In addition to his great calligraphy and paintings, the Yuan dynasty's Zhao Mengfu (1254–1322) also attracted considerable attention in Chinese history because of his non-artistic activities. Descended from the Song dynasty's imperial family, he served in a variety of government positions for the Mongol rulers of China. His earliest position was in the Ministry of War, but the Yuan court later recognised his literary and artistic skills and appointed him to assist in compiling the Veritable Records [Shilu] for Khubilai Khan's reign (1260–1294) and then promoted him to Superintendent of Confucian Education based in the city of Hangzhou. He protected Chinese officials and helped to bring down Sangha, a powerful official at court who imposed oppressive taxes on the population. Despite these services, some Chinese labelled him disloyal because he accepted assignments at the ‘barbarian’ dominated court. Shane McCausland, the author of this intellectual biography of Zhao, writes that the artist became a “controversial, pivotal figure in Chinese art history”. Yet among the virtues of Dr McCausland's study is a challenge to the conventional wisdom that contemporary Chinese condemned Zhao. Indeed McCausland shows that Zhao maintained close relations with many Chinese loyalists and continued to support traditional Chinese values. Although Zhao was the most renowned of the artists who became government officials in this foreign dynasty, several other prominent painters also served the Mongols.
Having offered a different view of Zhao's political and ideological affiliations and reputation, Dr McCausland then describes Zhao's contributions to Chinese art and, to an extent, relates his aesthetic growth to social developments. Starting with Zhao's calligraphy, he shows the artists’ devotion to China's cultural traditions. Zhao's calligraphic styles, in seal, standard, running, and cursive script, reveal an appreciation of Tang dynasty (618–907) calligraphy and an attempt to revitalise these antique models. The colophons he wrote on the works of others emphasise Confucian themes such as personal integrity and service to society.
Dr McCausland then deals, in turn, with the extraordinary variety of Zhao's paintings. He analyses Zhao's depiction of animals, human figures, including renowned Buddhists and Daoists, landscapes, and trees, bamboo, and rocks and describes the artist's development of new formulations of traditional Chinese genres. Dr McCausland's descriptions of the paintings are well done and accessible not only to art historians but also to a wide audience. In addition, he illustrates Zhao's Buddhist faith and especially his interest in the Chan Buddhist Zhongfeng Mingben.
Dr McCausland's efforts to relate Zhao's artistic works to his life at the Yuan court add to our knowledge of the dynasty. Zhao was appalled by the desecration of the corpses of the Song emperors by the Buddhist monk Yanglian Zhenjia, but he still had not achieved a sufficiently high bureaucratic position to prevent this incident. Once he had become an adviser to Khubilai Khan, he used his status to challenge the apparently exploitative and corrupt minister Sangha. Dr McCausland provides additional detail for an understanding of the relations between Zhao and Khubilai, as well as Zhao's links to the Renzong emperor (r. 1311–1320) who restored the Chinese civil service examinations and recruited Chinese officials to his court.
Three minor cavils about Dr McCausland's fine book. First, he occasionally lapses into art historical jargon, although not seriously enough to undermine the general reader's understanding and enjoyment. Second, the book does not sufficiently emphasise the Mongol impact on the great painter. Zhao must have known that his paintings of animals would appeal to the Yuan rulers who still had a strong affinity for a nomadic pastoral life. His choice of horses as subjects had precedents in Chinese art, but he clearly recognised that his repeated representations of horses, as well as his famous work Sheep and Goat, would certainly find a receptive audience in the Mongol conquerors of China. Third, the book's speculations about the meaning and symbols of specific paintings and calligraphic works require greater proof. There are too many ‘perhaps’, ‘suggests’, and ‘possibly’ sprinkled throughout the text. Nonetheless, these are minor quibbles for a work that is, surprisingly, the first book-length work, in English, on the premier painter/calligrapher of the Yuan dynasty.
The author and the publisher have provided a generous number of mostly colour illustrations, which enhance the book's value. Dr McCausland's translation of the official dynastic history [Yuanshi] biography of Zhao, as well as a chronology of Zhao's life, also enriches the work.
