Simon Reid-Henry has produced an extremely ambitious and generally quite successful book dealing with the challenges and achievements of Cuba's biotechnology programmes. His main goals, as set forth in a very useful introductory chapter, are, first, to examine how Cuba has been able to develop and, for the most part, to implement successfully a scientific paradigm outside the conventional Western or capitalist R&D model and, second, to explore the implications for philosophies of science, focusing in particular on the geographical dimensions of the enquiry.
The first half of the book is primarily descriptive, concentrating upon ‘telling the story’ of Cuba's emergence as a major player on the global biotechnology scene. Special attention here is devoted to the emergence of the Centre for Genetic Engineering and Biotechnology (CIBG) in Havana as the flagship of Cuba's efforts, noting also that over time the CIBG was augmented by other related research and production facilities which collectively have become known as the Western Havana Scientific Pole.
This narrative, which covers the book's first four chapters, is both extremely informative and extremely important, for it sheds much-needed light on a remarkable record of scientific achievement which has been largely ignored, especially by the mass media, in the more developed nations of the world, where it is widely assumed that a society which does not fit the conventional ‘economically developed country’ mould cannot achieve high levels of scientific sophistication. But Havana, as Reid-Henry demonstrates in these chapters, has not only shattered such pretensions, but has done so by implementing a distinctive Cuban model of scientific development which challenges many of the conventional rules of the game and therefore constitutes the ‘resistance in global science’ mentioned in the author's title.
One minor shortcoming of this material is that it is based mainly on research conducted in 2002, although the author does indicate that some 2006 updates were included. Nevertheless, since the book was published in 2010, and given the rapid changes that can occur in the field, some information about more recent developments would have been useful. For example, the growing importance of the Scientific Pole in particular and the Cuban medical community in general to the country's economic well-being can be illustrated by the fact that in recent years medical services and products have supplanted tourism as the island's main source of foreign income.
The second half of the book analyses the dynamics of Cuba's biotechnological development, the primary concern here being to explore the question of how and why the Cuban endeavour has been able to succeed, while operating for the most part outside, and often in opposition to, the Western liberal free market model which tends to dominate the world of biotechnological R&D. While drawing here upon various academic disciplines such as sociology and the philosophy of science, the author relies upon an analytical paradigm rooted primarily in the field of (cultural) geography to come to the overall conclusion (pp. 167–8) that
if such a specialised epistemology as we have engaged with offers us a way of accounting for the Cuban experience, so too does that experience shed light on the geographical nature of knowledge itself. It tells us, for example, about the articulation of knowledge over space … and how space is remade in the process of epistemic exchanges … New spaces are brought forth and in turn make possible new forms of social activity. When one innovates, one also contributes to social innovations. New scientific facts produce new spaces within which those facts are given meaning, operate, are circulated, and so on … Hence the Cubans' work on cancer revealed the value of a different epistemological structuring of a particular scientific problem in Cuba as compared to elsewhere; it was the product of Cuban scientists producing a particular geography of work as they sought to make innovations in scientific practice and thought.
Overall, Reid-Henry provides a fascinating enquiry into the largely unexplored and important topic of Cuba's emergence as a major player on the global biotechnological and larger medical research/services scene. However, the presentation of this material, both descriptively and especially analytically, within the context of a geographical paradigm may be problematical for some audiences. Indeed, some people will undoubtedly be intimidated by the book's extensive and often unnecessary use of highly discipline-specific jargon. In short, this is not a book for the general reader, which is unfortunate since the topic's importance goes far beyond the realm of the academic specialist.
Some specialists in Cuban affairs (this reviewer included) may have serious qualms about the author's geographic paradigm as the most effective tool for analysing the development and achievements of Cuban biotechnology, preferring, for example, to focus primarily on political and/or ideological considerations as the key mobilisation variables driving the country's emergence as a world-class biotechnological power. However, having noted such reservations, one must in all fairness grant that the author does a very impressive job of constructing and presenting his perspective.
One important element of the Cuban biotechnology story that is largely missing from the book involves the education and training of Cuban medical scientists. In the case of a few individuals the author mentions that they have studied abroad, but no serious attention is devoted to medical and scientific training within the country and how this variable might function to support the unique aspects of Cuba's biotechnological development. There have, for example, been studies of Cuba's public health system which have highlighted the distinct aspects of the educational process that have been instituted for training the country's doctors and other health professionals, especially the heavy emphasis in the curriculum on the servicing of the community's needs rather than the pursuit of individual profit/status as the central pillar of the profession's ethos. Such value-based education has been pivotal in developing the country's highly renowned ability to mobilise its resources to address public health challenges not only at home, but also overseas via its medical aid programmes, which surpass those of any other country or international organisation. It would have been interesting to see whether there are similar educational variables exerting a significant influence on the Cuban biotechnological experience.
Bottom line: despite the book's too-frequent forays into arcane academic jargon, it represents a very important work as the first in-depth study of Cuba's unique biotechnological odyssey.
