Postconflict reconstruction of broken societies is an onerous task for which there is no universal recipe. All too often, well-meant initiatives mired in lack of funding resemble disconnected pieces of a jigsaw puzzle, patching up the most apparent problems but failing to approximate the complexity of the situation. These two new books offer valuable insights into some of the missing pieces. Both focus on young people and their transitions through war and then peace of arms but often not of souls. Seemingly insurmountable obstacles in postconflict community acceptance and economic opportunities prolong the void of purpose that can result in the renewed cycle of violence. However, both books offer hope backed by observations of successful cases. Neither book seeks to provide comprehensive answers for there may be none. Nonetheless, the insights offer an engaging read, connecting the dots in the complex network of issues in new and sometimes unexpected ways.
Stephanie Schwartz's Youth in Post-Conflict Reconstruction addresses an important issue of conflict reoccurrence and recidivism of violence in postconflict societies. Motivated by various individual experiences of youth across postconflict contexts, Schwartz raises two central questions: 1) Can actions be taken in the reconstruction process to break the cycle of violence so that young people choose to remain in civilian society rather that take up arms? 2) If so, what structures can be put in place so that the youth of the world can better contribute to their societies? The reader is taken through an explorative theory-building endeavor of identifying the factors that affect the role of youth in postconflict reconstruction. In a highly commendable methodological setup, three cases with different values on the dependent variable are analyzed and compared: Mozambique (with no reemergence of violence), the Democratic Republic of Congo, or DRC (with violence recidivism), and Kosovo (with mixed outcomes).
Schwartz documents a positive scope for youths' roles in postconflict contexts that can be enhanced by reintegration, education, employment, and empowerment programs, as opposed to humanitarian, psychosocial, or advocacy initiatives. But even the programs with a higher success potential are conditioned on other factors for their effectiveness. For example, reintegration was found to be successful when focused not only on family reunification (as in the DRC) but also on community reintegration through acceptance and reestablishment of youth roles (Mozambique), which, in turn, might involve vocational training or religious practices, as well as conflict resolution workshops and youth voluntary corps (Kosovo).
The success of reconstruction programs hinges on a number of factors. Cooperation and coordination among the actors involved was noted in all three case studies. Cultural and environmental factors, such as the option for emigration in Kosovo or harsh terrain and a culture of impunity in the DRC, are also suggested to affect the ultimate effectiveness of the reconstruction programs. Sequencing of programming is identified as another key condition for success: Education or empowerment of youth must begin after humanitarian programs, peace treaty enforcement, and disarmament and demobilization programs (DDR) have been accomplished. Schwartz shows that while in Mozambique the progression was “especially apparent” and in Kosovo it was followed well, in the DRC the sequence was flawed, with different stages occurring simultaneously: DDR, reintegration, and humanitarian assistance had not been completed when the empowerment stage was launched.
In the author's very accurate words, “the study's value, then, is not in drawing finite conclusions but in identifying future avenues for exploration and development in the field” (p. 25). The book does not aspire to a theory on youths' role in postconflict reconstruction efforts that can be drawn upon following postwar situations of the future. Too many variables are left to consider without guidance on the measurement of concepts that could be comparable across cases. Most case-study sections are presented in a codebook format that lists individual features of a factor, which are often quite generic. If the reader is interested in the cases themselves, then this collection provides a comprehensive body of information, with apparent extensive background research involved. The relative strength of the factors offered is left untested.
The book would have benefited from additional discussion of previous literature on reconstruction and peace building and on its position within it (e.g., Michael Doyle and Nicholas Sambanis, Making War and Building Peace, 2006; Simon Chesterman, You, the People: The United Nations, Transitional Administration, and State-Building, 2004; Roland Paris, At War's End: Building Peace After Civil Conflict, 2004). Only a handful of references to influential studies appear in passing. It would be helpful to account for other factors from this literature by controlling for them, for instance, when designing the case-study analysis.
The current body of knowledge on youths' role in postconflict societies is also more discerning than the book suggests, as can be seen from a contrast with previous literature: For example, a great potential for positive experiences by former young combatants in the postconflict society was found by Christopher Blattman in “From Violence to Voting: War and Political Participation in Uganda” (American Political Science Review 103 [May 2009]: 231–47) and by Neil Boothby in “What Happens When Child Soldiers Grow Up? The Mozambique Case Study” (Intervention 4 [no. 3, 2006]: 244–59), among others.
The second book under review, Myriam Denov's Child Soldiers, delves into the “making” and “unmaking” of child fighters in one of the most notorious instances of the phenomenon's recent manifestation—the Revolutionary United Front (RUF) in Sierra Leone. This work seeks to unpack the militarization and subsequent reintegration process of children in the RUF ranks. The militarization part elaborates on three questions: How are child soldiers “made”? In what ways are the reconfigurations of children's identities as soldiers and members of a military regime realized? How do children become fighters capable of committing acts of brutality? The reintegration part then traces the challenges associated with carving out one's identity and self-concept in the aftermath of war.
Denov's interview narratives form the backbone of the book. Her treatment draws on in-depth interviews of individuals and focus groups from a nonrandom sample of 76 Sierra Leonean children. The reader is immersed in the gruesome reality of young children for whom war atrocities became not only a terrifying experience but also the means to survive. Inevitably, the narratives mirror, to a substantial degree, the accounts of former child soldiers that have been documented elsewhere in the literature. However, one can discern some aspects that are new. For example, an interesting finding is the wide diversity of feelings of belonging to and association with the RUF among the children, ranging from the absence of feeling to a demonstration of a false degree of commitment to genuine attachment and dedication to the RUF.
The underlying theme of the book is formed by the argument that child soldiers do not fall into one of the three benchmark categories as sometimes depicted in the media and nonacademic literature—the dangerous youngsters, the hapless victims, or the heroes—but, rather, fill the whole spectrum among these extremes. For the RUF abductees, the transition from victim to perpetrator was gradual, and the child soldiers drifted continually between the two positions. The same type of drift was experienced in the child soldier's “unmaking.”
In terms of usefulness, Denov's argument has the great untapped potential to be extended to the conflict-studies literature on child soldier recruitment (Jens Christopher Andvig and Scott Gates, “Recruiting Children for Armed Conflict,” in Scott Gates and Simon Reich, eds., Child Soldiers in the Age of Fractured States, 2009; Christopher Blattman, “Causes of Child Soldiering: The Evidence from Northern Uganda,” Working Paper, University of California, Berkeley, 2007) and on coercive mobilization strategies of armed groups (Bernd Beber and Christopher Blattman, “The Industrial Organization of Rebellion: The Logic of Forced Labor and Child Soldiering,” Working Papers, Department of Political Science, Yale University, 2008 and 2010; Kristine Eck, “Recruiting Rebels: Indoctrination and Political Education in Nepal,” in Mahendra Lawoti and Anup Pahari, eds., The Maoist Insurgency in Nepal: Dynamics and Growth in the 21st Century, 2009). Denov's book would have benefited greatly from a discussion of the previous work and from its position within the field, rather than (inaccurately) dismissing it as offering “no attempt at capturing or understanding what occurred to bring children into the fold of violence and armed conflict” (p. 14).
The process of indoctrination discussed in the book brings additional insights to the assumption in child-soldier literature on the intrinsic qualities of children that are sought by armed groups. Children are often depicted as being gullible and easily brought into obedience, hence making them good fighters. Through her extensive investigation of former child soldiers' experiences with the RUF, Denov shows that the situation is more complex. The RUF needed to exert a great deal of effort to elicit the “qualities” they wanted from the young fighters following their abduction. The RUF developed a semiformal ideological system whereby children were made to attend “lectures” by commanders who preached a “working philosophy” of the virtues of overthrowing the corrupt Sierra Leonean government. The RUF also actively fostered internal cohesion by patronage of the older boys over their younger apprentices, role-model playing for new recruits, symbol display such as tattooing, and war song rehearsals.
The unmaking of child soldiers and their reentry into civil society after liberation from the group follows a story of “sweet sorrow” similar to those of some other postconflict situations. The interviewees reported experiencing postconflict disillusionment, finding themselves in the grim world of boredom, poverty, and disenchantment. Depression, drugs, and violent behavior ensued, followed by a sense of powerlessness and frustration. At the same time, there was the prevalent sense of happiness that the war was over.
In this context, the book presents perhaps its most stunning observation drawn on secondary sources: Some success stories of postwar prosperity were built under the command structure forged at war—a social institution that remained intact despite the end of hostilities. In various towns, motorbike taxi companies were founded and owned by former commanders employing their former child soldiers as the taxi drivers. These companies formed unions, taking collective actions that included nonviolent strikes and a lawsuit won against police extortions in the court. This leaves us wondering whether the international community got its current postwar reconstruction efforts quite right. What matters most to people, it seems, is a functioning economy based on sound institutions and infrastructure, not psychosocial programs or high-profile international court cases with former dictators or perpetrators.
Both Youth in Post-Conflict Reconstruction and Child Soldiers fit into the discussion of the design of effective reintegration programs but do not include an analytical framework based on the related academic literature. Since both authors discuss political efficacy and youth empowerment mechanisms, they could draw, for example, on the relevant works by Johanna Söderström on reintegration and political participation of ex-combatants in Liberia. Anders Nilsson, in Dangerous Liaisons: Why Ex-Combatants Return to Violence (2008), actually dismisses structural factors, such as political influence, personal security, or economic assistance, viewed as important in the reintegration process by the books under review. Instead, he focuses on the presence of “remobilizers” (individuals who have the will, capacity, and skills to coordinate organized violence in a postconflict setting) and the existence of their relationship or bonds with former ex-combatants. The discussion of the case of taxi drivers in Denov's book might further engage such arguments, as it represents a positive case for peace building of existing unbroken ties between ex-combatants and commanders.
This debate might propel us further toward a more general discussion in the peace-building literature about the utility of leaving former villains in different levels of governance structures for future peace: Will such a setup backed by democratic free-market institutions lead to the most successful outcome for the society at large?
