In this excellent collection, Drude Dahlerup and Monique Leyenaar ask by what means and to what extent male dominance in politics has been challenged or “broken.” The volume examines “old democracies,” those that “share a long tradition of democratic practices and a highly developed socio-economic structure, and where women’s suffrage was established at the beginning of the twentieth century” (p. 3). The old democracies—five northern European countries (Denmark, Germany, Iceland, the Netherlands, Sweden, and the United Kingdom) and two subnational governments (in Australia and the United States)—appear to follow a master trajectory of development of women’s political inclusion: a struggle for women’s suffrage, resistance and opposition by political parties, and incremental growth in women’s parliamentary presence, culminating in an accepted norm of women’s (modest) inclusion in political institutions as a sign of political modernity and democracy.
The editors identify male dominance in terms of its scope and degree. The scope of male dominance is evidenced by the “male-coded norms and practices” of politics, public policies gendered to the masculine, and women’s under-representation in four political arenas (p. 8). The degree of male dominance is measured specifically against women’s parliamentary inclusion: as a “male monopoly” (where women account for less than ten percent of MPs); small minority of women (where women constitute more than ten but less than 25 percent of MPs); large minority of female MPs (25% ≤ women < 40%); and “gender balance,” where neither sex constitutes less than 40% of all MPs (p. 10). The volume focuses primarily on women’s parliamentary presence, indicting political parties as the major actors impeding women’s political inclusion and gender equality. It concludes with five summary chapters uniting the case findings, theorizing the results, and offering hypotheses for further testing.
The country chapters are excellent. No one should be surprised by the high quality and keen insights of Joni Lovenduski’s chapter on the United Kingdom. The story of women’s increasing inclusion in British national politics is not a happy one. British women were not fully enfranchised until 1928 (only three years before Spanish women won the right to vote in 1931). “Until the 1980s no political party [in the UK] was much interested in the political representation of women,” and it took until 1997 for female MPs to constitute at least 10 percent of the House of Commons (p. 73). Although the electoral system of first-past-the-post deserves much of the responsibility for the continuing small numbers of female MPs, disaggregation by party (and also newness of institutions at the subnational level) reveals that, under this unpropitious electoral system: 1) the Labour Party was nonetheless able to increase women’s numbers dramatically in 1997, using the controversial and problematic mechanism of all-women short lists; 2) the Green Party elected a woman (its leader, Caroline Lucas) to its sole seat in the Commons in 2010; and 3) the Conservative Party has had little will to increase women’s representation on their party’s benches, and hence little success. One of the many strengths of this chapter is Lovenduski’s attention to male dominance as enacted by actual men; male monopoly of British politics was no accident and not the result of black-box political parties, but the specific decisions of male politicians to exclude (and often to demean) political women. Despite the serious struggles of organized feminists and women within all political parties, male politicians have succeeded in limiting women’s political inclusion to an “almost large minority” in the Labour Party and to a small minority among Conservatives.
If the UK constitutes the recalcitrant case, Sweden appears as the exemplar for an incremental, positive trajectory of women’s political representation. With a strong tradition of group representation, a history of left party governance, a proportional representation electoral system, and uninterrupted universal suffrage since 1921 (granted nearly simultaneously to all Swedes; see pp. 99–100), autonomous feminists and activist women within political parties have been successful in advancing women in public office, protecting women’s electoral gains (where quotas work to backstop regression), and convincing political parties to endorse feminist principles and to adapt dominant political discourse to accommodate gender egalitarian social justice claims. Cross-party commitments to women’s political inclusion are detailed in Friedenvall’s excellent Table 5.2. The challenge for Sweden (as for Denmark) is to secure current gender equality achievements in the face of minor but rising rightwing parties.
Germany is the key country case in this volume, and its inclusion requires more justification than is provided by the editors. Germany is distinctive in the continuing priority given to the breadwinner-housewife model, women’s low rates of fulltime paid employment, a large gender wage gap (especially in comparison to other countries). Moreover, its history is distinguished by its Nazi era, its division into occupied zones, its immigration policies, the challenges of internal terrorist groups, and its belated reunification in 1990. Male dominance has not been broken in Germany, but it has been weakened by a strong feminist movement in the 1970s and 1980s and by left and left-libertarian parties responsive to feminist demands. The Social Democratic Party’s voluntary implementation of gender quotas substantially increased women’s representation in the Bundestag, more than doubling the numbers of women (p. 203-205). Chapter author Brigitte Geissel explicitly rejects “time-lag,” “reproduction of patriarchy,” contagion, and incremental progress models (p. 215), none of which serves to explain the German case.
Breaking Male Dominance supports the findings of other scholars that activist women are key for advancing women’s political interests. In Iceland, for example, the Women’s Alliance organized the external pressure necessary to increase women’s political inclusion (as evidenced by their success in local council and parliamentary elections between 1982 and 1994) by nominating candidates and by creating an electoral gender gap within the mass public. External pressure from autonomous feminists “gave leverage to women already engaged in politics to put pressure on their own parties to commit themselves to increase women’s political leadership” (p. 137). Although feminist movements may have diminished since their peak in the 1970s and 1980s, the case chapters demonstrate that in old democracies, organized women are the key actors in advancing women-friendly public policy and women’s political inclusion.
For all the country cases, political parties are key gatekeepers, foreclosing or opening political representational opportunities for women; moreover, they are “the target of gender equality advocates” (p. 298). In several countries, political parties, under conditions of male political monopoly, advanced major gender equity legislation (e.g.: the Equal Pay Act in Britain (1970), the Equal Status and Equal Rights of Women and Men in Iceland (1976), and in Sweden, the 1921 Marriage Code that provided equal spousal rights). The country cases also confirm the importance (for old democracies) of left parties in advancing women’s parliamentary representation and in the success of feminist activists in leveraging left ideology in support of gender equality.
The editors and their case contributors scrutinize changes in party structure and evaluate the impact of these changes on women’s political inclusion, policy representation, and public framing of gender equity (see esp. Table 13.1). In the face of gender equality claims, parties in old democracies are transforming their internal structures. Parties appear to be shifting from centralized nomination procedures to primary elections, protecting entrenched male dominance, rather than breaking it. Lovenduski suggests that some UK parties are considering such a move (p. 75). Auður Styrkársdóttir argues that primaries employed in Iceland worked to women’s detriment (p. 132), opening opportunities for political corruption (pp. 139–143). A second structural change—the demise of women’s sections in parties—appears to have weakened women’s positions within political parties, rendering women invisible by removing the internal party foundation upon which they had previously organized.
It is always a challenge to review and to critique a 14-chapter edited volume, especially one as important as Breaking Male Dominance. Among the many strengths of this volume is its point of origin: it rejects at the outset explanations that focus on individual inadequacies and emphasizes instead institutional arrangements and political discourse in terms of their restrictive gendered impact (electoral systems and party systems) in excluding women from parliaments and cabinets. The book also emphasizes the potential malleability of institutions and their transformative (if reluctant) positive impact upon women’s political inclusion. The volume is highly theorized; the individual case chapters are systematic in their evaluation of country evidence against the models being tested; and five chapters summarize the findings across cases, providing an integrating coherence not often found in edited collections.
With such a strong collective body of work, it may seem like quibbling to raise issues of weaknesses of the volume. Readers will challenge the case selection rationale. No southern European countries are included. France and Italy are absent, despite functioning as independent parliamentary systems for longer (France) or at least as long (Italy) as Germany, and without a half-century of division. The absence of these cases (and that of Spain) precludes serious consideration of anti-feminist regression. Including these additional countries would have reinforced Geissel’s careful chapter on Germany and provided further analysis of the recent successes of new rightwing parties in Denmark, Sweden, and the UK. The volume is also relatively silent on the rise of fascism and the impact of World War II on sustaining or weakening male political dominance. It would have been helpful to know how the experiences of breaking democracy (in France, Germany, Italy, and Spain) subsequently shaped the general trajectories of breaking male dominance. As a result, it is unclear how generalizable the conclusions are beyond the cases examined in the volume.
These comments, however, only critique this important volume for what it did not include. Required reading for scholars of women, gender, and political representation and for experts in the politics of these “old democracies,” Breaking Male Dominance will be an influential touchstone for future research. Questions of how and where male political dominance can be challenged persist. Breaking Male Dominance provokes further debate.
