This recent book offers an impressive level of detail about the history of the Campaign for Homosexual Equality (the ‘CHE’) from its roots in 1954 through to 1973. Written by journalist and playwright Peter Scott-Presland (who applied for the commission after Jeffrey Weeks turned it down), it fulfils the mission of being an ‘official’ history. Scott-Presland's quirky dramatist's approach is an ongoing source of engagement and indeed humour throughout. This volume will be of interest to those involved in the CHE itself, scholars and those with an interest in the history of this important postwar organisation that campaigned for law reform through a prism of equality, but also performed many other functions, some of which I explore below.
Scott-Presland observes, importantly, that ‘the neglect of CHE in the annals of LGBT history so far is nothing short of scandalous’ (p. xv). He paints a different picture from the reputation the CHE has acquired (through ignorance) of being made up of ‘middle-aged and middle-class closeted white men with a cautious, even reactionary approach to societal change’ (p. xv). The book has a foreword by Paul O'Grady, a member of the Liverpool CHE in the early 1970s, who recalls the regular deployment at meetings of the all-important word: equality. Many years on that is a word and concept that is not without its detractors, as noted below. Volume II, which will deal inter alia with relations with the Gay Liberation Front (the ‘GLF’) in more detail, will follow in due course.
Through a mixture of in-depth interviews with leading figures in the organisation and archival and library-based research, Scott-Presland has produced an extremely detailed ‘official history’, which he considered needed to be all-inclusive. In his preface he states that he writes ‘out of the insecurity of not being a “proper” historian, queer theorist, or indeed any kind of academic’ (p. xv), yet my argument in this review is that he performs an important task, and the book will be invaluable to academics and others alike, who may build on this scrupulously inclusive history. As he says, ‘I would defend the history of small things in that the tiniest detail can either shift a conventional perspective, or fill out a picture’ (p. xvii).
‘Amiable warriors is emphatically not a work of Queer studies’ (p. xviii), an academic pursuit that receives short shrift in the book. Scott-Presland paints a rich and detailed picture of the CHE's development into the 1970s. The book ends with a detailed ‘Timeline of events’, which tabulates key (‘gay’) developments in the CHEFootnote 1 in parallel to those in the UK and the rest of the world, as well as other significant contemporaneous events in the news and also in the arts. The parallels drawn in terms of events are striking in places. One issue highlighted in the timeline of events, as well as in the earlier chapters of the book, is the number of high-profile criminal trials of ‘homosexual men’ and the ‘fear that homosexuals were security risks, since they were likely to be blackmailed’ (p. 46). The concern that homosexuals were such security risks was one driver for the setting up of the Wolfenden Enquiry.Footnote 2
As Scott-Presland notes early on, both the CHE and the GLF had an important role to play in educating the public and moving the cause of homosexual ‘equality’ forwards in Great Britain.Footnote 3 This volume, however, concentrates on the grass-roots approach of the CHE to achieving equality. What was unique about the CHE was its organic growth and relatively flat hierarchy. A child of the collectivism of the north-west, specifically the Labour movement in Manchester, the NWHLRC, which became the CHE, was set up 1964 as a small law-reform committee.Footnote 4 Various local groups emerged in time, and it blossomed into a nationwide grass-roots campaign, with 150 ‘local groups from Cornwall to Tyneside’ (p. 8). What is fascinating are the many and varied ways in which the groups influenced public opinion. Scott-Presland's argument is that small-scale capillary influence and change in attitudes was brought about by the presence of CHE groups across the country.
The ‘book concentrates on the micro level of the local groups. It is above all concerned with the process of creating elbow room for homosexuals’ (p. xxi), and goes into great detail describing how the members of the local groups formed friendships, developed personal confidence and went out into the world ‘as ourselves, and not as ersatz heterosexuals’ (p. xxi). The challenge of even getting advertisements in local papers is just one of the insights into the very real difficulties that faced the CHE (p. 265). They did succeed in promoting themselves, however, so membership slowly grew, and a strong social element to the CHE developed. Thus there was also a ‘networking’ aspect to the CHE – simply put, it was a place to meet other people of the same persuasion. Nor should it be thought that this aspect was limited to men: women made up a significant minority – some 20 per cent – of the active members right through until the early 1980s.
At a time of reflection on what achieving equality might signify (Leckey, Reference Leckey2015; Barker and Monk, Reference Barker and Monk2015) and a further breakthrough in the US in the form of the recent Supreme Court decision on gay marriage,Footnote 5 it is pertinent to look back at an organisation that was at the forefront of the equality movement in the UK. Scott-Presland remarks early on that the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the General Assembly in December 1948, laid down a ‘significant marker’ as regards homosexuality, noting Article 7 amongst others, that provided for equality before the law and protection from discrimination (p. 22). From the late 1940s, the concept of applying human rights discourse to homosexuals developed, particularly in the US. That is not to say that it was a major driver in the UK as regards law reform, at least early on. Rather, an examination of the Wolfenden Report reveals a limited approach to the ‘proper ambit of the criminal law’ (see Cretney, Reference Cretney2006, pp. 7–9), not the emancipation of a long discriminated against constituency.
The HLRS had had very real difficulties in persuading the Labour Party to put the issue of law reform (in the late 1950s and early 1960s, following the Wolfenden Report) on the political agenda within the party, which in time was a driver for the ‘idea that reform could only come as a result of local homosexuals organizing themselves to lobby local [Labour] party associations’ (p. 99). So the NWHLRC emerged a few years later, with its working-class roots. Class, more generally, is an important theme that emerges from the book, and is pertinent today, tying into contemporary debates about who is set to benefit from same-sex marriage – some can be worse off financially, in particular working-class women (see Barker, Reference Barker2013; Reference Barker2015; Auchmuty, Reference Auchmuty, Munro and Stychin2007), and the predominance of white middle-class men taking up the opportunity is critiqued by Joshi (Reference Joshi2012). In the heyday of the CHE in the 1970s, it might have been difficult to imagine that legal recognition of same-sex relationships, a form of equality, might be considered a mixed blessing so many years on, as equality was precisely what they were fighting for.
Interactions with the GLF provide an insight into the realities of the time. The GLF and the CHE are often considered to be ‘radically different’ and at odds with each other. What the book demonstrates is that facilitating reform required a number of approaches.Footnote 6 There was attendance at each other's meetings and initiatives to co-operate. The CHE's liberalism is demonstrated by its inviting the GLF and other groups to share its media time on Radio London, on a programme called ‘Platform’ in 1972. What this book begins to challenge is the idea that the CHE can neatly be classified as a ‘gay rights’ movement, with the GLF as a radical queer movement that sought to go beyond assimilation (Jeffreys, Reference Jeffreys2003). Ferguson has recently argued that the ‘gay rights’ movement (in the US):
‘relies on a certain telling of the civil rights movement … they [gay rights] do so by constructing the state as the domain of resolution and by promoting rights based practices as the raison d’être for political agency, making rights the point of political action and political transformation … Yet, by seeing rights as the end of politics, the gay rights movement also erases the histories of how anti-racist and queer movements mobilised sexuality, gender and race to challenge and move beyond the logics and practices of the state.’ (Reference Ferguson and Leckey2015, p. 151)
This book makes such a stance difficult to maintain, at least in the UK context. What the book avoids is any particular (historiographical, to quote Ferguson)Footnote 7 reading of the past: rather its honest and relentless detail resists the GLF/CHE binary described above. Volume II of Amiable Warriors will offer more detail on the relationship between the organisations, providing the opportunity to consider the blurring of the lines between them as well as their relationship with the state and law reform, in a period where the institution of marriage, into which homosexuals were to be eventually assimilated, had itself changed.Footnote 8
Whilst the author doesn't seek to be analytical in his style, the depth of archival and interview material, presented in an easily readable fashion with humour regularly interspersed, is a significant contribution to the history of homosexual emancipation. Others will surely draw on the text to research the area further. Two further volumes are in train and are to be awaited with anticipation.
