It is hard to imagine anyone interested in either Thai politics or Thailand's southern insurgency not familiar with the prodigious output of Duncan McCargo. Mapping national anxieties: Thailand's southern conflict is McCargo's third book on Thailand's deep south. The first, Rethinking Thailand's southern violence (NUS Press, 2007), was an edited volume, the contents of which first appeared as a special edition of Critical Asian Studies in 2006). This was followed by his widely read and well-received monograph, Tearing apart the land: Islam and legitimacy in southern Thailand (Cornell University Press, 2008). Like Rethinking Thailand's southern violence, Mapping national anxieties makes available to a readership without access to library databases or snout to sniff out open-access versions available on the Internet, articles which have appeared in a range of journals between 2006 and 2011. The book's eight chapters are peppered with some stunning shots by Ryan Anson and are followed by two appendices. The first is a short netnography presenting exchanges about southern strife and relations between Thai-Buddhist and Malay-Muslims on a range of Thai bulletin boards, chat rooms, and websites by Thai academic Phrae Sirisakdamloeng (pp. 160–83). These graphically illustrate the Buddhist fears and the presence of a decidedly uncivil Buddhism in Thailand dealt with by McCargo in chapter 2. The second appendix contains a list of McCargo's publications on Thailand's southern conflict, which precedes a bibliography and a most helpful index. The republication of previously published works is not the only element of repetition in Mapping national anxieties. While McCargo honed arguments that the southern insurgency was first and foremost a crisis of political legitimacy in Tearing apart the land, the chapters in this present work consider how the wider crisis in Thai politics has impacted the far south. Readers interact with themes that never made it into Tearing apart the land, and insights written (or compiled) in the wake of the violent end to months of political protest in central Bangkok during 2010. Thailand's southern insurgency and political and civil chaos in Bangkok represent Thailand's twin fires (chapter 8) and national anxieties (chapter 1) that McCargo maps out for his readers. For McCargo, southern insecurity should be conceived as a severest symptom of national disease. Furthermore, as an essentially political problem, political solutions are required. Chapter 2, entitled ‘Buddhist fears’, explores Thai Buddhism's decidedly uncivil dark side. Similar to Michael Jerryson's work on monks in South Thailand in Sacred fury (2008), and contrary to arguments by Charles Keyes and Donald Swearer about civil Buddhism, McCargo describes Buddhists' responses to Muslim violence. Recent intimidation of Muslims seeking to brand halal products in Sri Lanka, and violence against Muslims in Myanmar by Buddhists are, lamentably, far from isolated cases of Theravada Buddhism's uncivil constituency.
Chapter 3, ‘Managing Islam’ also deals with religious issues. In it, details of the political organisation of Islam in Thailand and how Thai authorities have occasionally interfered in these processes are described. Following a treatment of the Pattani Islamic Council and the political career of Malay politician Den Tohmeena, McCargo relates attempts to influence the outcome of the 2005 election of the Council. These revealed a breakdown in relations between the ‘Thai state and Muslim leaders; the subordination of religious issues to partisan political agendas; the commercialisation of the process by which Muslim leaders were selected and the unraveling of an imagined “civil Islam” as previously construed on the basis of Thailand's 1997 process of political reform’ (p. 111). Chapter 4 is concerned with the National Reconciliation Commission (NRC), which was set up by former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra (2001–6) and met together and wrote its report between 2005 and 2006. In addition to dissecting the deficiencies of what he evaluates as a deeply flawed response to the southern conflict initiated by Thaksin before his inauspicious exit and exile following the 2006 coup, McCargo reprises his analysis of ‘network monarchy’ in which the chair of the NRC, former prime minister Anand Panyarachun, plays a leading role. Issues concerned with how, and by whom, the southern conflict has been communicated in Thailand are dealt with in chapter 5. Once more, McCargo brings his knowledge of the idiosyncrasies of Thai print media into dialogue with incidents he personally observed during his 12-month stint of fieldwork in Pattani between 2005 and 2006, specifically the Tanyonglimo incident and the establishment of Issara News. The author's discussion of citizenship, ‘Contested citizenship’ in chapter 6 blows a refreshing burst of fresh air into discussions of identity. McCargo frames this as an issue of interest to many anthropologists working in Thailand's south, which has a fascinating Malay borderscape in terms of citizenship. He compares the ‘Thai deficiency syndrome’ which Kasian Tejapira has described Thai Chinese to have historically suffered from, with the ‘graduated citizenship’ of southern Malays. In chapter 7, ‘Autonomous futures’, McCargo assumes the persona of an advocate. What are the alternatives to the present political structures that limp with a lack of legitimacy? While talk of this kind was once tantamount to ‘thinking the unthinkable’, McCargo articulates both the necessity of some form of limited autonomy in the far south, and tables proposals about what form this might take, specifically Monthon Pattani, Nakorn Pattani, or the Ministry for the South. In conclusion, while an engagement with perspectives provided by historians, anthropologists, and Islamic studies specialists should also be consulted by anyone with a serious interest in making sense of present-day South Thailand, the range of insights on Thai politics reproduced by McCargo in Mapping national anxieties provide pieces of the puzzle.
