Judith Cochran's new book is a comprehensive study of educational politics in modern-day Egypt. It is an accomplishment in a number of respects. First, the author has composed as part of the work a thorough chronological history of education in Egypt. Focused on the modern period but stretching back to 4000 b.c., this historical narrative accounts for political instability, authoritarianism, and the ethnic and religious undercurrents that have been endemic to educational ideology. Second, Cochran manages to highlight in an accessible, textbook-style narrative the complex and conflicting politics and ideologies of foreign and local actors in the educational scene. Third, she has accomplished a synthesized analysis despite gaps in the sources on the social and political outcomes of the educational process, which stem from the current dictatorial regime's restrictions on research.
As a result of overcrowding in Egypt's public schools, large numbers of people hoping for social elevation turn to alternative education programs offered by local religious groups, local and foreign nongovernmental organizations, and UNESCO. Education has become a site of political contestation between these forces. The quality of public education and technical training has simultaneously declined because of government corruption and lack of interest. The Egyptian government adopts foreign models of education without modifications and does not check on schools’ progress. For example, it annually sends teachers to foreign countries for teacher training as part of a program initiated by the Ministry of Education in 1993. The program has failed to improve the quality of education, however, because the government does not check to ensure that these teachers incorporate the new pedagogical training after resuming their tenured positions in Egypt.
Cochran's book includes a history of Egyptian feminist movements’ approaches to women's educational rights. She also examines rural female enrollment trends and how social norms negatively affect female employment in the private sector. In the former case, rural women's domestic and agricultural labor has kept female school-dropout rates in rural regions extremely high. In terms of the latter, women are largely restricted to a few gender-specific professions such as gynecology and teaching.
As is the case with men, many women who go beyond primary schooling attend secondary technical schools. These institutions lack adequate teachers and facilities and therefore cannot provide students with the skills to compete in the private sector. Exacerbating the situation, the public sector can no longer guarantee employment opportunities proportional to the number of graduates or offer its employees adequate salaries. There exists a dire need to enhance teachers’ skills and update course content, a venture parties in power perhaps view as unprofitable. Upper-class and to a lesser extent middle-class Egyptian youth have found private schools geared toward preparing for national tests a solution to the problem of low-quality public education. Those able to attend such institutions achieve higher scores and have an easier time finding employment.
Cochran's description of the history, economics, and outcomes of the Egyptian educational system points to the ways in which the political crisis and authoritarian rule in the country relate to the lack of teacher accountability and students’ freedom of thought. Political turmoil also accounts for the persistent problem of unemployment. Cochran posits that systematized, task-oriented tutoring by trained and certified tutors may help students develop the educational and technical skills to become more competitive in the job market. Yet given the problem of checks and balances in the educational system, this solution does not appear to promise results. Rather, systemized tutoring risks becoming another unregulated educational system running parallel to the already existing one. The author could have discussed other possible solutions for the Egyptian government to pursue, such as directly engaging public and private industrial and business enterprises to assess employer needs; developing a uniform national educational policy; revising curriculum so that it prepares students from all economic classes for the job market; and improving teachers’ training, salaries, and benefits. Together, such solutions could bring quality and accountability into the existing system.
Judith Cochran has managed to provide a synthesized picture of public and private education in Egypt in a straightforward narrative, with well-documented sources and an exhaustive bibliography. Readers searching for a more theoretical discussion of educational politics should look elsewhere. This multifaceted study is an accessible read not only for those specializing in Egypt but also for those with little knowledge of the country's history.
