The role of the revolutionary Marxist left in the 1979 Iranian revolution has been a subject of controversy for the past thirty-one years. Some have supported an urban myth that the left played a pivotal role in the revolution that brought the Islamists to power, while others have argued that although the left played a role in the antishah struggle, it was far from a pivotal one. Numerous scholarly studies have attempted to address this controversy, and the book under review is the latest addition to the literature. By focusing on the largest revolutionary Marxist guerrilla organization, the author attempts not only to document the history of the Organization of Iranian People's Fadaʾi Guerrillas (henceforth Fadaiyan) prior to the revolution but also to examine the contributions and shortcomings of its key theorists and, perhaps most important of all, the relevance of their ideas in a post-Marxist-revolutionary age.
The book consists of eight chapters, but its overall structure can be viewed as constituting three sections. The first two chapters, comprising a general historical background of Iran with a focus on leftist movements from the 1953 coup up to the late 1960s and a history of the Fadaiyan in the 1970s, constitute the first section. Here the author has utilized a large body of the available primary and secondary sources as well as a collection of interviews with personalities who worked closely with the Fadaiyan or who were members of the group in the 1970s. The interviews the author managed to conduct, undoubtedly through much time and effort, are the most important addition to the source base of previous works on the subject. The importance of the interviews is mainly due to the reluctance of many former and current militant activists to go on record about their activities or record them on their own. The chapter on the history of the Fadaiyan is a meticulous documentation of events, personalities, and challenges that the organization faced, along with its internal dynamics. This chapter, however, misses an opportunity to set the issue of the internal purges of the Fadaiyan in the 1970s straight. The author could have also discussed the theoretical context in which the line between security concerns and political differences was blurred, leading to the assassination of a number of cadres. This tendency was a Stalinist practice established well before many Fadaiyan cadres were even born. The assassination of Abdollah Panjehshahi in 1976, about which the Fadaiyan had kept silent for years, is a good case in point. Despite the fact that explanations of this assassination remain inadequate and contradictory, the author seems to accept those given by his interviewees at face value.
Chapters 3 through 7 can be viewed as constituting the second section of the book because they represent the author's impression of key Fadaiyan theorists as well as his analysis of theoretical differences between the Fadaiyan and other militant organizations. The author attempts to deconstruct the main elements of the theories put forth by the Fadaiyan theorists in order to show the differences between them as well as their relevance for a future generation. The book relies here on major available primary sources and does a good job at “deconstruction.” Although the contributions of these theorists have been studied before, the author's approach in trying to find contemporary relevance is both innovative and intriguing.
The last two chapters, constituting what can be viewed as the final section, are basically the author's reflections on the project and his endeavor to bring all of the important conclusions and observations into a holistic overview.
The book is a most welcome addition to the study of the Marxist left in 20th-century Iran. The left undoubtedly played an important role in Iran's recent history, and the Fadaiyan was a generation's response to the challenges of liberation movements, secularism, and democracy. The author does a fine job in both recording and putting in perspective the Fadaiyan, the most important and largest of the guerrilla organizations in Iran. The book would appeal to those interested in Iran's 20th-century history and the history of communist movements in Iran. It would also be suitable for graduate courses on the intellectual history of the 20th-century Middle East. Since the Iranian Revolution, much attention has been paid to religious thinkers and their activities. This book brings leftist intellectual revolutionary thinkers to the forefront and as such would fit well in any course on modern Iran.
