Negotiating performance within contexts of reality can be a difficult task. Scholarly attempts to do so are often confounded by issues of authorship, mimicry, and editorializing, problems that plagued many early endeavors to grasp the significance of documentary theatre. Following the lead of Carol Martin's Theatre of the Real (2012), Ulrike Garde and Meg Mumford's new book aims to change the conversation. They argue that instead of assessing the veracity of a performance's truth claims, one should interrogate the productive impact that a performance's relationship with truth may have on audiences.
In Theatre of Real People, Garde and Mumford explore a style of performance that bridges the worlds of reality and theatrical artifice, primarily by placing these “real people” (generally individuals with little to no theatre experience) in theatrical settings and encouraging intimate encounters between them and the audience. The authors expertly navigate the intricate melding of these two worlds, as exemplified through their case studies of various productions staged by the Hebbel am Ufer (HAU) under the leadership of artistic director and manager Matthias Lilienthal from 2003 to 2012. Early on, Garde and Mumford establish the theoretical framework of Authenticity-Effects, which they define as “both the artistic strategies that generate and/or destabilize a sense of contact with the sincere, truthful, unmediated, and intimate, and as the perceptual experiences arising from such techniques and representations” (23). Authenticity-Effects become the lens through which the authors interrogate the Theatre of Real People, arguing that this destabilization of reality has the potential to encourage audiences to confront “the complex, contradictory, and unexpected nature of individuals and social reality” (201), and to reexamine their unique perceptions of diverse Others in an increasingly multicultural world.
Chapter 1 provides a historical overview of Theatre of Real People with a focus on the “third wave” (35) of this performance style (since the fall of the Berlin Wall), which has explored identity, social inequality, and the instability of archives in a post-Baudrillardian world. Chapter 2 summarizes the reality-infused work of the HAU under Lilienthal, providing an early look at the theatre pieces the authors explore in depth in Chapters 5–8. Garde and Mumford also trace the ways in which the HAU and Lilienthal innovated the documentary form, arguing that “[t]hey no longer pursued the position of moral leaders who would guide audiences in their responses to current (and very recent) issues, offering instead multiple points of view by casting a range of experts on a given topic” (66–7).
Chapters 3 and 4 organize the theoretical arguments of the book, first with regard to the authors’ incorporation of Authenticity-Effects as a means of examining performances of the real, and then in an exploration of the ways that the HAU has incorporated this tactic to confront diversity in an age of intense xenophobia, Islamophobia, and racial discrimination. In the former chapter, Garde and Mumford masterfully incorporate Hans-Thies Lehmann's notion of “‘an aesthetics of indecidability’” (79; emphasis in original), arguing that it is the very instability and oscillation between categories of reality and performance in HAU's Theatre of Real People that prompt the audience to reassess their internal realities and the constructs of reality presented before them. Innovatively, the authors argue for a skeptical approach to Authenticity-Effects, claiming that “the uncertainty can produce something like the ambiguity and openness of meaning, the incompleteness of understanding and of proximity that characterize encounters with people and their worlds, particularly culturally diverse people” (79).
After the first four chapters lay the exhaustive groundwork for their arguments, Garde and Mumford are most persuasive in their case-study chapters (5–8), which use production analyses of various performances by the HAU alongside anecdotal evidence from audience members. Chapter 5 explores 100% Berlin and the offshoot production, 100% Melbourne, panoramic performance pieces that recruited participants through a “statistical chain reaction” (107) and that attempted to reflect the diversity of these cities onstage through 100-person casts. Yet the labor of creating a statistically representative cast of diverse identities paradoxically erased their respective individuality, minimizing the onstage people to mere numbers and symbols. Chapter 6 focuses on the X-Apartments series, where audiences would be led on tours around Berlin's neighborhoods and then enter people's apartments for short performances. The blurred boundaries of public and private spaces (as well as quotidian and theatrical spaces) created an instability in the audience's experience of Authenticity-Effects, which Garde and Mumford claim “invited the audience to ask whether they are witnessing ‘everyday life portrayals of self that have been put in a theatre frame, or heightened performances of self lifted from everyday life’” (127).
I was most intrigued by Chapter 7 and its description of Call Cutta: Mobile Phone Theatre, in which each audience member was paired with an associate at a call center in India, who would, via cell phone, serve as their sole performer and tour guide through the streets of Berlin. Blending authentic conversations with scripted interjections and route instructions, these performers created real—if ephemeral—relationships with the audience members, as they took the hourlong journey together. Finally, Chapter 8 navigates the HAU's productions of Blackmarket No. 7 and Mr. Dağaçar and the Golden Tectonics of Trash, both of which have been used to tackle audience's perceptions of Berlin's immigrants. Drawing on Sara Ahmed's postcolonial critiques, the authors attest that by being allowed only partial proximity to the subjects in these pieces, the audiences were forced to confront “the ethical and educational value of creating perceptual distance and acknowledging cultural difference during encounters with the unfamiliar” (184).
With this book, Garde and Mumford notably advance the study of Theatre of the Real and of the performer in documentary theatre. While they may have been better served delving into their case studies earlier—the first half of the book can get repetitive in the authors’ attentiveness to structuring and reiterating their argument—the notion of a skeptical approach to Authenticity-Effects and the impact that this can have on willing audiences is a thrilling step forward in the field and one that can have a wide impact among both scholars and theatre practitioners.
