longer than a few decades each.
But the greatest overall strength of this volume is that it shows how ad hoc the process of sugar expansion was in the Atlantic world. Far from determining forms of production, sugar cultivation called forth a host of responses to the problems of land, capitalization, and labor. Iberian monarchs typically offered land as incentive, but no law required sugar plantations to be large. A variety of sizes could be found throughout the region in this time period, with a similar complexity in the terms of use or ownership of land on which sugar was grown. A common difficulty was the acquisition of capital to erect a mill, the most expensive element in sugar production. Initial success in production favored further capital accumulation and expansion of mills, but planter debt was everywhere and at all times a problem.
Also, African slavery was only one possible solution to the labor requirements of sugar production, which at various times and places also employed native Americans slaves and European peasant sharecroppers and wage laborers. If African slaves eventually came to dominate the sugar labor force, it was because of increased availability and low cost through the intensification of the Atlantic slave trade. That said, a clear pattern does emerge from these essays: Iberian peasants were not likely to meet the labor requirements of the sugar complex as it expanded ever further away from Europe. Coerced labor—in one form or another—appeared to be a necessary ingredient for the success of production, and the New World indigenes in the growing zones were ill-prepared to take up this burden. Consequently it is hard to imagine the continued expansion of the Atlantic sugar economy without the inputs of enslaved African workers.
Another challenge presented here to the conventional narrative of the spread of sugar concerns the introduction of sugar to Barbados, supposedly the beginning of a “revolution” in sugar production. An essay contributed by John McCusker and Russell Menard shows that when sugar cultivation eventually leapt to the British Caribbean, Barbados was already well poised to receive it. By the time colonists here turned to sugar cane, they had already gained valuable experience producing other agricultural commodities for the export market. It is doubtful, then, that Dutch capital fleeing Pernambuco was decisive in starting up production in Barbados. Also, the authors show that the movement away from tenant farming in Barbados and towards larger “integrated” estates was gradual, and small farmers producing cane never disappeared completely.
Although most of the contributions to this volume focus on sugar production, two address the African slave trade and European sugar consumption. Herbert Klein provides a useful synthesis of the most recent research on the trans-Atlantic slave trade. And in a memorable essay, Eddy Stols describes the rapid addiction of Europeans to sugar, which began to dominate elite banquets and sweeten holidays in the sixteenth century, even though it was still not an item of consumption for ordinary people. Stols also describes the inter-European trade in sugar, but lacking from the volume is any detailed description of the trade on its Atlantic routes.
This volume may not achieve the status of revisionist history, but it should go a long way towards dispelling ignorance about the origins of sugar in the Atlantic world, especially for scholars reading only English. The quality of scholarship here is excellent and the emphasis on contingency in the creation of an Atlantic sugar economy is apt. This volume also serves to emphasize the pioneering role of the Iberians in creating the Atlantic economy, even though the English and French eventually came to dominate it.