In the early fifth century, Epiphanius, the metropolitan bishop of Cyprus, travelled to Constantinople on the prompting of Theophilus of Alexandria. Once there, he began interfering in clerical ordinations, attempted to get other bishops to condemn the long-dead theologian Origen and entered into a vicious disagreement with John Chrysostom, bishop of the imperial city. When Epiphanius was preparing to return home in the spring of 403, he expressed the wish that John would not die as a bishop; John reciprocated by stating that he hoped Epiphanius would never reach Cyprus alive. Both men were proven correct, since John was deposed and sent into exile, while Epiphanius died on the voyage back.
This version of events, told by Socrates in his Ecclesiastical History (6.12, 14), accords well with the standard modern view of Epiphanius as an intransigent heresy-hunter and controversialist who railed vehemently against more intelligent individuals. He is not well known; even among those who do know him, he is not well liked. As the three books reviewed here all remark, it is easy to collect a plethora of scholarly judgements criticising Epiphanius for his invective, arrogance, stupidity and dishonesty (Kim, 1–5; Berzon, 15; Jacobs, 1–4). This reputation is based in large part on his longest surviving work, the Panarion, a voluminous heresiology often mined by historians and theologians for information about heretics and quotations from their writings. In the course of refuting eighty different sects, Epiphanius provided tendentious accounts of their actions and beliefs, quite possibly inventing details, and even entire heretical groups, to support his arguments. In particular, it is his damning description of Origen's life and beliefs, together with his campaign to persuade others to accept this interpretation, that has aroused the most interest, and criticism, in modern scholarship.
Nonetheless, like other previously disdained forms of late antique literature, such as poetry and panegyric, Epiphanius’ heresiology has begun to receive more detailed and less judgemental attention, including being translated into English in its entirety for the first time by Frank Williams. Epiphanius’ Ancoratus, a shorter treatise completed just before the Panarion, has also recently been translated by Young Richard Kim. These gradual developments have now resulted in these three substantial and significant monographs, two of which, by Kim and Jacobs, focus on Epiphanius himself, while the third, by Berzon, is a broader exploration of late antique heresiology, but with a focus on the Panarion.
Moreover, all three authors argue for an end to the marginalisation of Epiphanius and his works not only in modern scholarship but, more significantly, in our conception of Late Antiquity itself. J., who makes a reconsideration of the period and its identity the central thesis of his book, states that ‘we should recognize that he speaks more representatively of his time and place than he is given credit for’ (5). Similarly, B. seeks to address a scholarly disregard for heresiologies, arguing that these forms of writing, while distasteful to many modern eyes, ‘constructed the boundaries of late antique Christianity itself’ (8). K. is less concerned with reshaping the era than with restoring the bishop to his rightful place within it, but nonetheless opens his work with the declaration that ‘Epiphanius of Cyprus was late antiquity’ (1). Despite these differences in emphasis, these three volumes are united in observing that Epiphanius’ prominence among his contemporaries should be matched in our own accounts of his time.
K.’s scholarly volume takes the recognisable form of a biography, drawing mostly on the Panarion, which contains a number of autobiographical episodes, including Epiphanius’ youthful encounter with Gnostics, his opposition to a heretic called Peter and his attempt to root out Apollinarianism at Antioch. Attention is therefore shifted from heretics to heresiologist: ‘Rather than mine the Panarion as a source of information on the beliefs and practices of others, this study examines it as a window into the man himself’ (7). The odd-numbered chapters proceed chronologically through his life, reconstructing his education in Egypt, his foundation of a monastery in Palestine, the first decade of his tenure as bishop of Cyprus, and finally his later life, including his conflict with John Chrysostom. The last of these covers the twenty-five years after the completion of the Panarion and therefore draws substantially on other ancient authors, especially Jerome, Socrates and Sozomen, while also briefly mentioning Epiphanius’ two surviving shorter treatises, known as On Weights and Measures and On the Twelve Stones.
Interleaved with these biographical segments are three important chapters exploring aspects of the Panarion itself and Epiphanius’ self-presentation within it: the first provides an incisive reading of the earliest chapters of the Panarion, which trace man's decline from the Garden of Eden and the concomitant birth of heresy. Here K. uses comparisons with ancient chronographies to show how Epiphanius argued that ‘the Panarion, a quintessential heresiology, was also a work of history’ (80) and thus promoted his own expertise. Ch. 4 traces Epiphanius’ moves to position himself as an heir to Athanasius of Alexandria and his development from a one-hypostasis to a three-hypostasis Trinitarian theology, contextualised within this broader shift among fourth-century Nicene Christians. Ch. 6 then explores Epiphanius’ notorious comparisons between heretics and different dangerous and venomous animals, especially snakes, and thus his own claim to be able to counteract their poisons: ‘Like a spiritual pharmacist, Epiphanius prepared the scriptural ingredients for the remedies needed to cure the maladies of heresy’ (201). This chapter, which echoes the work of Rebecca Lyman, seeks to draw a rather stark dichotomy between ‘imbalance’ and ‘invasion’ theories of disease in the ancient world, but is nonetheless a thorough discussion of this fascinating aspect of the text. Moreover, K. is the only one of these three scholars to acknowledge the fundamental uncertainty and insecurity of Epiphanius’ position in writing the Nicene Panarion under the ‘Semi-Arian’ emperor Valens (173–4).
Despite the presence of ‘biography’ in J.’s subtitle, he employs a very different approach to K., focusing much less on the bishop himself and more on various aspects of Late Antiquity that his life, work and reputation might be said to exemplify, together with a range of conceptual approaches to them. These form the structure of this insightful book, and, while the Panarion does still feature prominently, there is a notable emphasis both on Epiphanius’ other works and also on writings about him. The latter category is not so much analysed to understand his life as to glimpse how he was used by others for their own literary purposes. Ch. 1 therefore eschews as fruitless any attempt to understand the sources of his ‘power’ and ‘authority’ and instead invokes the notion of ‘celebrity’ to move ‘our emphasis away from cause to effect’ (32). J. thus provides a compelling survey of how late antique authors found Epiphanius good to think with, particularly for the difficult issues of the proper ecclesiastical relationship with imperial power, the place of paideia in Christian life and the practice of asceticism. This is balanced, at the other end of the book, by a chapter on the afterlife of the bishop as saint in the fifth-century Vita Epiphanii and a nineteenth-century novella by an Anglo-Catholic named Thomas Wimberley Mossman. Once again, contemporary concerns loom large in these works, especially in their articulation of the relationship between ‘clerical’ and ‘secular’ power, and also the myth of Epiphanius’ Jewish origins.
Ch. 2 explores ‘conversion’ in a number of Epiphanius’ writings and argues convincingly that a concern with the policing of boundaries extends beyond the Panarion and mirrors Roman attitudes towards the frontiers of empire. The following chapter uses the concept of ‘improvisation’ to interpret moments when Epiphanius acted with apparent spontaneity to resolve situations to his advantage and uphold the institutions of the Church while not necessarily adhering scrupulously to their rules and procedures. J. uses this to challenge a supposed perception of late antique Christianity as a ‘totalizing discourse’, which tends ‘to emphasise limit and constraint over fluidity and flexibility’ (107). Although J. does acknowledge that Epiphanius was far from alone in acting in this manner, the fact that similar behaviour is well attested in other bishops more commonly regarded as ‘mainstream’ to Late Antiquity, such as Ambrose of Milan or Athanasius of Alexandria, should also be taken into account.
Ch. 4, entitled ‘Scripture’, concerns Epiphanius’ attitude towards knowledge and his ‘antiquarian’ tendencies, such as including large quantities of apparently superfluous information in his works. This is a wide-ranging exploration not only of the Panarion, but also of the Ancoratus, On Weights and Measures and On the Twelve Stones, examining the intertwining of ‘biblical’ and ‘classical’ material so that ‘Christian culture is built out of individual bits of knowledge, harnessed and brought together in totalized order’ (173). This is an impressive piece of scholarship, although it could have benefited from greater differentiation of Epiphanius’ writings and their individual purposes. J. also seems to use the term ‘antiquarian’ interchangeably with ‘compilatory’ and ‘encyclopedic’ to describe the works of a broad sweep of ancient authors, including Aulus Gellius, John Lydus, Pliny the Elder and Frontinus, despite significant differences in their form, methodology and rhetoric. Ch. 5 then considers Epiphanius’ theology, emphasising that his theory of salvation was rooted in the body and arguing that it was ‘a discourse of morality, rather than one of metaphysics’ (180). Like K.’s chapter on this subject, J. also builds on the work of Oliver Kösters in an attempt to rescue Epiphanius from his reputation as an insignificant theologian.
For B., by contrast, the theology of Epiphanius is less of a concern than his intellectual methods for assessing and classifying the world. In particular, B. argues that early Christian heresiologists had much in common with ethnographers, both in the Roman world and also in the Victorian period, in their labelling and organisation of groups of people according to their own cultural norms. This association with imperial attitudes might suggest the notion of ‘totalizing discourse’, most famously used by Averil Cameron, which the other two authors both invoke to describe Epiphanius’ texts (‘a sense of totalizing command of knowledge’ (K., 80); ‘a potentially endless display of totalizing knowledge’ (J., 153)). B. differs markedly from them, however, in arguing that such rhetoric was always undercut by an acknowledgement of the task's impossibility: ‘In expressing the discourse of totalization as aspirational rather than realized, the heresiologists emphasized their labor as collectors over and above their ability to find and enumerate a comprehensive whole of heresy … Heresiologies were not texts of control and totalization but catalogues marked by vulnerability, hazard, and fissure’ (10). Supported by significant explicit discussion of theoretical approaches, B. explores this notion across a number of texts, most notably Epiphanius’ Panarion and Augustine's De haeresibus, but also the Refutatio omnium haeresium (sometimes attributed to Hippolytus), Theodoret of Cyrrhus’ Haereticarum fabularum compendium and Tertullian's De praescriptione haereticorum. This allows for some excellent sustained analysis of the common practices of heresiology, although it would have been fascinating to have seen whether these conclusions might have been different if Filastrius of Brescia’s Diuersarum hereseon liber and the anonymous Praedestinatus had been included as well.
Each chapter explores a different aspect of this ‘ethnographic’ approach to heresies, not always discussing every heresiology, but advancing via a series of interesting close readings. After an opening section comparing these texts to classical ethnographies, ch. 2 examines the importance of naming for creating distinct and coherent heretical groups, as well as the foregrounding of habits and customs in their definition. This is followed by a convincing chapter focused on the Refutatio omnium haeresium and its attacks on heretics who supposedly imported astrology and pagan myth into Christianity, explaining how its author argued for the primacy of his own religion and so ‘transformed the history of the world into a history of Christianity’ (126).
This exploration of heresiology as history continues in ch. 4, where the concept of universal history in Epiphanius and Theodoret is examined. This is another impressive discussion, although the interpretation of the complicated nature of the earliest ‘heresies’ in the Panarion is not as sophisticated as K.’s chapter on this topic, perhaps due to the absence of some important pertinent scholarship by Pierre Fraenkel, Elias Moutsoulas and Calogero Riggi. Some of B.’s observations about how heresiologists gathered, assessed and ordered knowledge also find parallels in other forms of ancient writing, such as accounts of philosophical, sophistic and medical ‘sects’, as Kendra Eshleman has previously argued, suggesting that these phenomena were not confined to ethnography.
The following chapters explore the problems and limits of heresiological writings, opening with an illuminating discussion of the tensions felt by their authors regarding the perils of excessive enquiry into such dangerous subject matter, including tales of theologians who fell into heresy through their unrestrained inquisitiveness. The final two chapters form a pair, looking at how Epiphanius and Augustine, like earlier ethnographers ‘expounded upon their inability to organize the world and describe the peoples, places, and things within it’ and so ‘articulated a rhetoric of expansion that confronted its own inadequacies’ (187–8). This argument is constructed through consideration of some passages from Pliny, Strabo and Pomponius Mela, before proceeding into close analysis of the two heresiologists, especially the final section of the Panarion, known as the De fide, and Augustine's reflections in the epilogue to his De haeresibus.
It is undoubtedly correct that Augustine acknowledged the impossibility of completing the process of heresiological enquiry, but B.’s argument is less convincing for Epiphanius, where it is based on the bishop's exegesis of Song of Songs 6:8–9. The biblical description of eighty ‘concubines’ and ‘young women without number’ is taken by Epiphanius as a reference to the eighty heresies that he catalogues, together with ‘the remaining philosophies and different ways of life across the whole world, some praiseworthy, some not’ (De fide 9.1). B. takes this to be an acceptance that the eighty chapters of the Panarion encompass ‘only a small portion of the total volume of known heresies’ (206), but in fact Epiphanius draws a distinction between the ‘concubines’ — the ‘heresies’ in his catalogue which are associated with the Word, albeit illegitimately — and the ‘young women’, who symbolise the innumerable other ways of thinking and behaving that are external to his understanding of orthodoxy and heresy, thereby presenting his own heresiological project as complete. This interpretation may be partly due to B.’s quotation of Williams’ translation of the Panarion throughout his book, since this includes the word ‘sect’ in De fide on a number of occasions when αἵρεσις does not appear in the Greek. This does not detract from B.’s excellent reading of Augustine, but it cautions us of the importance of taking each text on its own terms and not seeking to overgeneralise about a whole ‘genre’.
Taken together, these three volumes reveal the richness of ancient heresiology and the vital need to reintegrate it not only into Late Antiquity, but also into our understanding of the late antique reworking of classical literary forms. J.’s desire to place Epiphanius at the centre of our understanding of this period might be deemed excessive, despite his notoriety at the time, but that also reflects the ongoing debate about the nature of Late Antiquity and the degree to which religious transformation should be seen as its dominant, defining theme. Rather, this trio of ground-breaking studies simultaneously brings Epiphanius into the light and reminds us of the drawbacks of canonising particular authors or characters as representative of an age: no one figure, or small group of figures, deserves to be at the heart of Late Antiquity, but Epiphanius can no longer remain relegated to its margins.
